HomeMy WebLinkAboutAgenda Report - April 18, 2012 G-01 PHTM
CITY OF LODI
COUNCIL COMMUNICATION
AGENDA ITEM
6-1
AGENDA TITLE: Conduct Public Hearing on April 18, 2012 to Consider Amending Lodi Municipal
Code Chapter 13.20 — Electrical Service, by Repealing and Re-enacting
Section 13.20.175 `Schedule ECA— Energy Cost Adjustment" in its Entirety to
Include Flat Energy Cost Adjustment (ECA) Option
MEETING DATE: April 18, 2012
PREPARED BY: Electric Utility Director
RECOMMENDEDACTION: Conduct public hearing on April 18, 2012 to consider amending
Lodi Municipal Code Chapter 13.20 — Electrical Service, by
Repealing and Re-enacting Section 13.20.175 "Schedule ECA —
Energy Cost Adjustment" in its entirety to Include Flat Energy
Cost Adjustment (ECA) option.
BACKGROUND INFORMATION: The Electric Utility proposes a flat ECA option for customers taking
service under schedule 1-1 — This was at the request of one of our
major customers. This benefits the customer by reducing the
impact of the monthly ECA fluctuations. EUD staff will
create a levelized payment option (flat ECA) based on projected sales divided by the budgeted NCPA All
Resources Bill for the upcoming 12 month period (July -June) minus 8.31 cents. The resulting amount
shall be automatically implemented for bills rendered during the 11 billing months beginning in July and
ending in May. The June billing shall include a true -up for the actual ECA billed in the same 11 month
period and the actual ECA for the month of June.
FISCAL IMPACT: None. This will only impact one customer and the full amount of ECA due will be
collected within the fiscal year.
FUNDING: Not applicable.
UAA cAtpkw
Elizabeth A. Kirkley
Electric Utility Director
PREPARED BY: Matt Foskett, Rates and Resources Manager
EAK/MF/Ist
APPROVED:
Konradt Bartlam, City Manager
ORDINANCE NO.
AN ORDINANCE OF THE LODI CITY COUNCIL AMENDING
LODI MUNICIPAL CODE CHAPTER 13.20 — ELECTRICAL
SERVICE — BY REPEALING AND REENACTING SECTION
13.20.175, "SCHEDULE ECA — ENERGY COST
ADJUSTMENT" IN ITS ENTIRETY
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE LODI CITY COUNCIL AS FOLLOWS:
SECTION 1. Lodi Municipal Code Section 13.20.175, "Schedule ECA — Energy Cost
Adjustment," is hereby repealed and reenacted in its entirety to read as follows:
APPLICABILITY:
This schedule is applicable to all electric customers served by the City of Lodi. Each customer
shall pay the applicable rate plus an Energy Cost Adjustment (ECA) for each kilowatt-hour (kWh)
delivered to the customer. The adjustment shall be the product of the total kilowatt-hours (kWh)
for which the bill is rendered times the ECA amount per kWh.
The purpose of the ECA is to adjust for increases/decreases to the City of Lodi's wholesale
energy costs. This adjustment provides a mechanism to recover increased costs for wholesale
energy or to lower collections when costs decrease below the base charge level.
RATES:
Effective July 6, 2007, the ECA billing factor for any given month shall be calculated as follows:
ECA = (a) + (b) - (c)(d+f) - (f)
(e)
Where:
(a) equals the amount the City of Lodi is actually charged by the Northern California Power
Agency for the billing month, including adjustments for prior billing periods, less any third party
revenue credits.
(b) equals the City of Lodi's estimated costs related to the acquisition of wholesale power, both
financial and physical, procured directly by the City for the billing month, including adjustments for
prior billing periods.
(c) equals the difference between actual retail energy sales and projected sales levels for the
month which is two (2) months prior to the billing month.
(d) equals the ECA billing factor for the month which is two (2) months prior to the billing month.
(e) equals the forecast of projected retail energy sales for the billing month.
(f) equals the baseline energy cost for the City of $0.0831.
The City of Lodi will recalculate the ECA each month, and resulting amount shall be automatically
implemented for bills rendered during the following billing month. The ECA shall not be
discounted.
SCHEDULE 1-1 FIXED ECA OPTION:
Customers must elect this option prior to the start of the twelve month cycle
(July -June) and must be billed for the entire twelve months under this option.
Customers may opt out in the May prior to the next twelve month billing
period.
The City of Lodi will calculate a fixed ECA based on projected sales divided by
the budgeted NCPAAII Resource Bill for the upcoming 12 month period (July -
June) minus eight point three one (8.31) cents. The resulting amount shall be
automatically implemented for bills rendered during the eleven billing months
beginning in July and ending in May. The June billing shall include a true -up
for the actual ECA billed in the same eleven month period and the actual ECA
for the month of June.
SECTION 2. No Mandatory Duty of Care. This ordinance is not intended to and shall not be
construed or given effect in a manner which imposes upon the City, or any officer or employee
thereof, a mandatory duty of care towards persons or property within the City or outside of the
City so as to provide a basis of civil liability for damages, except as otherwise imposed by law.
SECTION 3. Severability. If any provision of this ordinance or the application thereof to any
person or circumstances is held invalid, such invalidity shall not affect other provisions or
applications of the ordinance which can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
To this end, the provisions of this ordinance are severable. The City Council hereby declares
that it would have adopted this ordinance irrespective of the invalidity of any particular portion
thereof.
SECTION 4. All ordinances and parts of ordinances in conflict herewith are repealed insofar as
such conflict may exist.
SECTION 5. This ordinance shall be published pursuant to law and shall become effective 30
days from the date of passage and adoption.
SECTION 6. The amended Schedules referenced above shall be effective on applicable
electric utility billings prepared by the City of Lodi on or after , 2012, or the first date
allowable under State law.
ATTEST:
RANDI JOHL
City Clerk
2
Approved this day of , 2012
JOANNE MOUNCE
MAYOR
State of California
County of San Joaquin, ss.
I, Randi Johl, City Clerk of the City of Lodi, do hereby certify that Ordinance No. was
introduced at a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Lodi held , 2012, and
was thereafter passed, adopted, and ordered to print at a regular meeting of said Council held
, 2012, by the following vote:
AYES: COUNCIL MEMBERS —
NOES: COUNCIL MEMBERS —
ABSENT: COUNCIL MEMBERS —
ABSTAIN: COUNCIL MEMBERS —
I further certify that Ordinance No. was approved and signed by the Mayor on the date of its
passage and the same has been published pursuant to law.
Approved to Form:
D. STEPHEN SCHWABAUER
City Attorney
3
RANDI JOHL
City Clerk
Energy Cost Adjustment
Industrial Rate Class Option
Loci city council
April 18, 2012
ckground
updated monthly to reflect
actual powcosts
Positive when co'+ks are higher than base
Negative when CosiOltw lower than base
CA is identical for all rate classes
t ECA - why?
Requests from Industrial customers
Budget vs. actual monthly utility bills
National marke petitiveness
Provides electric bill pr»ctabiIity
roposal
•
Re e impact of fluctuating ECA
n In
for City's s
(12.4% load)
Flat ECA would b
months (July -May)
dustrial (11) customers
filled over eleven
Customers would receitrue-up of
actual ECA costs on their Ju bill
Opt -out at end of Fiscal Year
July 1, 2012 proposed start date
t ECA Calculation
Based on upcoming Fiscal Year's
Budgeted power costs/projected sales
Less baseline energy costs
Y 2012/13 Flat ECA =
($39.3 M/434.5 M kWh) - $0.0831
$0.0905 - $0.0831 = $0.0074
Projected Flat ECA is $0.0074
ible Customers
th,
General isik,
Ralcorp
CertainTeed
Pacific Coast Producers
Lodi Iron Works
White Slough
Schaefer Systems
•
tions / comments???
Jennifer Robison
Page 1 of 2
G -I
From: Randi Johl
Sent: Wednesday, April 18,2012 01:23 PM
To: Jennifer Robison
Subject: FW. Item G-1
Randi Johl, JD, MMC
City Clerk. City cfLodi
221 West Pine Street
Lodi. California 95240
(209) 333-6702 Telephone
(209) 333-6807 Facsimile
From: JOHN E. JOHNSON [mailto:john@johnejohnson.com]
Sent: Wednesday, April 18, 2012 01:07 PM
To: City Council; Randi Johl
Cc: Rad Bartlam; Elizabeth Kirkley; Pat Patrick; Rich Harmer; Keith Reid
Subject: Item G-1
As you are all aware, I have been working with the ECA and checking the ECA calculations since its
inception. I have also spoken out that the ECA should be fixed for a period of time so that customers
could count on consistent rates. So, this item is somewhat satisfying but it is also disturbing in that one
customer will receive preferential treatment while the rest of us will have variable rates each month.
I understand that there will be a "true -up" at the end of the eleven months and that new rates will be set
for this one customer. What is unclear is how the "true -up" will impact the rest of us.
As the ECA is today, the calculation is rather easy. Anything that we pay over 8.31 cents is added and
if it is under it is subtracted, assuming usage is at budget With one large customer coming out of the
equation, are their hours coming out of the equation too? If so, that will impact the ECA calculation for
the rest of us and most likely not in a favorable way unless changes are made to the formula. Please
keep in mind that the ECA has only been negative 7 time since its inception and there have been 57
ECA calculations since inception.
The current ECA passes the cost or the benefit to everyone equally. Pulling a large customer out will
pass the cost or the benefit across fewer usage hours unless the cost paid for power is also adjusted by
this one customers usage and their budgeted hours as well as actual hours are also removed. If you
think the average person has a hard time understanding the ECA formula now, make those changes.
Why not do this for everyone? I realize that this is a large customer but it is one customer. Why not fix
rates for 6 months for everyone and then adjust them using the ECA formula? Why not fix them for a
year and then adjust them?
The ECA was designed to make sure rates reflected the true cost of power and that it was collected
timely. It was also designed to treat everyone equally in that everyone paid the same ECA times the
hours used regardless of their rate structure. The current ECA does those things. This change does
04/18/2012
Page 2 of 2
none of that.
I particularly like the this portion of item G-1.
FISCAL IMPACT: None. This will only impact one customer and thefull amount of ECA due will be collected
within the fiscal year.
That simply is not true and it is naive to say it. If during the 11 months that this one customer has their
ECA power prices increase, we, the owners of the utility, will be financing their portion of the ECA that
is unpaid. The only way to avoid that is to overcharge them in advance or to overcharge the rest of us.
Now before you dismiss my understanding or knowledge of the ECA, allow me to remind you that
there have been two errors made in the ECA calculations and both were found by me. The latest one in
December 2011 would have cost the city about $150,000 had it not been caught.
I hope that you will not support this item. Rather, I would like to see you support a change like this for
all customers.
I am sending this email because I cannot attend tonight's meeting.
Respectfully,
John
John E. Johnson, CFA
JOHN E. JOHNSON, LLC
106 S. Orange Avenue
Lodi, California 95240
(209) 369-1451
(209) 369-3032 FAX
john@iohnejohnson.com
04/18/20 12
Please immediately confirm receipt
d this fax by calling 333-6702
CITY OF LODI
P. O.BOX 3006
LODI, CALIFORNIA 9524 1-1 91 0
ADVERTISING INSTRUCTIONS
SUBJECT: PUBLIC HEARING TO CONSIDER AMENDING LODI MUNICIPAL CODE
CHAPTER 13.20 - ELECTRICAL SERVICE - BY REPEALING AND
REENACTING SECTION 13.20.175, "SCHEDULE ECA - ENERGY COST
ADJUSTMENT," IN ITS ENTIRETY TO INCLUDE FLAT ENERGY COST
ADJUSTMENT OPTION
PUBLISH DATE: SATURDAY, APRIL 7,2012
LEGAL AD
TEAR SHEETS WANTED: One (1 ) please
SEND AFFIDAVIT AND BILL TO:
DATED: THURSDAY, APRIL 5,2012
ORDERED BY:
JENNIFER M. ROBISON, CMC
ASSISTANT CITY CLERK
RANDI JOHL, CITY CLERK
City of Lodi
P.O. Box 3006
Lodi, CA 95241-1910
RANDI JOHL
CITY CLERK
!gef611
"-.,6M[NISTRATIVE CLERK
Verify Appearance of this Legal in the Newspaper — Copy to File
Faxed to the Sentinel at 369-1084 at I : OS
ej on
2. (date) 2- (pages)
F_HS Phoned to confirm receipt of all paces at time} JMP _MB CF (initials)
forms\advins.doc
DECLARATION OF POSTING
PUBLIC HEARING TO CONSIDER AMENDING LODI MUNICIPAL CODE CHAPTER
13.20 — ELECTRICAL SERVICE — BY REPEALINGAND REENACTING SECTION
13.20.175, "SCHEDULE ECA — ENERGY COST ADJUSTMENT," IN ITS ENTIRETY
TO INCLUDE FLAT ENERGY COST ADJUSTMENT OPTION
On Thursday, April 5, 2012, in the City of Lodi, San Joaquin County, California, a Notice
of Public Hearing to consider amending Lodi Municipal Code Chapter 13.20 — Electrical
Service — by repealing and reenacting Section 13.20.175, "Schedule ECA — Energy Cost
Adjustment," in its entirety to include flat energy cost adjustment option (attached and
marked as Exhibit A) was posted at the following locations:
Lodi Public Library
Lodi City Clerks Office
Lodi City Hall Lobby
Lodi Carnegie Forum
declare under penalty of perjurythat the foregoing is true and correct.
Executed on April 5, 2012, at Lodi, California.
JENNIFER M. ROBISON, CMC
ORDERED BY:
RANDI JOHL
CITY CLERK
OIL/ A► A A LSV
M"Ai C RRA
ASSISTANT CITY CLERK • DMINISTRATIVE CLERK
N:\Administration\CLERKWorms\DECPOSTEUD.DOC
CITY OF LODI
Carnegie Forum
305 West Pine Street, Lodi
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
Date: April 18, 2012
Time: 7:00 p.m.
For information regarding this notice please contact:
Randi Johl
City Clerk
Telephone: (209) 333-6702
t> •V liBiT A
r �
OF PUBLIC TEARING
NOTICE B HEREBY GIVEN that on Wednesday, April 18, 2012, at the hour of
7:00 p.m., or as soon thereafter as the matter may be heard, the City Council will
conduct a public hearing at the Carnegie Forum, 305 West Pine Street, Lodi, to
consider the following matter:
a) Amending Lodi Municipal Code Chapter 13.20 — Electrical Service —
by repealing and reenacting Section 13.20.175, "Schedule ECA —
Energy Cost Adjustment," in its entirety to include flat energy cost
adjustment option.
Information regarding this item may be obtained in the Electric Utility
Department, 1331 South Ham Lane, Lodi, (209) 333-6762. All interested persons
are invited to present their views and comments on this matter. Written
statements may be filed with the City Clerk, City Hall, 221 West Pine Street,
2r° Floor, Lodi, 95240, at any time prior to the hearing scheduled herein, and oral
statements may be made at said hearing.
If you challenge the subject matter in court, you may be limited to raising only
those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this
notice or in written correspondence delivered to the City Clerk, 221 West Pine
Street, at or prior to the close of the public hearing.
By..
pi
Ra nhf
City Clerk
r of the Lodi City Council:
Dated: April 4, 2012
Approved as to form:
D. Stephen Schwabauer
City Attorney
j
CLERKIPUBHEARINOTICESINoteud,doc 3/29/12