HomeMy WebLinkAboutAgenda Report - August 16, 2000 E-08CITY OF LODI COUNCIL COMMUNICATION
AGENDA TITLE: Purchase of Padmount Transformers ($181,546.91)
MEETING DATE: August 16, 2000
PREPARED BY: Electric Utility Director
RECOMMENDED ACTION: That the City Council adopt the attached resolution awarding the bid
for the purchase of 17 single-phase, and 17 three-phase padmount
transformers to the bidders whose proposals and equipment meet City of Lodi specifications, and whose
transformers are expected to yield the lowest overall life -cycle costs,
Western States Electric, Portland, OR 6 ea 75KVA 240/120V 1 -phase
$ 8,352.78
2 ea 150KVA 208Y/120V 3-phase
$ 8,492.86
3 ea 500KVA 208YI120V
$ 23,561.69
1 ea 1000KVA 208Y/120V
$ 12,866.43
1 ea 300KVA 480YI277V
$ 5,238.81
3 ea 500KVA 480YI277V
$ 23,002.47
5 ea 1500KVA 480Y/277V
$ 76,066.11
$157,581.15
Howard Industries, Laurel, MS 2 ea 225KVA 208Y/1 20V 3-phase $ 11,733.98
Ermco, Dyersburg, TN 11 ea 37.5KVA 240/120V 1 -phase $ 12,231.78
$181,546.91
BACKGROUND INFORMATION: On May 19, 1999, the City Council approved specifications and author-
ized advertisement for bids for polemount and padmount transformers
as necessary to meet the Department's needs through Fiscal Years 1999-2001.
On July 26, 2000, bids for 32 padmount transformers were opened and total life -cycle costs were evaluated.
(Life -cycle costs are the combined total of purchase price plus cost of operation based on estimated power
loss during the projected life of the transformer. Proposals are also evaluated on the basis of compliance
with equipment and bid specifications. Failure to comply with both may lead to disqualification of the bid). A
summary of the bid evaluation is attached as Exhibit A. Subsequent to completion of the evaluation, the need
for two additional 500KVA 480Y/277V transformers became known, increasing the 500KVA quantity
requirement from one to three, and the total number of padmounts recommended for purchase from 32 to 34.
These transformers will be used to serve new industrial, commercial, and residential loads, and to replenish
the department's inventory. Some of the locations planned for installation are Guild Avenue and Victor Road,
the Downtown Theater and Parking Garage, the Pac Bell building, the Grape Festival expansions, and
various residential subdivisions in town. The two additional transformers will be used to serve new loads at
Pluglt on Pine Street, and Valley Industries on South Stockton Street.
FUNDING: Electric Utility Dept 2000-2001 FY Operating P an, Page E-25
Funding: Vicky McAthie, Finance Director
Alan N. Vallow, Electric Utility Director
Prepared by Joel Harris, Purchasing Officer
APPROVED:
H. Dixon Flynn -- ity Manager
PAD M 8162000 08/08/00
Exhibit A
Transformer Bid Evaluation Bid Opening: July 26, 2000 Page 1
Padmount Transformers
Padmount
Tax (factor):
1.0775
6
28
1.80
Vendor
Unit
Extended
Price
No Load Loss $!waft:
3.75
No Load
Load
Cost of
Life Cycle
Delivery
Height
Impedance
July 27, 2000
Price $
Load Loss $/watt:
1.25
Loss (watts) Loss (watts)
Loss value
Loss value
Losses $
Cost $
(weeks)
(Inches)
Bid Item 1: 37.5 kVA, 2401120 Volt, Single Phase Pad
Western States (Cooper)
1,292.00
7,752.00
Number of units:
11
687
2,520.00
28
1.50
Vendor
Unit Extended
Price
No Load
Load
No Load
Load
Cost of
Life Cycle
Delivery
Height
Impedance
8,197.50
Price $ Price $
witax $
Loss (watts) Loss (wafts)
Loss value
Loss value
Losses $
Cost $
(weeks)
(inches)
%
Enrico
1,032.00 11,352.00
12,231.78
77
308
3,176.25
4,235.00
7,411.25
19,643.03
12-14
28
1.60
GE Supply
985.00 10,835.00
11,674.71
79
365
3,258.75
5,018.75
8,277.50
19,952.21
10-12
30
1.88
western States (Cooper)
999.00 '10,989.00
11,840.65
88
334
3,630.00
4,592.50
8,222.50
20,063.15
10-12
24
1.52
Central Moloney
1,028.00 11,308.00
12,184.37
72
379
2,970.00
5,211.25
8,181.25
20,305.62
13
29
1.68
Wesco
1,110.00 12,210.00
13,156.28
77
297
3,176.25
4,083.75
7,260.00
20,416.28
12
32
1.68
Howard Industries (AC)
1,216.00 13,376.00
14,412.84
32
342
1,320.00
4,702.50
6,022.50
20,435.14
16-18
24
2.66
Kuhlman Electric Corp.
1,029.00 11,319.00
12,196.22
84
365
3,465.00
5,018.75
8,483.75
20,679.97
8
27
1.70
Howard Industries
1,039.00 11,428.00
12,314.75
83
367
3,423.75
5,046.25
8,470.00
20,784.75
16-18
24
1.75
Western States (Pauwels)
No Bid
No Load
Load
No Load
Load
Cost of
Life Cycle
Delivery
Height
Impedance
Bid Item 2:75 kVA, 2401120 Volt, Single Phase Pad
Number of units:
6
28
1.80
Vendor
Unit
Extended
Price
No Load
Load
No Load
Load
Cost of
Life Cycle
Delivery
Height
Impedance
Price $
Price $
wAax $
Loss (watts) Loss (watts)
Loss value
Loss value
Losses $
Cost $
(weeks)
(Inches)
%
Western States (Cooper)
1,292.00
7,752.00
8,352.78
112
687
2,520.00
5,152.50
7,672.50
16,025.28
10-12
24
2.00
Emrco
1,237.00
7,422.00
7,997.21
129
706
2,902.50
5,295.00
8,197.50
16,194.71
12-14
28
1.90
Kuhlman Electric Corp.
1,365.00
8,190.00
8,824.73
126
623
2,835.00
4,672.50
7,507.50
16,332.23
8
27
1.60
Howard Industries (AC)
1,604.00
9,624.00
10,369.86
46
667
1,035.00
5,002.50
6,037.50
16,407.36
16-18
24
2.15
Howard Industries
1,388.00
8,328.00
8,973.42
135
631
3,037.50
4,732.50
7,770.00
16,743.42
16-18
24
2.13
Wesco
1,436.00
8,616.00
9,283.74
143
775
3,217.50
5,812.50
9,030.00
18,313.74
12
32
1.99
G E supply
1,188.00
7,128.00
7,680.42
143
636
3,217.50
4,770.00
7,987.50
15,687.92
6-10
30
1.48 `
Central Moloney
1,305.00
7,830.00
6,436.83
133
604
2,992.50
4,530.00
7,522.50
15,959.33
13
29
1.99 "
Western States (Pauwels)
No Bid
Bid Item 3: 150 kVA, 208YI120 Volt, Three Phase Pad
Number of units:
2
65
2.00
Vendor
Unit
Extended
Price
No Load
Load
No Load
Load
Cost of
Life Cycle
Delivery
Height
Impedance
Price $
Price $
wAax $
Loss (watts) Loss (wafts)
Loss value
Loss value
Losses $
Cost $
(weeks)
(inches)
%
Western States (Pauwels)
3,941.00
7,882.00
8,492.86
277
1181
2,077.50
2,952.50
5,030.00
13,522.86
10-12
58
2.65
Howard Industries (AC)
4,340.00
8,680.00
9,352.70
123
1392
922.50
3,480.00
4,402.50
13,755.20
8-10
51
2.27
Western States (Cooper)
3,875.00
7,750.00
8,350.63
304
1326
2,280.00
3,315.00
5.595.00
13,945.63
10-12
50
3.57
Howard Industries
3,872.00
7,744.00
0,3".16
265
1455
1,987.50
3,637.50
5,625.00
13,969.16
8-10
51
2.12
Wesco
3,526.00
7,052.00
7,598.53
292
1793
2,190.00
4,482.50
0,672.50
14,271.03
11
42.5
3.65
GE Supply
5,154.00
10,308.00
11,106.87
106
1086
795.00
2,715.00
3,510.00
14,616.87
14
61
3.79
Emrco
4,751.00
9,502.00
10,238.41
271
1320
2,032.50
3,300.00
5.332.50
15,570.91
14-18
49
3.50
Central Moloney
No Bid
Kuhlman Electric Corp.
No Bid
Transformer Eval 072700 pads.xls 1
Bid Item 5: 500 kVA, 20OW12O Voll, Three Phase Pad
Number of units: 3
75
4.00
Vendor
Unit Extended
Price
Exhibit A
Load
No Load
Load Cost of
Life Cycle
Delivery
Height
Impedance
Price $ Price $
wttax $
Loss (watts) Loss (watts)
Page 2
Loss value Losses $
Cost S
(weeks)
(inches)
%
Western States(Pauwels)
7,289.00 21,867.00
23,561.69
592
3657
6,660.00
Padmount Transformers
Bid Item 4: 225 kVA, 208YN20 Volt, Three Phase Pad
10-12
66.75
Number of units:
2
6,730.00 20,190.00
21,754.73
65
3.50
Vendor
Unit Extended
Price
No Load
Load
No Load
Load
Cost of
Life Cycle
Delivery
Height
Impedance
13,005.00 16,481.25
Price $ Price $
wRax $
Loss (watts) Loss (watts)
Loss value
Loss value
Losses $
Cost S
(weeks)
(inches)
%
Howard Industries (AC)
5,445.00 10,890.00
11,733.98
177
1683
1,327.50
4,207.50
5,535.00
17,268.98
8-10
57
3.71
Western States (Pauwels)
4,693.00 9,386.00
10,113.42
367
1783
2,752.50
4,457.50
7,210.00
17,323.42
10-12
58
3.74
Howard Industries
4,817.00 9,634.00
10,380.64
402
1647
3,015.00
4,117.50
7,132.50
17,513.14
8-10
51
3.93
Western States (Cooper)
4,179.00 8,358.00
9,005.75
502
1939
3,765.00
4,847.50
8,612.50
17,618.25
10-12
50
3.80
Wesco
4,200.00 8,400.00
9,051.00
401
2343
3,007.50
5,857.50
8,865.00
17,916.00
11
42.5
4.00
G E Supply
4,777.00 9,554.00
10,294.44
392
2184
2,940.00
5,460.00
8,400.00
18,694.44
14
61
4.15
Emrco
5,910.00 11,820.00
12,736.05
337
1844
2,527.50
4,610.00
7,137.50
19,873.55
14-18
49
3.70
Central Moloney
No Bid
Kuhlman Electric Corp.
No Bid
Bid Item 5: 500 kVA, 20OW12O Voll, Three Phase Pad
Number of units: 3
75
4.00
Vendor
Unit Extended
Price
No Load
Load
No Load
Load Cost of
Life Cycle
Delivery
Height
Impedance
Price $ Price $
wttax $
Loss (watts) Loss (watts)
Loss value
Loss value Losses $
Cost S
(weeks)
(inches)
%
Western States(Pauwels)
7,289.00 21,867.00
23,561.69
592
3657
6,660.00
13,713.75 20,373.75
43,935.44
10-12
66.75
4.21
Western States (Cooper)
6,730.00 20,190.00
21,754.73
743
3769
8,358.75
14,133.75 22,492.50
44,247.23
10-12
50
4.31
Howard Industries (AC)
9,059.00 27,177.00
29,283.22
309
3468
3,476.25
13,005.00 16,481.25
45,764.47
8-10
69
4.36
Wesco
6,595.00 19,785.00
21,318.34
662
4661
7,447.50
17,478.75 24,926,25
46,244.59
11
50.5
5.35
Howard Industries
7,467.00 22,401.00
24,137.08
812
3492
9,135.00
13,095.00 22,230.00
46,387.08
8-10
63
4.20
G E Supply
9,655.00 28,965.00
31,209.79
254
3361
2,857.50
12,603.75 15,461.25
48,671-04
14
65
4.69
Emco
7,890.00 23,670.00
25,504.43
773
4274
8,698.25
16,027.50 24,723.75
50,228.18
14.18
49
4.60
Central Moloney
No Bid
Kuhman Electric Corp.
No Bid
Bid Item 8: 1000 kVA, 206Y1120 Volt, Three Phase Pad
Number of units: 1
90
5.30
Vendor
Unit Extended
Price
No Load
Load
No Load
Load Cost of
Life Cycle
Delivery
Height
Impedance
Price $ Price $
whax $
Loss (watts) Loss (watts)
Loss value
Loss value Losses $
Cost $
(weeks)
(inches)
%
Western States(Pauwels)
11,941.00 11,941.00
12,866.43
989
7562
3,708.75
9,452.50 13,161.25
26,027.68
12-14
72
5.75
Wesco
11,180.00 11,180.00
12,046.45
1056
8121
3,960.00
10,151.25 14,111.25
26,157.70
11
70,5
5.76
G E Supply
15,059.00 15,059.00
16,226.07
434
6872
1,627.50
8,590.00 10,217.50
26,443.57
14
77
5.73
Western States (Cooper)
11,079.00 11,079.00
11,937.62
1606
7299
6,022.50
9,123.75 15,146.25
27,083.87
10-12
64
5.74
Howard Industries
12,209.00 12,209.00
13,155.20
1102
7896
4,132.50
9,870.00 14,002.50
27,157.70
8-10
63
5.75
Central Moloney
No Bid
Emrco
No Bid
Howard Industries (AC)
No Bid
Kuhlman Electric Corp.
No Bid
Transformer Eval 072700 pads.xis 2
-
Number of units: 5
Number of units:
1
5.30
Vendor
75
4.00
Vendor
Unit
Extended
Exhibit A
No Load
Load
No Load
Load
Cost of
Life Cycle
Delivery
Height
Impedance
%
Price $
Price $
Page 3
Loss (watts) Loss (watts)
Loss value
Loss value
Losses $
Cost $
(weeks)
(inches)
%,
Western States (Pauwels)
7,116.00
7,116.00
7,687.49
Padmount Transformers
Bid Item 7: 300 kVA, 480Y/277 Volt, Three Phase Pad
2,501.25
3,760.00
Number of units:
1
10-12
61.5
65
3.50
Vendor
Unit
Extended
Price
No Load
Load
No Load
Load
Cost of
Life Cycle
Delivery
Height
Impedance
8,466.00
Price $
Price $
w/tax $
Loss (watts) Loss (watts)
Loss value
Loss value
Losses $
Cost $
(weeks)
(inches)
4.71
Western States (Cooper)
4,862.00
4,852.00
5,238.81
532
1868
1,995.00
2,335.00
4,330.00
9,568.81
10-12
50
4.32
Western States (Pauwels)
5,532.00
5,532.00
5,960.73
433
1956
1,623.75
2,445.00
4,068.75
10,029.48
10-12
58
3.64
Howard Industries (AC)
6,277.00
6,277.00
6,783.47
203
2178
761.25
2,722.50
3,483.75
10,247.22
8-10
57
4.24
Howard Industries
5,436.00
5,436.00
5,857.29
528
2034
1,980.00
2,542.50
4,522.50
10,379.79
8-10
51
4.21
G E Supply
8,020.00
6,020.00
6,486.55
137
2752
513.75
3,440.00
3,953.75
10,440.30
14
65
4.40
Wesco
5,252.00
5,252.110
5,659.03
455
2517
1,706.25
3,148.25
4,852.50
10,511.53
11
42.5
3.86
Ermco
6,218.00
6,218.00
6,699.90
381
2033
1,428.75
2,541.25
3,970.00
10,669.90
14-18
49
4.70
Central Moloney
No Bid
Kuhlman Electric Corp.
No Bid
Bid Item 0: 500 kVA, 4BOY1277 Volt, Throe Phase Pad
Number of units: 5
Number of units:
1
5.30
Vendor
75
4.00
Vendor
Unit
Extended
Price
No Load
Load
No Load
Load
Cost of
Life Cycle
Delivery
Height
Impedance
%
Price $
Price $
witax $
Loss (watts) Loss (watts)
Loss value
Loss value
Losses $
Cost $
(weeks)
(inches)
%,
Western States (Pauwels)
7,116.00
7,116.00
7,687.49
667
3008
2,501.25
3,760.00
6,261.25
13,928.74
10-12
61.5
4.08
Western States (Cooper)
6,520.00
6,520.00
7,025.30
652
3681
2,445.00
4,601.25
7,046.25
14,071.55
10-12
5o
4.77
Howard Industries (AC)
8,466.00
8,466.00
9,122.12
302
3273
1,132.50
4,091.25
5,223.75
14,345.87
8-10
63
4.71
G E Supply
9,220.00
9,220.00
9,934.55
260
2814
975.00
3,517.50
4,492.50
14,427.05
14
65
4.28
Wesco
6,390.00
6,390.00
6,885.23
598
4459
2,242.50
5,573.75
7,816.25
14,701.48
11
46.5
5.12
Howard Industries
7,692.00
7,692.00
8,288.13
781
2808
2,928.75
3,510.00
6,438.75
14,726.88
8-10
63
4.29
Ensco
7,466.00
7,466.00
8,044.62
754
3425
2,827.50
4,281.25
7,108.75
15,153.37
14-18
49
4.7
Central Moloney
No Bid
Kuhlman Electric Corp.
No Bid
Bid Item 9: 1500 kVA, 480Y127T Volt, Three Phase Pad
Number of units: 5
90
5.30
Vendor
Unit Extended
Price
No Load
Load No Load
Load Cost of Life Cycle
Delivery
Height
Impedance
Price $ Price $
wRax $
Loss (watts) Loss (watts) Loss value
Loss value Losses $ Cost $
(weeks)
(inches)
%
Western States (Pauwels)
14,119.00 70,595.00
76,066.11
1346
8328 25,237.50
52,050.00 77,287.50 153,353.61
12-14
72
5.78
G E Supply
17,285.00 86,325.00
93,015.19
554
8623 10,387.50
53,893.75 64,281.25 157,296.44
14
77
5.78
Wesco
12,710.00 63,550.00
88,475.13
1609
9704 30,168.75
60,650.00 90,818.75 159,293.88
11
66.5
5.76
Western States (Cooper)
14,766.00 73,830.00
79,551.83
1811
7873 33,956.25
49,206.25 83,162.50 162,714.33
12-14
72
5.75
Howard Industries
15,074.00 75,370.00
81,211.18
1683
8727 31,556.25
54,543.75 86,100.00 167,311.18
8-10
63
5.75
Central Moloney
No Bid
Ermco
No Bid
Howard Industries (AC)
No Bid
Kuhlman Electric Corp.
No Bid
(AC) : Amorphous Core • Does not meet specifications (Height and Impedance)
•` Does not meet specifications (Height)
Transformer Eval 072700 pads.xls 3
RESOLUTION NO. 2000-144
A RESOLUTION OF THE LODI CITY COUNCIL AWARDING THE
BID FOR THE PURCHASE OF PADMOUNT TRANSFORMERS
WHEREAS, in answer to notice duly published in accordance with law and the order of this
City Council, sealed bids were received and publicly opened on July 26, 2000 at 11:00 a.m. for the
purchase of 17 single-phase, and 17 three-phase padmount transformers for the Electric Utility
Department, described in the specifications therefore approved by the City Council on May 19,
1999; and
WHEREAS, said bids have been compared, checked, and tabulated and a report thereof
filed with the City Manager as shown on Exhibit A attached; and
WHEREAS, the City Manager recommends that award of the bid for the purchase of 17
single-phase, and 17 three-phase padmount transformers for the Electric Utility Department, be
made to the bidders whose propgsals and equipment meet City of Lodi specifications, and whose
transformers are expected to yield the lowest overall life -cycle costs, to wit:
Western States Electric, Portland, OR
Howard Industries, Laurel, MS
Ermco, Dyersburg, TN
6 ea 75KVA 240/120V 1 -phase
$
8,352.78
2 ea 150KVA 208Y/120V 3-phase
$
8,492.86
3 ea 500KVA 208Y/120V
$
23,561.69
1 ea 1000KVA 208Y11 20V
$
12,866.43
1 ea 300KVA 480YI277V
$
5,238.81
3 ea 500KVA 480Y/277V
$
23,002.47
5 ea 1500KVA 480Y/277V
$ 76.066.11
$157,581.15
2 ea 225KVA 208YI120V 3-phase $ 11,733.98
11 ea 37.5KVA 240/120V 1 -phase $ 12,231.78
$181,546.91
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Lodi City Council that the award of the
purchase of 17 single-phase, and 17 three-phase padmount transformers for the Electric Utility
Department, be and the same is hereby awarded to the above-described responsible bidders, in the
total amount of $181,546.91.
Dated: August 16, 2000
I hereby certify that Resolution No. 2000-144 was passed and adopted by the City Council of
the City of Lodi in a regular meeting held August 16, 2000, by the following vote:
AYES: COUNCIL MEMBERS — Hitchcock, Land, Nakanishi, Pennino and Mann
(Mayor)
NOES: COUNCIL MEMBERS — None
ABSENT: COUNCIL MEMBERS — None
ABSTAIN: COUNCIL MEMBERS — None
SUSAN J. BL�TON
City Clerk
2000-144
D
Transformer Old Evaluatlon
Dld OPOnl119: July 26, 2000
Padmount Tax (laclur): 1.0715
No Load Loss Wall: 3.75
July 27, 2000 Load Loss Wall: 1.25
Exhibit A
Page ]
Padmount Transformers
Did flons 1: 31.6 Wk. 2401120 Voll, Single Phase Pad • Number otunils: 11 28 1.50
Vendor
Unit Extended
Price
No Load
load
No Load
Load
Cost of
Lila Cycle
Delivery
Height
Inipadance
Price
Price $ Price Il
wllax $
Loss (waits) Loss
(wails)
Loss value
Loss value
Losses 5
Cost S
(weeks)
(Inches)
x
Fresco
1,032.00 11,352.00
12,231.18
77
308
3,178.25
4,235.00
7,411.25
19,843.03
12-14
28
1,60
GE Supply
985.00 10,635.00
11,614.11
79
365
3,258.75
5,018.75
8,277.50
19.932.21
10.12
30
1.88
western states (Cooper)
999.00'10,989.00
Mamas
B8
334
3,630.00
4.592.50
8.222.50
20,063.15
10.12
24
1.52
Central Moloney
1,028.00 11,308.00
12,184.31.
72
379
2.970.00
5.211.25
8,161.25
20.385.62
4 13
29
1.68
Wesco
1.110.00 12,210.00
13,158.26
77
297
3.176.25
4,083.75
7.260.00
20,416.26
12
32
1.68
"award Industries (AC)
1.216.00 13,378.00
14,412.64
32
342
1,320.00
4.702.50
8,022.50
20.435.14
18.18
24
2.68
Kuhlman Electric Corp,
1,029.00 11.319.00
12,108.22
84
305
3.465.00
5,018.75
8.483.75
20.679.97
a
27
1.70
Huward industries
1,039.00 11.429.00
12,314.75
83
361
3,423.75
5,046.25
8.470.00
' 20,164.75
16-10
24
1.75
Western Slates (Pauwels)
No Did
14.18
49
3.50
Central Moloney
No Bid
flld Item 2: 75 kVA, 2401120 Volt. Single Plisse Psd
Number of unils:
0
Kul dinan Electric Corp.
-
28
1.80
Vendor
Unit Extended
Price
No Load
Load
No Load
Load
Cost of
Ula Cycle
Delivery
Helgld
Ingsedance
PALO f Price S
witax 3
Loss (waits) Loss
(waits)
Loss value
Loss value
Losses $
Cost S
(weeks►
(kwisas)
%
Western Stiles (Cooper)
1,292.00 1.152.00
6,352.78
112
691
2.520.00
5.152.50
7,672.50
16,025.26
10.12
24
2.00
Efmco
1,237.131 1,422.00
7,007.21
129
706
2.902.50
5,205.00
a, 197.50
18.194.11
12.14
28
1.90
KuNman Electric Corp.
1,365.00 8.100.00
6,824.13
126
623
2,835.00
4.672.50
7.507.50
16.132.23
a
27
1.60
Itoward Industrles (AC)
1.604.00 9,824.00
10,369.66
40
667
1.035.00
5,002.50
6,037.50
16,407.36
16.18
24
2.15
)toward Industries
1,388.00 8,328.00
6,013.42
135
031
3,037.50
4,732.50
7,770.00
18,743.42
116 -la
24
2.13
Wesco
1,436.00 8,618.00
9,283.74
143
775
3,217.50
5,812.50
0,030.00
16,313.14
12
32
1.99
G E Supply
I,t8800 7.128.00
7,660.42
143
036
3.217.50
4,710.00
7,087.50
15,661.62
8.10
30
1.40
Control Mulunuy
1,305.00 7.630.00
6.436.03
133
004
2,092.50
4.530.00
7.522.50
15,950.31
13
20
1.09
Western Status (Pauwels)
Nu Did
Bld hem 3: 150 kVA, 206YI120 Voll, Three Phase Pad
Number of units:
2
05
2.00
Vendor
Unit
Extended
Price
No Load
Load
No Load
Load
Cost of
LIN Cycle
Delivery
Helghl
Impedance
Price $
Price S
wAnx S
Loss (walls) Loss (walls)
Loss value
Loss value
Losses S
Cost S
(weeks)
(inches)
%
Western Slates (Pauwels)
3,041.00
7,882.00
6,492.00
277
1181
2,071.50
2,952.50
5,030.00
13,522.88
10-12
58
2.55
[toward Industries (AC)
4,340.00
6,880.00
9,352.70
123
1302
922.50
3,480.00
4,402.50
13,155.20
a- to
51
2.21
weslemrStates (Cooper)
3,675.00
7,750.00
0,350.63
704
1326
2,280.00
3,315.00
5.595.00
13,945.63
10.12
5o
3.57
Howard Industries
3,872.00
7,744.00
6,344.10
265
1455
1,967.50
3,837.50
5,625.00
13,909.10
8.10
51
2.12
Wesco
3,526.00
7,052.00
7,59a.53
292
1793
2,100.00
4,402.50
8,872.50
14,271.83
11
42.5
3.85
GE Supply
S. 154.00
10.308.00
11,108.11
100
1066
105.00
2.115.00
3,510.00
14,618.01
14
at
3.70
Enrico
4.751.00
0,502.00
10,238.41
271
1320
2,032.50
3,300.00
5,332.50
15,570.91
14.18
49
3.50
Central Moloney
No Bid
Kul dinan Electric Corp.
No Did
Tianslontset Cva1012100 padlAs
N
i
4J
i
O
N
O
2S
i
Q �
4-1
41 C
r. N
Q O
4) c
Lua-C.
a4 ax sirieiri�.'ri
Y� c pp
O N
r � f
os novo v
]A~ a A n^ w 1 n
U n N P a
e�N e P O
^ r w N r r
N S0�1SSOrtf
N p N ^ O n N h
U J roi pw �<eo is
.- O Sim NAS O
p p
O
- J
7 p p p p
70 � 1fl �f'! S O S O Ifs
O >
Nhwl.� s w
J
rn�+on
e e < n T o«
J w
M
J
N �O=Ov et n
O ;
= O
J
O N E wI O f N
w Of Oa.Of 0
m ^n a •+mow e
Y n �.�ti eow1�
w
a p
o omveo 'o
w ui C o m m o 0 p 0 ^
P M O O O O S O O
s 0
f coO O CON A Q O O
O Q e<< 4<< h Z Z
0
n «
Y Q J O
w O L O U _ C, U
o
NA
N y fU
C ? C 2
a 3
a '3 °33ou7uY
S
p
� qY� vi•i wi�vs
9
H a rn e n� Q
�z m
9-
� 3
N f M O O
O O N ti N n O N
V nvv+oe�o
L♦ J N N m N N� ry
^ M1 O ^ O ^ O
Z O O O nN.
7 � OI H M1 1f1 ri
� a3 e;=ST;oSo
7
Z 9 � O rN.rti OStHv
pj vi Id i i..O
N T< n r q
O m
Z p oe Cl 1�PNe
J
N H e m O g O T
O ;
J N
O
J
n n H^n.00 Nei.
J ;
O '^
2 O
J
P^ N f e p
N e N n 0 1r
N^ e e w P T
w
Q
w d M O S S S O S S
w o ••
gis M J vi o
ui 4. NNN Q-NHN
�" M OOS 00 S 03:2
Y 1 q O a O H O 0 0 0
H
O
d 8� CL
> o
e ? u w S c m
yj ' w O� j a O Gul
X41 C � sS OW
"J 7 j fi
3
c a u n N
N z_ s
°101,uunc
" 1. T n H Y �+e. r.
iei � � ri ei � ri ai
a
J
J A
ti3
os w Oa
> o
O ;
O V A N e A
rte+ w:w nnw
O
V eeo�.w
J N N N N N
M N N O M p
w N_ N�1 N10
N mIV
O
O J a O O O p pi
m O
O J
7 p o
= 7 O O b h
n N
J� OCnIV CI
2 e riri�o f
J
e 3
O
J w
O
J
a O s = O
O ; -
J
O
Z O
J
^ = n a O
M O N
O O O w N
� • e T ^ n
7 C# N r O'+
w - �
CL
O pp
w 9 w o S 0 0 0
b $ Y 0 o o n
Y V - - � • - -
t
�
0000
p
S:P 7 7
O - u T O1ii � pm OCa
- nzzzz
T
0
N
d 3 n v d
0
fA q 7 O ?
�u
sy3a _,
ZZ
c 5:C7�SUW.Y
N
hansfolm87 EYSI 072700 pads.xii 3
i
_ n
Exhibit n
Page 3
Padmount
Transformers
Old lien 7: 300 kVA, 4SOY1277 Voll, Three Phase Pad
Number of unit S:
1
65
3.50
Vendor
Unit Extended
Price
No Load
Load No Load
Load
Cost of
Lite Cycle
Delivery
Height
Impedance
Price S Price 5
wnax S
Loss (waits) Loss (walls► Loss value
Loss value
Losses S
Cost $
(weeks)
(Inches)
%
Western slates (Cooper►
4,662.00 4,802.00
6,231.61
532
sees 1,995.00
2,335.00
4.330.00
9,566.91
10.12
s0
4.32
Western Stales (Peuwels)
5,532.00 5,532.00
5,960.73
413
1050 1,023.75
2,44500
4.008.75
10,029,46
10.12
56
3.84
Howard Industries (AC)
8,277.00 0,277.00
6,761.41
203
2118 781.25 s
2,722.50
3,483.75
10,247.22
B-10
57
4.24
Howard Indusldes
5,430.00 5,436.00
5,651.20
529
2034 1,980.00
2,542.50
4,522.50
10,379.19
B-10
51
4.21
G E Supply
8,020.00 6.020.00
6,466.S5
131
2752 511.75
3,440.00
3,953.75
10,440.30
14
65
4.40
Wesco
5,252.00 5,252.Oq
5,656.03
455
2517 1,706.25
3,145.25
4.852.50
10,511.51
11
42.5
3.86
Ernlco
8,218.00 6,2t6.00
6,699.90
381
2033 1,4211.75
2,541.25
3,070.00
10,0169.10
14.18
49
4.70
Central Moloney
No Old
• Kuldnnan Electric Culp,
No Did
Did lion, 8: $oo kVA, 4a0Y/277 Volt, Tluee Phase Pad
Nunnbur of U1111 1:
1
4
75
4.00
Vendor
Unit Extended
Mice
No Load
Load No Load
Laid
Cost of
Llle Cycle
Delivery
Haight
Impedance
Price S Price S
wnax $
LOS& (walls) Loss (walls) Loss value
Loss value
Losses S
Cost $
(weeks)
(Inches)
%
Western States(Pauwels)
7,1(6.00 7,119.00
7,081.49
067
JOD8 2,501.25
3,760.00
0,201.25
13,926.14
10-12
61.5
4.09
Westurn States (Couper)
8.520.00 8,520.00
1,025.30
652
3081 2,445.00
. 4,801.25
7,040.25
14,011.55
10.12
50
4.77
lluwardInduslrles(AC)
8.460Ao 8,486.00
0,122.12
302
3273 1,132.50
4,091.25
5,223.75
14,345.61
9-10
63
4.71
G E Supply
9,220.00 9,220.00
9,934,55
260
2614 975.00
3,517.50
4,492.50
14,421.05
14
65
4.26
Wesco
8,390,00 0,390.00
6,865.23
594
4459 2,242.50
5,573.75
7,810.25
14,701.48
11
46.5
5.12
Itoward lrklUSUIUS
7692.00 1,892.00
0,266,13
lei
2608 2,928.75
3,510.00
0.436.75
14,126.86
11.10
03
4.29
Ennca
7,46000 7,46800
1,044.62
75.1
3425 2,1127.50
4,281.25
7,109.75
15,153.37
14.18
49
4.7
Cenlrat Mulorwy
140 old
Kulanan Eleddc Corp.
Nu okl
Dldhem9: 1$00 kVA. 440YI211Volt. ThreePllnaPad
Number Ofunits:
5
110
5.30
V endur
Unit Exlen ded
Pdce
No Load
Load No Load
Load
Cost of
Life Cycle
Dullvery
1 ieloht
Impedance
Price S Price S
wnax S
Lost (wails) Lass (walls) Loss value
Loss value
Losses $
Cost S
(weeks)
(inelses)
%
Western Slates (11auwels)
t4,110.00 70,595.00
76,0116.11
13.10
0328 25,?31.50
52,050.00
77,267,50
153,351,61
12.14
12
5.18
G 1: Supply
17,205.00 80.325.00
63,011.19
554
8023 18,361.50
57,693.75
64,261.25
157,290.44
14
17
5.76
WL'1C0
12,710.00 63,550.00
ee,41s.13
1609
0704 30,168.75
60,650.00
90,018.75
159,297.88
11
08.5
5.76
WeslamStales (Cooper)
14,768.00 73,830.00
71,551.83
telt
1873 33,958.25
49,206.25
83,102,50
162,714.33
12.14
72
5.75
tluwaldlnduSilies
15,074,00 75,370,00
111,211.111
1683
8727 31,558.25
54,543.75
86,100.00
157,311.18
8.10
63
5.75
Central Mol000y
No Oki
[1111co
No Old
llowaid Industries (AC)
No Bid
Ku)dman Elepile Corp,
No Bid
(AC) : Amorphous Core
Does not noel Specifications (lielihl and Impedance)
Does not
111861 specifications 111819111)
hansfolm87 EYSI 072700 pads.xii 3