Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutAgenda Report - March 15, 2023 C-09CITY OF ,Q4 ft zt� D CALIFORNIA AGENDA ITEM C40q COUNCIL COMMUNICATION AGENDA TITLE: Adopt Resolution Authorizing the City Manager to Execute a Fee Payment Agreement for 302 North Sacramento Street (Lodi Bowling Alley) MEETING DATE: March 15, 2023 PREPARED BY: Public Works Director RECOMMENDED ACTION: Adopt resolution authorizing City Manager to execute a Fee Payment Agreement for 302 North Sacramento Street (Lodi Bowling Alley). BACKGROUND INFORMATION: Elite Management Company, Inc. (Owner) has submitted a building permit application (No. 20182145) to construct a two-story bowling alley equipped with a bar and banquet room on the property known as 302 North Sacramento Street (shown in Exhibit A). The project included the installation of public improvements on Sacramento Street and Lockeford Street which were accepted by Council on August 19, 2020. Payment of Development Impact Mitigation (DIM) Fees ($219,913.13) is required as part of the building permit conditions. The Owner requested to enter into a Fee Payment Agreement on December 20, 2022, with the City to allow payment of the DIM fees in twenty (20) equal semi-annual installments ($12,853.24) plus interest over a ten-year period. Interest would be charged at the current Local Agency Investment Fund (LAIF) rate plus one percent (3.07%). The City Manager currently has authority to approve Fee Payment Agreements having a term of seven years or less and up to $50,000. Since the requested term is ten years and the fees due are more than $50,000, Council approval of the agreement is required. The letter requesting the fee payment agreement (attached as Exhibit B) explains that the project can provide substantial economic benefit to the Lodi Community and that there is a significant financial need to defer the fee payment. Staff concurs with this request since having a new bowling alley will provide additional revenues and other long-term economic benefits to the City. Staff therefore is recommending the City Council to authorize the City Manager to execute the Fee Payment Agreement for 302 North Sacramento Street (Lodi Bowling Alley). FISCAL IMPACT: While this Council action has no impact, the approved Fee Payment Agreement would allow for the successful completion of the bowling alley, which will provide new revenues to the City. FUNDING AVAILABLE: Not Applicable. _Mouo Charles E. Swimley, Jr. Public Works Director Prepared by Karissa Kiriu, Associate Civil Engineer CES/KTVK/cd Attachment cc: City Attorney, Magdich Deputy Public Works Director/City Engineer, Chang Associate Civil Engineer, Kiriu Junior Engineer, Wiman Elite Management Company, Inc., Owner APPROVED: 6� Stephen Schwabauer, City Manager \\cvcfilv02\pu bwks$\WP\DEV_SE RV\Developments\C om mercial- Indust rial\Sacramento 302 N Lodi Bowling\Fee Payment Agreement\CC_Lodi Bowling Alley doc 2/23/2023 T 1� ra 419 417 412 415 405 O 408 407 Li 403 1) 1-7 .� 461 o (N N � � r � Do ForcaAv, 325 322 s 320 317 +� 6 321 3;4 311 312 O O 30 � flj 302 c7 rq N w. r CD LCr C3 ock8ford St 0 22G L 214 295 212 2;o IISeI llY�' ' L A -P V. , H,d: r 121Q Keill,'!`T ri Ln fen 3 Ham y Ln. 711 31s) S15 49 0) Lockeford St f2242yg r-- Legend ❑ Parcel Outline SOFTBALL ; City Limits Landmarks tj STADIUM n ARCH THEATRE CITYBUILDINGS TRAIN M1 CITYHALL Railroads ,� COURT Waterbodies DOGPARK Street Names FIRESTATIONS ❑ Basins Map Scale Notes 302 North Sacramento Street Lodi Bowling Alley 1:2,257 376 0 188 376 Feet W GS_1984_Web_Mercator_Auxi liary_Sph e re © City of Lodi Geographic Information Systems This map is a user generated static output from an Internet mapping site and is for reference only. Data layers that appear on this map may or may not be accurate, current, or otherwise reliable. THIS MAP IS NOT TO BE USED FOR NAVIGATION Elite Management Company Inc. P.O. Box 1673 Woodbridge, CA 95258 December 20, 2022 By Email Only: pwdept@lodi.gov City of Lodi P.O. Box 3006 Lodi, CA 95241-1910 Re: 302 North Sacramento Street 6wling Alley) Fee Payment Agreement Request Dear Sir or Madam: This letter is in response to your letter dated December 1St and addresses the questions required in order for us to receive a 'Fee Payment Agreement". Question 1. Bowling is an entertainment industry that for the last 20 years has not been catered to in Lodi California. Lodi Bowling will bring not only a Bowling venue, but a restaurant, a party hall and an innovative alley design that is both modern and elegant. We will be offering a truly unique atmosphere attracting after-school kids looking for entertainment and a snack, families with young children seeking inexpensive entertainment, seniors looking for fun activities, and local bowlers seeking league competition in their own neighborhoods. Lodi Bowling is being constructed in a prime downtown location. It is approximately 44k sq ft, 1 3/4acre. The City of Lodi provided incentive to us to bring this alley to life. The city has donated a full parking garage for our use once the alley is built. Lodi, CA does not have a bowling alley, entertainment venue, with a restaurant currently. Lodi Bowl & Restaurant will have the advantage of having no local WHEN RECORDED, RETURN TO: City Clerk City of Lodi 221 West Pine Street Lodi, CA 95240 FEE PAYMENT AGREEMENT 302 NORTH SACRAMENTO STREET, Lodi, CA APN: 041-166-06 THIS AGREEMENT is made and entered into by and between the CITY OF LODI, a California municipal corporation, hereinafter referred to as "City" and ELITE MANAGEMENT COMPANY, INC., a California corporation, hereinafter referred to as "Owner". RECITALS: Owner is the owner of that certain real property situated in the City of Lodi, County of San Joaquin, and described as follows: PARCEL ONE: Commencing at the point of intersection of the north line of Lockeford Street with the east line of Sacramento Street in said City of Lodi; thence east along the north line of Lockeford Street, a distance of 125.00 feet to a point distant 50.0 feet, measured at right angles from the center line of the main line of Central Pacific Railway Company; thence North 2 degrees 01 minutes West, parallel and distance 50.0 feet from center line of said Railway, a distance of 180.0 feet to the northeast corner of the land described in Deed to John A. Trainor, et ux, recorded October 28, 1947, in Volume 1061 of Official Records, at page 457, San Joaquin County Records, and the true point of beginning of the herein described tract; thence continuing North 2 degrees 01 minutes West, parallel and distance 50.0 feet from said center line of said Railway, a distance of 60 feet to the southeast corner of the land described in Deed to George M. Hughes, et ux, recorded February 4, 1952 in Volume 1391 of Official Records, at page 508, San Joaquin County Records; thence at right angles South 87 degrees 59 minutes West, along the south line of said Hughes Land, a distance of 125 feet to the east line of Sacramento Street; thence South 2 degrees 01 minutes East, along the east line of said Sacramento Street; a distance of 60 feet to the northwest corner of said Trainor Land; thence North 87 degrees 59 minutes East, along the north line of said Trainor Land, a distance of 125 feet to the true point of beginning. Said above tract also being known as Lot Four (4), in Block One (1), as shown upon map entitled, Ayers & Pitchers Addition, Map. PARCEL TWO: All of Lot Three (3), in Block One (1), as shown upon map entitled, AYERS & PITCHERS ADDITION, MAP NO. 1, San Joaquin County Records, also being described as follows: Commencing at the intersection of north line of Lockeford Street with the east line of Sacramento Street in said City of Lodi; running thence east FeePayAgmt_Sacramento 302 N Page 1 of 6 along the north line of Lockeford Street, a distance of 125.00 feet to a point distance 50.0 feet measured at right angles from center line of main line of Central Pacific Railway Company; thence North 2 degrees 01 minutes West, parallel with the distance 50.0 feet from center line of said railway, a distance of 120.00 feet to the southeast corner of Lot 3 and point of beginning; thence continuing North 2 degrees 01 minutes West, parallel with the distance 50.00 feet from said center line, a distance of 60.0 feet to a point; thence at right angles South 87 degrees 59 minutes West, a distance of 125.00 feet to the east line of Sacramento Street; thence South 2 degrees 01minutes East, along the east line of Sacramento Street, a distance of 60.0 feet to a point; thence North 87 degrees 59 minutes East, a distance of 125.0 feet to point of beginning. PARCEL THREE: That portion of the East one-half (E 1/2) of the Northwest quarter (NW 1/4) of Section One (1), Township three (3) North, Range six (6) East, Mount Diablo Base and Meridian, and being the North one-half (N 1/2) of the following described tract of land. BEGINNING at a point 50 feet North 4° East, from the Southeast corner of County Survey 2319 made for J.M. Burt on October 28, 1870 and on record in the office of the County Surveyor of San Joaquin County; thence along the Easterly line of said survey, North 4° East, 120 feet to the land formerly owned by Abby Kellogg, which was acquired by him by Deed dated August 13, 1873 and recorded July 24, 1876 in Book "A" of Deeds, Volume 32, page 313, San Joaquin County Records; thence at right angles Westerly along said Kellogg's land, 125 feet; thence at right angles Southeasterly 120 feet; thence at right angles Easterly 125 feet to the point of beginning. EXCEPTING THEREFROM to the United States all oil, coal, or other minerals in portion of land lying within a 150 foot strip lying Westerly of and adjacent to the 100 foot right of way of the Central Pacific Railway Company. The Easterly line of the above described strip being parallel to and distant 50 feet Westerly at right angles to the center line of main line tract of said Central Pacific Railway Company. PARCEL FOUR: Being a portion of the East one-half (E 1/2) of the Northeast Quarter (NW 1/4) of Section One (1), Township three (3) North, Range six (6) East, Mount Diablo Base and Meridian, and being the South one-half (S 1/2) of the following described tract of land. BEGINNING at a point; 50 feet North 4° East, from the Southeast corner of County Survey No. 2319, made for J.M. Burt on the 28th day of October 1870; thence along the Easterly line of said survey, North 4° East, 120 feet to land owned by One Kellogg; thence at right angles Westerly along said Kellogg's land, 125 feet; thence at right angles Southerly 120 feet; thence at right angles Easterly 125 feet to the point of beginning. FeePayAgmt_Sacramento 302 N Page 2 of 6 EXCEPTING THEREFROM that portion conveyed to the City of Lodi in instrument recorded November 13, 1991, Recorder's Instrument No. 91111372, San Joaquin County Records. ALSO EXCEPTING THEREFROM to the United States all oil, coal, or other minerals in portion of land lying within a 150 foot strip lying Westerly of and adjacent to the 100 foot right of way of the Central Pacific Railway Company. The Easterly line of the above described strip being parallel to and distant 50 feet Westerly at right angles to the center line of main line tract of said Central Pacific Railway Company. PARCEL FIVE: Lots 1, 2, and 3 and the South 1/2 of Lot 4, in Block 8, as shown upon the Map entitled Moran Handel Tract, filed for record April 2, 1907 in Vol. 3 of Maps and Plats, Page 53, San Joaquin County Records. EXCEPTING THEREFROM to the a United States all oil, coal, or other minerals in portion of land lying within a 150 feet strip lying Westerly of and adjacent to the 100 foot right of way of the Central Pacific Railway Company. The Easterly line of the above alcove described strip being parallel to and distant 50 feet Westerly at right angles to the center line of main line tract of Central Pacific Railway Company. PARCEL SIX: Beginning at a point distant 320 feet Northerly from the Northwest corner of Block 21 in the Town (now City) of Lodi; thence run Northerly 100 feet; thence Easterly 125 feet to a point in a line parallel with the distant 50 feet Westerly, measured at right angles from the original located center line of Southern Pacific Company's main track (Stockton to Polk); thence Southerly along said parallel line, 100 feet; thence Westerly 125 feet to the point of beginning, the same being a fraction of the West half of the Northwest 1/4 of Section 1, Township 3 North, Range 6 East, Mount Diablo Base and Meridian, as per Deed, recorded January 3, 1920, in Book "A" of Deeds, Vol 400, page 265, and being in Ayres and Pitchers Addition to the City of Lodi. EXCEPTING THEREFROM to the United States all oil, coal, or other minerals in portion of land lying within a 150 foot strip lying Westerly of and adjacent to the 100 foot right of way of the Central Pacific Railway Company. The Easterly line of the above described strip being parallel to and distant 50 feet Westerly at right angles to the center line of main line track of said Central Pacific Railway Company. Owner is desirous of complying with existing City ordinances and policies regarding payment of the Development Impact Mitigation Fees as set forth in Title 15, Chapter 15.64, respectively, of the Lodi Municipal Code. However, Owner has requested payment of the Development Impact Mitigation Fees in twenty (20) equal semi-annual installments over a ten (10) year period. Council of the City will approve the payment of fees in twenty (20) equal semi-annual installments on condition that the owner first enter into and execute this agreement with the City. FeePayAgmt_Sacramento 302 N Page 3 of 6 NOW THEREFORE, in order to insure satisfactory performance by Owner of Owner's obligations under said City Code, the parties agree as follows: 1. Owner agrees to pay Development Impact Mitigation Fees in the amount of TWO HUNDRED NINETEEN THOUSAND NINE HUNDRED THIRTEEN AND 13/100 DOLLARS ($219,913.13) in twenty (20) equal semi-annual payments of TWELVE THOUSAND EIGHT HUNDRED FIFTY- THREE AND 24/100 DOLLARS ($12,853.24) at an interest rate of 3.07 percent. The principal amount represents the Impact Fees as shown on the attached Development Impact Mitigation Fee Summary Sheet, attached hereto as Exhibit A and made a part hereof. 2. The first installment payment shall be due and payable no later than July 1, 2023. All subsequent payments are due no later than January I and July 1 of each calendar year thereafter until the fees are paid in full. 3. Each payment shall be credited first on interest due and the remainder on principal as set forth in the Fee Payment Amortization Schedule, attached hereto as Exhibit B and made a part hereof. 4. Upon sale, transfer, or any other conveyance of the real property, described hereinabove, all fees payable under this Agreement shall become immediately due and payable to City. This Agreement shall have no right of assignment. 5. If Owner fails to meet any specified installment payment as set forth above within fifteen (15) days following the due date, the City Manager, City Council, or designee, may serve written notice upon Owner for breach of this Agreement and declare the default of Owner. 6. In the event of any such notice of breach and default, Owner shall have the duty to pay, in full, the balance of the required fees then due and owing to City. If the Owner, within five days after the serving of notice, does not give the City written notice of its intention to pay in full the balance of the unpaid Development Impact Mitigation Fees and interest thereon, and does not make such payment within five (5) days after its notice to City, this Agreement shall be considered void. City shall institute legal proceedings to recover the balance of the unpaid fees and interest thereon and for any excess cost or damage occasioned City thereby, including attorney's fees and costs. 7. A copy of the Agreement shall be recorded in the office of the San Joaquin County Records, P. O. Box 1968, Stockton, California 95201-1968. 8. All notices herein under this Agreement shall be in writing, and delivered in person or sent by registered mail, postage prepaid. Notices required to be given to City shall be addressed as follows: Charlie Swimley, Jr. Public Works Director City of Lodi P. O. Box 3006 Lodi, CA 95240-1910 Notices required to be given to Owner shall be addressed as follows: Mary Haddad Chief Executive Officer Elite Management Company, Inc. PO BOX 691863 Stockton, CA 95269 FeePayAgmt_Sacramento 302 N Page 4 of 6 9. The signatories of this Agreement represent that they are authorized to enter into this Agreement on behalf of the Party for whom they purport to represent. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have set their hands the day, month and year appearing opposite their names. Dated: Dated: CITY OF LODI, a California municipal corporation 2023 By: Stephen Schwabauer, City Manager Attest: Olivia Nashed, City Clerk ELITE MANAGEMENT COMPANY, INC., a California corporation 2023 By: Mary Haddad, Chief Executive Officer Approved as to form: Janice D. Magdich, City Attorney Dated: 2023 FeePayAgmt_Sacramento 302 N Page 5 of 6 CALIFORNIA ALL-PURPOSE ACKNOWLEDGEMENT CIVIL CODE & 1189 A notary public or other officer completing this certificate verifies only the identity of the individual who signed the document to which this certificate is attached, and not the truthfulness, accuracy, or validity of that document. State of California County of San Joaquin On before me, Date personally appeared Insert Name and Title of the Officer Name(s) ofSigner(s) Who proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the person(s) whose name(s) is/are subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he/she/they executed the same in his/her/their authorized capacity(ies), and that by his/her/their signature(s) on the instrument the person(s), or the entity upon behalf of which the person(s) acted, executed the instrument. I certify under PENALTY OF PERJURY under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing paragraph is true and correct. WITNESS my hand and official seal. Signature: FeePayAgmt_Sacramento 302 N Page 6 of 6 ; - CITY OF LODI PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT Subdivision: Name Parcel: 302 North Sacramento Street Address Lodi, CA 95240 AP # EXHIBIT A Development Impact Mitigation Fee Revised Summary Sheet 1/31/2023 Developer/Owner: Joe Haddad Name PO Box 691863, Stockton CA 95629 Address Project Description: New 45,537 SF Bowling Alley on 1.48 acres Tract # File # 20182145 Permit # GP Land Use Category: Fee Category 1) Water Facilities 041-166-06 Parcel Account # 56200000.57501 $ F Ad'. 31,244.00 121 PWDF03 Project (if different) B (1) 1.00 T $ 31,244.00 2) Wastewater Facilities 3) Storm Drainage Facilities 53300000.57501 $ 53500000.57501 $ 45,971.00 12' 20,339.00 {3y PWDF02 PWDF04 1.00 0.79 $ 45,971.00 $ 16,067.81 4) Street Improvements 30800000.57501 $ 1,284.00 {4) PWDF05 24.22 $ 31,098.60 5) Police Protection Facilities 43500000.57501 $ 620.00 PWDF07 24.22 $ 15,016.46 6) Fire Protection Facilities 43600000,57501 1 $ 751.00 t4j PWDF08 24.22 $ 18,189.29 7) Parks & Recreation Facilities 43700000.57501 $ 954.00 t41 PWDF09 24.22 $ 23,105.97 7a) Neighborhood Park Facilities 43900000.57501 $ 0.00 cel PWDF13 0,00 $ 0.00 8) General City Facilities 43800000.57501 $ 693.00 r4) PWDF10 24.22 $ 16,784.52 9) Electrical Facilities 50500000.57501 $ 15,339.00 ler PWDF01 1.00 $ 15,339.00 10) Art in Public Places 43400000.57504 $ 78.001(') PWDF11 24.22 1 $ 1,889.17 11) South Wastewater Trunk Line 53300000.57505 $ 0.00 in PWDF12 0.00 $ 0.00 12) Non -Potable Water 56200000.57506 $ 215.001'4' PWDF14 24.22 $ 5,207.32 Total 1-12: Total: $ 219,913.13 $ 219,913.13 due prior to Certificate of Occupancy Notes: 1. The commercial building is approximately 45,537 SF on a 1.48 acre site. Impact fees were paid for the southern 0.69 acres of the property on 11/4/1991; fees are assessed based on the unpaid 0.79 acres (53% of the total site area). 2. The Water and Wastewater Capacity Fees based on one 3 -inch commercial water meter. 3. Storm drain facilites fees are based on acreage of office use. Unpaid portion is 0.79 acres in Zone 1, 4. Street Improvements, Police Protection, Fire Protection, Parks and Recreation, General Facilities, Art in Public Places, and Non -Potable Water Impact fees are billed per 1,000 SF or proposed building space and are based on building size of 24,220 SF (53% of the total 45,537 SF building). 5. Neighborhood Park Facilities Impact fee does not apply for this project location. 6. Electrical Facilities Fees are based on a 2000 amp/ 208 volt/3 phase electrical panel. 7. South Wastewater Trunk Line I mpact fee does not apply for this project location. 8. The fee schedule utilized in this summary is based on the December 26, 2022 ENR and is subject to change. Development Impact Mitigation Fees due shall be based on the effective schedule at final inspection. By: Date Billed: Date Paid: Approved: Record #: K:\WP\DEV_SERV\Developments\Commercial-Industrial\Sacramento 302 N Lodi Bowling\Fee Payment Agreement\PaymentSched_Sacramento 302 N EXHIBIT B FEE PAYMENT AMORTIZATION SCHEDULE Lodi Bowling Alley 302 North Sacramento Street (APN 041-166-06) Total Fees: $219,913.13 Interest Rate: 3.07% (2.07% LAIF rate plus 1%) Term: 10 vears Payment No.+ Unpaid Balance I Semiannual I Principal Interest Pavment 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 Check Totals $219,913.13 $12,853.24 $9,477.57 $3,375.67 $12,853.24 $210,435.56 $12,853.24 $9,623.05 $3,230.19 $12,853.24 $200,812.51 $12,853.24 $9,770.77 $3,082.47 $12,853.24 $191,041.74 $12,853.24 $9,920.75 $2,932.49 $12,853.24 $181,120.99 $12,853.24 $10,073.03 $2,780.21 $12,853.24 $171,047.96 $12,853.24 $10,227.65 $2,625.59 $12,853.24 $160,820.30 $12,853.24 $10,384.65 $2,468.59 $12,853.24 $150,435.66 $12,853.24 $10,544.05 $2,309.19 $12,853.24 $139,891.60 $12,853.24 $10,705.90 $2,147.34 $12,853.24 $129,185.70 $12,853.24 $10,870.24 $1,983.00 $12,853.24 $118,315.46 $12,853.24 $11,037.10 $1,816.14 $12,853.24 $107,278.36 $12,853.24 $11,206.52 $1,646.72 $12,853.24 $96,071.85 $12,853.24 $11,378.54 $1,474.70 $12,853.24 $84,693.31 $12,853.24 $11,553.20 $1,300.04 $12,853.24 $73,140.11 $12,853.24 $11,730.54 $1,122.70 $12,853.24 $61,409.57 $12,853.24 $11,910.60 $942.64 $12,853.24 $49,498.97 $12,853.24 $12,093.43 $759.81 $12,853.24 $37,405.54 $12,853.24 $12,279.06 $574.18 $12,853.24 $25,126.48 $12,853.24 $12,467.55 $385.69 $12,853.24 $12,658.93 $12,853.24 $12,658.93 $194.31 $12,853.24 $219,913.13 1 $37,151.66 $257,064.79 competition in a densely populated, mixed -aged area with good public transportation making it conveniently accessible for locals. Question 2. Upon startup, the business will not be making a profit immediately. It will take at least 12 months to start seeing some type of profit margin. Having an agreement will greatly assist us while we go through the lean time for this brand new venture. Thank you in advance for your consideration. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me at 209-483-9873. Thank you for your prompt attention to this matter. Sincerely, Mary Haddad RESOLUTION NO. 2023-57 A RESOLUTION OF THE LODI CITY COUNCIL AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO EXECUTE A FEE PAYMENT AGREEMENT FOR 302 NORTH SACRAMENTO STREET (LODI BOWLING ALLEY) WHEREAS, Elite Management Company, Inc., has submitted a building permit application (No. 20182145) to construct a two-story bowling alley equipped with a bar and banquet room on the property known as 302 North Sacramento Street; and WHEREAS, the project included the installation of public improvements on Sacramento Street and Lockeford Street, which were accepted by Council on August 19, 2020; and WHEREAS, payment of Development Impact Mitigation (DIM) Fees ($219,913.13) is required as part of the building permit conditions; and WHEREAS, on December 20, 2022, the Owner requested to enter into a Fee Payment Agreement with the City to allow payment of the DIM fees in twenty (20) equal semi-annual installments ($12,853.24) plus interest over a ten-year period and interest would be charged at the current Local Agency Investment Fund (LAIF) rate plus one percent (3.07%); and WHEREAS, staff recommends authorizing the City Manager to execute a Fee Payment Agreement for 302 North Sacramento Street (Lodi Bowling Alley). NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Lodi City Council does hereby authorize the City Manager to execute a Fee Payment Agreement for 302 North Sacramento Street (Lodi Bowling Alley); and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, pursuant to Section 6.3q of the City Council Protocol Manual (adopted 11/6/19, Resolution No. 2019-223), the City Attorney is hereby authorized to make minor revisions to the above -referenced document(s) that do not alter the compensation or term, and to make clerical corrections as necessary. Dated: March 15, 2023 I hereby certify that Resolution No. 2023-57 was passed and adopted by the City Council of the City of Lodi in a regular meeting held March 15, 2023 by the following votes: AYES: COUNCIL MEMBERS — Bregman, Craig, Nakanishi, and Mayor Hothi NOES: COUNCIL MEMBERS — None ABSENT: COUNCIL MEMBERS — None ABSTAIN: COUNCIL MEMBERS — None PAMELA M. FARRIS Assistant City Clerk 2023-57