HomeMy WebLinkAboutAgenda Report - February 2, 2000 Public CommentContinued February 2, 2000r
• Result:
> Time schedule in permit
> Aggressive, but reasonable
➢ Full compliance by May 1, 2004
➢ NO Cease and Desist Order
> Includes major effluent requirements (BOD, Bacteria, Turbidity, Cyanide, Zinc,
Lead, Lindane, Dissolved Oxygen and Temperature)
• Our Issue:
➢ Dilution/Mixing Credit for trace pollutants
• Result:
➢ No dilution credit, but .. .
> Compliance is in schedule
➢ Slightly higher limits on metals
> Ability to do site specific study
• Our Issue:
> No Tertiary without Basin Plan Update
• Result:
> No change, but .. .
> Compliance is in schedule
• Our Issue:
> Reasonable limits for Lindane
• Result:
➢ Limit set at detection limit of 0.02pg/I achievable by 20% of labs
• Compliance is in schedule
• Our Issue:
➢ SB709 — Immediate Fines
• Result:
> Eliminated due to time schedule and removal of Cease and Desist
• However, we need to show progress
Recommended Actions
• Finish Master Plan promptly
• Work with West Yost and subconsultants on additional studies specified in permit
• Seek grant funding for recycling studies
No Council action was required.
10. ORDINANCES
None.
11. COMMENTS BY THE PUBLIC ON NON -AGENDA ITEMS
a) Don Lindsay, 384 Valley Avenue, Lodi once again addressed the City Council voicing his
opposition to the recently adopted ordinance regarding truck parking in Lodi. Mr. Lindsay
presented information pertaining to US Code, Title 49, Section 31114 stating that it was
his opinion that this Code would invalidate the City of Lodi Ordinance. He further stated it
appears that he cannot influence Council Members regarding this matter but that he can
influence businesses and voters.
The City Clerk was directed to provide the City Attorney with a copy of the US Code, Title
49 as was presented by Mr. Lindsay to allow the City Attorney to review the document.
7
JIM ARTMAN}INC
805 Locust Avenue
Ripon, CA 95366
Don Lindsay
Driver/Trainer
Business (209)599-5000
Cellular (209)404-0736
Ideas
submitted by Don Lindsay
February 2, 2000
Set up truck routes.
People will have to be educated that trucks are needed to keep the
city running. If trucks can safely park, let them.
Require permits for local trucking companies.
Before a business permit is issued, the owner must show proof they
have made parking arrangements. The city is not their parking lot.
Set time limits for how long a truck can stay in one spot.
Meter maids do this with cars.
A reasonable example is 48 hours midnight to midnight. This way
a driver could get into town Friday afternoon, stay in a motel and
unload Monday morning. A courtesy note could be put on the
truck to let the driver know when the truck needs to be moved. In
this example the truck must be moved by midnight on Monday or it
will be ticketed. They are actually getting 72 hours if moved at
midnight on Monday.
Put in a truck stop on Highway 99.
There is a piece of property in the county that would be good for a
truck stop, if variances and waivers could be obtained.
us Lone : Title 49, Section 31114
Sec. 31114. Access to the Interstate System
Page 1 of 1
US Code as of 01/26/98
• (a) Prohibition on Denying Access. - A State may not enact or enforce a law denying to a
commercial motor vehicle subject to this subchapter or subchapter I of this chapter reasonable
access between -
o (1) the Dwight D. Eisenhower System of Interstate and Defense
Highways (except a segment exempted under section 31111(f) or
31113(e) of this title) and other qualifying Federal -aid Primary
System highways designated by the Secretary of Transportation; •
and
o (2) terminals, facilities for food, fuel, repairs, and rest,
and points of loading and unloading for household goods carriers,
motor carriers of passengers, or any truck tractor -semitrailer
combination in which the semitrailer has a length of not more
than 28.5 feet and that generally operates as part of a vehicle
combination described in section 31111(c) of this title.
• (b) Exception. = This section does not prevent a State or local government from imposing
reasonable restrictions, based on safety considerations, on a truck tractor -semitrailer
combination in which the semitrailer has a length of not more than 28.5 feet and that generally
operates as part of a vehicle combination described in section 31111(c) of this title.
http://www4.law.cornell.edu/uscode/49/31114.text.htm1 1/29/00
us uocie : Title 49, Section 31111 Page 1 of 3
US Code as of. 01/26/98
Sec. 31111. Length limitations
• (a) Definitions. - In this section -
o (1) "maxi -cube vehicle" means a truck tractor combined with a
semitrailer and a separable property -carrying unit designed to be
loaded and unloaded through the semitrailer, with the length of
the separable property -carrying unit being not more than 34 feet
and the length of the vehicle combination being not more than 65
feet.
o (2) "truck tractor" means -
■ (A) a non -property -carrying power unit that operates in
combination with a semitrailer or trailer; or
• (B) a power unit that carries as property only motor vehicles
when operating in combination with a semitrailer in
transporting motor vehicles.
• (b) General Limitations. - (1) Except as provided in this section, a State may not prescribe or
enforce a regulation of commerce that -
o (A) imposes a vehicle length limitation of less than 45 feet on
a bus, of less than 48 feet on a semitrailer operating in a truck
tractor -semitrailer combination, or of less than 28 feet on a
semitrailer or trailer operating in a truck
tractor -semitrailer -trailer combination, on any segment of the
Dwight D. Eisenhower System of Interstate and Defense Highways
(except a segment exempted under subsection (f) of this section)
and those classes of qualifying Federal -aid Primary System
highways designated by the Secretary of Transportation under
subsection (e) of this section;
o (B) imposes an overall length limitation on a commercial motor
vehicle operating in a truck tractor -semitrailer or truck
tractor -semitrailer -trailer combination;
o (C) has the effect of prohibiting the use of a semitrailer or
trailer of the same dimensions as those that were in actual and
lawful use in that State on December 1, 1982;
o (D) has the effect of prohibiting the use of an existing
semitrailer or trailer, of not more than 28.5 feet in length, in
a truck tractor -semitrailer -trailer combination if the
semitrailer or trailer was operating lawfully on December 1,
1982, within a 65 -foot overall length limit in any State; or
o (E) imposes a limitation of less than 46 feet on the distance
from the kingpin to the center of the rear axle on trailers used
exclusively or primarily in connection with motorsports
competition events.
■ (2) A length limitation prescribed or enforced by a State under paragraph (1)(A) of
this subsection applies only to a semitrailer or trailer and not to a truck tractor.
• (c) Maxi -Cube and Vehicle Combination Limitations. - A State may not prohibit a maxi -cube
http://www4.law.cornell.edu/uscode/49/31111.text.html 1/29/00
US Code : Title 49, Section 31111 Page 2 of 3
vehicle or a commercial motor vehicle combination consisting of a truck tractor and 2 trailing
units on any segment of the Dwight D. Eisenhower System of Interstate and Defense Highways
(except a segment exempted under subsection (f) of this section) and those classes of qualifying
Federal -aid Primary System highways designated by the Secretary under subsection (e) of this
section.
• (d) Exclusion of Safety and Energy Conservation Devices. - Length calculated under this
section does not include a safety or energy conservation device the Secretary decides is
necessary for safe and efficient operation of a commercial motor vehicle. However, such a
device may not have by its design or use the ability to carry cargo.
• (e) Qualifying Highways. - The Secretary by regulation shall designate as qualifying Federal -
aid Primary System highways those highways of the Federal -aid Primary System in existence
on June 1, 1991, that can accommodate safely the applicable vehicle lengths provided in this
section.
• (f) Exemptions. - (1) If the chief executive officer of a State, after consulting under paragraph
(2) of this subsection, decides a segment of the Dwight D. Eisenhower System of Interstate and
Defense Highways is not capable of safely accommodating a commercial motor vehicle having
a length described in subsection (b)(1)(A) of this section or the motor vehicle combination
described in subsection (c) of this section, the chief executive officer may notify the Secretary
of that decision and request the Secretary to exempt that segment from either or both
provisions.
o (2) Before making a decision under paragraph (1) of this subsection, the chief executive
officer shall consult with units of local government in the State in which the segment of
the Dwight D. Eisenhower System of Interstate and Defense Highways is located and
with the chief executive officer of any adjacent State that may be directly affected by the
exemption. As part of the consultations, consideration shall be given to any potential
alternative route that serves the area in which the segment is located and can safely
accommodate a commercial motor vehicle having a length described in subsection (b)(1)
(A) of this section or the motor vehicle combination described in subsection (c) of this
section.
o (3) A chief executive officer's notification under this subsection must include specific
evidence of safety problems supporting the officer's decision and the results of
consultations about alternative routes.
o (4)
• (A) If the Secretary decides, on request of a chief executive officer or on the
Secretary's own initiative, a segment of the Dwight D. Eisenhower System of
Interstate and Defense Highways is not capable of safely accommodating a
commercial motor vehicle having a length described in subsection (b)(1)(A) of this
section or the motor vehicle combination described in subsection (c) of this
section, the Secretary shall exempt the segment from either or both of those
provisions. Before making a decision under this paragraph, the Secretary shall
consider any possible alternative route that serves the area in which the segment is
located.
• (B) The Secretary shall make a decision about a specific segment not later than
120 days after the date of receipt of notification from a chief executive officer
under paragraph (1) of this subsection or the date on which the Secretary initiates
action under subparagraph (A) of this paragraph, whichever is applicable. If the
http://www4.1a o ed iuscode/49I31111.text.html 1/29/00
U SUode : Title 49, Section 31111 Page 3 of 3
Secretary finds the decision will not be made in time, the Secretary immediately
shall notify Congress, giving the reasons for the delay, information about the
resources assigned, and the projected date for the decision.
■ (C) Before making a decision, the Secretary shall give an interested person notice
and an opportunity for comment. If the Secretary exempts a segment under this
subsection before the final regulations under subsection (e) of this section are
prescribed, the Secretary shall include the exemption as part of the final
regulations. If the Secretary exempts the segment after the final regulations are
prescribed, the Secretary shall publish the exemption as an amendment to the final
regulations.
• (g) Accommodating Specialized Equipment. - In prescribing regulations to carry out this
section, the Secretary may make decisions necessary to accommodate -specialized equipment,
including automobile and vessel transportersand maxi -cube vehicles.
htt,t//Wwv4Jaw. cornell.edit/uscode/49/31111.te t.1t0m1 1/29/00
US Code : Title 49, Section 31113 Page 1 of 2
US Code as of 01/16/98
Sec. 31113. Width limitations
• (a) General Limitations. - (1) Except as provided in subsection (e) of this section, a State
(except Hawaii) may not prescribe or enforce a regulation of commerce that imposes a vehicle
width limitation of more or less than 102 inches on a commercial motor vehicle operating on -
o (A) a segment of the Dwight D. Eisenhower System of Interstate
and Defense Highways (except a segment exempted under subsection
(e) of this section);
o (B) a qualifying Federal -aid highway designated by the
Secretary of Transportation, with traffic lanes designed to be at
least 12 feet wide; or
o (C) a qualifying Federal -aid Primary System highway designated
by the Secretary if the Secretary decides the designation is
consistent with highway safety.
■ (2) Notwithstanding paragraph (1) of this subsection, a State may continue to
enforce a regulation of commerce in effect on April 6, 1983, that applies to a
commercial motor vehicle of more than 102 inches in width, until the date on
which the State prescribes a regulation of commerce that complies with this
subsection.
■ (3) A Federal -aid highway (except an interstate highway) not designated under this
subsection on June 5, 1984, may be designated under this subsection only with the
agreement of the chief executive officer of the State in which the highway is
located.
• (b) Exclusion of Safety and Energy Conservation Devices. - Width calculated under this
section does not include a safety or energy conservation device the Secretary decides is
necessary for safe and efficient operation of a commercial motor vehicle.
• (c) Special Use Permits. - A State may grant a special use permit to a commercial motor
vehicle that is more than 102 inches in width.
• (d) State Enforcement. - Consistent with this section, a State may enforce a commercial motor
vehicle width limitation of 102 inches on a segment of the Dwight D. Eisenhower System of
Interstate and Defense Highways (except a segment exempted under subsection (e) of this
section) or other qualifying Federal -aid highway designated by the Secretary.
• (e) Exemptions. - (1) If the chief executive officer of a State, after consulting under paragraph
(2) of this subsection, decides a segment of the Dwight D. Eisenhower System of Interstate and
Defense Highways is not capable of safely accommodating a commercial motor vehicle having
the width provided in subsection (a) of this section, the chief executive officer may notify the
Secretary of that decision and request the Secretary to exempt that segment from subsection (a)
to allow the State to impose a width limitation of less than 102 inches for a vehicle (except a
bus) on that segment.
o (2) Before making a decision under paragraph (1) of this subsection, the chief executive
officer shall consult with units of local government in the State in which the segment of
the Dwight D. Eisenhower System of Interstate and Defense Highways is located and
with the chief executive officer of any adjacent State that may be directly affected by the
http://www4.law.cornell.edu/uscode/49/31113 .text.html 1/29/00
US Code : Title 49, Section 31113 Page 2 of 2
exemption. As part of the consultations, consideration shall be given to any potential
alternative route that serves the area in which the segment is located and can safely
accommodate a commercial motor vehicle having the width provided for in subsection
(a) of this section.
o (3) A chief executive officer's notification under this subsection must include specific
evidence of safety problems supporting the officer's decision and the results of
consultations about alternative routes.
o (4)
• (A) If the Secretary decides, on request of a chief executive officer or on the
Secretary's own initiative, a segment of the Dwight D. Eisenhower System of
Interstate and Defense Highways is not capable of safely accommodating a
commercial motor vehicle having a width provided in subsection (a) of this
section, the Secretary shall exempt the segment from subsection (a) to allow the
State to impose a width limitation of less than 102 inches for a vehicle (except a
bus) on that segment. Before making a decision under this paragraph, the Secretary
shall consider any possible alternative route that serves the area in which the
segment is located.
• (B) The Secretary shall make a decision about a specific segment not later than
120 days after the date of receipt of notification from a chief executive officer
under paragraph ( 1) of this subsection or the date on which the Secretary initiates
action under subparagraph (A) of this paragraph, whichever is applicable. If the
Secretary finds the decision will not be made in time, the Secretary immediately
shall notify Congress, giving the reasons for the delay, information about the
resources assigned, and the projected date for the decision.
• (C) Before making a decision, the Secretary shall give an interested person notice
and an opportunity for comment. If the Secretary exempts a segment under this
subsection before the final regulations under subsection (a) of this section are
prescribed, the -Secretary shall include the exemption as part of the final
regulations. If the Secretary exempts the segment after the final regulations are
prescribed, the Secretary shall publish the exemption as an amendment to the final
regulations.
http://www4.law.Cornell.edu/uscode/49/31113.text.html 1/29/00