HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes - July 8, 2008 SSCITY OF LODI
INFORMAL INFORMATIONAL MEETING
"SHIRTSLEEVE" SESSION
CARNEGIE FORUM, 305 WEST PINE STREET
TUESDAY, JULY 8, 2008
An Informal Informational Meeting ("Shirtsleeve" Session) of the Lodi City Council was held Tuesday,
July 8, 2008, commencing at 7:02 a.m.
A. ROLL CALL
Present: Council Members — Johnson, Katzakian, and Mayor Mounce
Absent: Council Members — Hansen and Hitchcock
Also Present: City Manager King, City Attorney Schwabauer, and City Clerk Johl
B. TOPIC(S)
B-1 "Lodi Animal Advisory Commission Presentation"
City Manager King briefly introduced the subject matter of the Lodi Animal Advisory
Commission.
Special Services Manager Jeanie Biskup introduced the members of the Lodi Animal
Advisory Commission.
Rose Hilliard provided a PowerPoint presentation regarding lifesaving shelter programs.
Specific topics of discussion included lifesaving strategies, reducing shelter intake,
increasing lifesaving, lifesaving model, feral cat program, spay and neuter, rescue groups,
volunteer foster program, comprehensive adoption programs, pet retention, medical and
behavioral rehabilitation, public retention and community involvement, volunteers,
compassionate shelter director, and the need for change immediately.
In response to Mayor Mounce, Ms. Hilliard stated some of the ten suggested programs are
being completed by volunteers, although to a lesser degree than is necessary through an
organized program.
In response to Council Member Johnson, Ms. Hilliard stated there are three bona fide
501(c)(3) organizations in Lodi including the Cat Connection, Animal Friends, and People
Assisting the Lodi Shelter (PALS).
In response to Mayor Mounce, Ms. Biskup stated the City transfers animals to PALS for
adoption purposes and the animals are then pulled fom PALS by Animal Friends, Cat
Connection, and the city of Sacramento. She stated staff contacts and works with
approximately 15 different facilities.
In response to Council Member Johnson, Ms. Biskup stated the city of Sacramento pulls
adoptable dogs, of which 89% are directly adopted through the City as well. Ms. Biskup
stated in general Sacramento has the same issues with cats as Lodi and other
communities.
Linda Castelanelli spoke in favor of the programs as presented and requested a previous
office clerk position be filled for assistance at the animal shelter.
Ms. Biskup provided a brief update on the funding that was approved through the 2008-09
budget process, stating staff is actively working on spay and neuter programs and physical
improvements at the shelter as discussed.
In response to Mayor Mounce, Ms. Biskup stated shelter needs include bedding, food,
leashes, and other items listed online. She stated monetary donations and assistance with
fundraising for PALS, special needs animals, and spay and neuter programs is also helpful.
1
Continued July 8, 2008
In response to Council Member Johnson, Police Chief David Main stated that, while the City
continues to work toward a "no loll" goal and progress is being made, the numbers of
animals involved make it somewhat unrealistic.
Michael Leach spoke in favor of marketing efforts by the City to increase public awareness
of the animal shelter and its services.
In response to Mayor Mounce and Mr. King, Ms. Biskup stated previously the part-time
shared position budget was reduced and full-time cleaning staff was retained as was
necessary. Ms. Biskup stated Partners assist with office staffing at the shelter currently.
Ms. Castelanelli stated it is important to have a full-time office assistant who is there daily,
is trained, and knows the ins and outs of the shelter since volunteers do not have the ability
to do that.
In response to Myrna Wetzel, Ms. Biskup stated she does not have the exact number
associated with licensing revenue; although, she believes it was approximately $196,000.
She stated the shelter is working with a new licensing system and of the approximately
50,000 animals in the City about 3,000 are licensed.
Discussion ensued between Mayor Mounce, Mr. King, and Ms. Hilliard regarding the
traditional function of disease control for shelters, animal control efforts, contracting for
animal housing services, united effort between cities in the community in resolving animal
control issues through a joint powers agreement or similar entity, the City's responsibility
for a safe and clean shelter, the Commission's desire to work on a more detailed outline of
the programs, and a possible mission statement from the City for the shelter.
Michael Leach spoke in opposition to contracting out animal shelter services based on his
concerns of the level of service over an extended period of time.
Mayor Mounce asked the Commission to forward information regarding San Francisco's
efforts in reaching its "no kill" goal to the City Manager.
Gina Mendes spoke in opposition to contracting out animal shelter services based on her
concern that the shelter should be run like a business.
C. COMMENTS BY THE PUBLIC ON NON -AGENDA ITEMS
None.
D. ADJOURNMENT
No action was taken by the City Council. The meeting was adjourned at 8:02 a.m.
ATTEST:
Randi Johl
City Clerk
W
AGENDA ITEM OPO I
CITY OF LODI
COUNCIL COMMUNICATION
• TM
AGENDA TITLE: Lodi Animal Advisory Commission Presentation
MEETING DATE: July 8, 2008
PREPARED B Y David Main, Chief of Police
RECOMMENDED ACTION: Lodi Animal Advisory Commission members will present a model
Animal Shelter Lifesaving Program.
BACKGROUND INFORMATION: Lodi Animal Advisory Commission members Linda Castelanelli and
Rose Hilliard will present a 10-pointAnimal Shelter lifesaving
program to the City Council covering the following:
1. Feral CatTraptNeuter/Release program
2. High Volume, Low Cost Spay/Neuter
3. Rescue Groups
4. Foster Care
5. Comprehensive Adoption Programs
6. Pet Retention Programs and trainings
7. Medical & Behavioral Rehabilitation Programs
8. Public Relations/Community Involvement Program
9. Volunteers
10. A compassionate Shelter Director
FISCAL IMPACT:
FUNMNG AVAILABLE
cc: City Attorney
Unknown
Unknown
David Main
Chief of Police
APPROVED:
qT*ing, City Manager
Lifesaving Shelter Programs
10 Essential Programs & Services
Presenter: Rose Hilliard, Vice President, Abandoned Cat Team- April 2008 —
to Lodi Animal Advisory Commission
Life Saving Strategies
• # 1 - Reduce intake of
homeless dogs & cats
into the shelter through
various programs
• # 2 — Implement proven
life saving programs for
animals impounded
#1 -Reducing Shelter Intake
• Primary Means— Subsidized
Spay/Neuter for low income
residents & problem pet
populations (feral cats & Pit
Bull dogs)
• Secondary Means- Pet
Retention Programs —
Behavior Hot Line &
Counseling, Subsidies for
Medical Care, Feral Cat
Help & Counseling
f
# 2 — Increasing Lifesaving
• City management & shelter staff attitude
shift to a proactive, community based
adoption & rescue agency rather than
simply a reactive public health or police
enforcement oriented shelter
• By working with their community,
implementing lifesaving programs and
treating each animal's life as precious, a
shelter can energize, excite and
transform an entire community.
Life Saving Model
1) Feral Cat T/N/R program
2) High Volume, Low Cost Spay/Neuter
3) Rescue Groups
4) Foster Care
5) Comprehensive Adoption Programs
6) Pet Retention Programs
7) Medical & Behavioral Rehabilitation
8) Public Relations/Community Involvement
91 Volunteers
i
10) A Compassionate Shelter Director
1) Feral Cat TIN/R Program
Trap/Neuter/Return
v r= 2. ri
Humane for cats
Reduces shelter intake
- +
Reduces death rates
Meets obligations for public
welfare (Rabies control)
• Reduces cat nuisance
complaints & calls
Maintains neighborhood
= ,
tranquility demanded by
governments
• Stabilizes & diminishes feral
5
cat colonies
Costs less than trap & kill
- .
methods
-
Is both effective & humane
by more
• Preferred & aTe
/o of than 80° public
• Targeted spay/neuter
quickly leads to fewer
animals entering the
shelter, less field calls
& phone calls, less
paperwork, less
supplies, less killing &
leaves more
resources for saving
lives.
IV
0
I
3) Rescue Groups
d& 0
Adoption or transfer to a
rescue:
Frees up shelter cage
space
• Reduces expense of
feeding, care & killing
• Saves staff time
• Increases a
community's lifesaving
rate
• Greatly increases I ives saved
• Provides an opportunity for the
community to be involved & to
volunteer
• Allows for care of animals that
are difficult in a shelter— the
orphaned, sick, injured, or in
need of behavior rehabilitation
• Promotes a positive shelter
image while creating greater
awareness in the community of
animals in need
L
*.::
Swo For
AftWe Peft
In Your Ommunity
• Vital to the lifesaving mission of a
shelter
• The number & the quality of adoptions
lies directly in shelter management's
hands
• Shelters need to better promote &
market sheltered animals to the public
(studies show only 10 — 15% of people get their
pets from a shelter)
• Animals must be widely and easily
available to the community — ie: on
websites, through media, at the
shelter, on weekends, evenings and
at off site adoptions
• Shelters can and should adopt their
way out of killing
• Some surrenders can be
prevented when shelters work
with people to help solve their
pet problems —reducing intake
• The more a community sees
their shelter as a place to turn
to for help, the easier this
becomes.
• Examples: Pet care & behavior
fact sheets in the shelter & on
the website, low cost dog
training classes, pet friendly
housing rental lists, pet sitter
referrals, news articles on
behavior issues.
r
_,"ti
• Shelter begins saving treatable
animals by analyzing statistics to
identify:
what injuries/illnesses are most common?
What behavior problems are encountered?
How many are underage or elderly animals?
• Each problem will need a different
lifesaving program or policy
• Professional volunteers can often
help( Trainers, veterinarians, vet techs,
experienced fosterers)
• If the shelter itself or staff is
creating illnesses or injury—
training,proper care & adequate
p p q
facilities must be addressed
• The public may donate to a
behavior or injury fund created to
help those needy animals
• Shelter must redefine itself as a "pet
rescue" agency.
• Public must see improvements at
the shelter & in the area of lifesaving's
• Public contacts through good
customer service, more adoptions,
tangible commitments to tools
shelter needs to do the job
humanely 140
4
• Positive PR is key to more money, h
volunteers, adoptions and good will
• Shelter must be in the public's eye
9) Volunteers
*The "army of compassion" — the
backbone of shelter lifesaving
There is never enough staff,
enough dollars to hire more staff
& always more needs than paid
human resources.
Volunteers make the difference
between success & failure — and
for the animals between life &
death.
eThe purpose of a volunteer
program is to help the shelter
help the animals
Crucial to have procedures &
goals in place as part of the
program.
Ot (1" 4% r
l� }
e
10) A Compassionate Shelter
Director
• Most important of all the 10
elements!
• Must be hard working &
compassionate with the goal
of saving lives, not making
excuses for why the shelter
kills animals
• Traditional animal sheltering
experience is often NOT
desirable — a new can -do
attitude is essential
• Director's performance is
judged by success in saving
animals lives
Change is Happening Now
To the extent that a shelter is not implementing all elements of this
lifesaving model, animals are needlessly being killed.
• 1994 — San Francisco begins saving 100% of healthy & treatable
animals & 100% of feral cats
• 2001 — 2003 Tomkins County, NY saw a 75% decrease in shelter death
rates
• 2005 - 2006 Philadelphia Animal Control doubled the percent of
animals saved in only 8 months (having previously killed 80% of their
animals)
• 2006 - Charlottesville, NC SPCA saved 92% of all animals sheltered
• 2007 - Reno, NV SPCA Killing has decreased by 51% for dog & 52%
for cats since 2006 (within 1 Year)
The Clock is Ticking
Every life is precious to that animal and ending any animal's life is an
extremely serious decision. Each and every animal is an individual and
each deserves individual consideration —the very young, the frightened, the
very old, the cat or dog with a treatable illness or injury, the so called "bad"
breeds & the wild cats as well. , _ , .� .,.
Mr
iNr• Al
r
Their Lives Are in Our Hands
• If we don't act tonight, by the time of
our next commission meeting, the
Lodi Animal Shelter will put to death
approximately another 90 cats ( at
least 36 of them healthy ferals) and
another 10 dogs (many will be Pits or
Pit mixes).
• We have the authority and support of
the Lodi Mayor & city council to
recommend immediate lifesaving
shelter & policy changes. Let's do it!
PALS
People Assisting Lodi Shelter
MAKING MIRACLES
HAPPEN AT THE
LODI ANIMAL SHELTER
PALS
People Assisting Lodi Shelter
History
• BEGAN WITH A DEDICATED GROUP OF VOLUNTEERS
INCLUDING DAUNIS BRADSHAW WHO WERE ASSISTING
AT THE LODI ANIMAL SHELTER SEVERAL DAYS A
WEEK, CLEANING CAT CAGES, HELPING ADMINISTER
MEDICATIONS, SOCIALIZATION AND GROOMING.
• A BOARD WAS FORMED AND A MISSION ESTABLISHED.
FUNDRAISING AND DONATIONS WERE OBTAINED FROM
INDIVIDUALS AND ORGANIZATIONS.
. AN AGREEMENT WAS MADE WITH THE CITY OF LODI
TO ESTABLISH AN ADOPTION CENTER ON PROPERTY
ADJACENT TO THE ANIMAL SHELTER
• ADOPTION CENTER (THE FORMER SKATE PARK
BUILDING) WAS MOVED, THE INTERIOR WAS DESIGNED
WITH 4 CAT ROOMS WITH FREE ROAMING CATS AND A
GET- ACQUAINTED ROOM. THE ADOPTION CENTER HAS
LAUNDRY, CLEANING AND GROOMING FACILITIES
AND OFFICE SPACE FOR ADOPTION PAPERWORK.
PALS ACCOMPLISHMENTS
• IMPROVEMENTS TO THE LODI ANIMAL SHELTER
+ RECEIVED GRANT FROM LODI LION'S CLUB FOR
INFORMATIONAL SIGN AT KETTLEMAN LANE, NEW
KENNELS ETC.
• ADOPTION CENTER ESTABLISHED
HUNDREDS OF ANIMALS HAVE BEEN ADOPTED
- MANY OF WHICH WOULD BE CONSIDERED
UNADOPTABLE DUE TO MEDICAL ISSUES ,
BEHAVIOUR OR AGE
• APPLIED FOR AND RECEIVED MADDIE' S GRANT WHICH
WILL BE USED FOR ADVERTISING, EDUCATION AND
STATISTICS
• ESTABLISHED PETFINDER ACCOUNT TO HELP THE
PUBLIC ADOPT A NEW COMPANION
• UPDATED WEBSITE SO THE PUBLIC CAN LEARN ABOUT
WAYS TO HELP THE ANIMAL SHELTER
• APPLIED TO THE LODI ARTS COMMISSION AND WAS
GRANTED A PUBLIC ART PIECE TO BRING ATTENTION
TO THE SHELTER THE MURAL DESIGNED BY TONY
SEGALE IS NOW COMPLETE
. FENCED EXERCISE AREA BUILT INFRONT OF SHELTER
VALUE OF THESE ACCOMPLISHMENTS EXCEEDS
$2509000!
THIS DOES NOT INCLUDE THE VALUE OF THE THOUSANDS
OF VOLUNTEER HOURS DONATED TO THE CITY OF LODI!
PALS Expenditures 1 stand 2nd Quarters of 2008
V4Z'x
�
�
Total
r
n i
Includes
Includes
PALS pays
Includes
Paymentsfor
includes
ADT Alarm
Includes the
Liability
special
Healthwise
$25.00
vaccinations,
advertising,
advertising
System and
new dog
and
surgeries and
Food, KMR,
towards
microchips
statistics
for special
Glearwire
exercise
insurance
ail medical care
and KV Vet
spay or
and feline
and
events
area
on building
for City of Lodi
supplies and
neuterof
leukemia test
inventory
animals located
ail animal
shelter
kits
control
in PALS
related
animal
adoption center
supplies
$8,3'10.37
$3,187.65
$863.00
$11,993.02
$2,429.00
$4,158.88
$1,386.14
$9,839.44
$690.07
$42,857.57
PALS VOLUNTEER HOURS
MAY 07 — DEC 07 - 5,588
JANUARY 1-31,2008 - 893
These hours are for those working in the
PALS Adoption Center, cleaning, feeding,
socializing, grooming, medicating of cats
and dogs, adoption paperwork for the City
of Lodi, dog walking and promotion of
adoptions through PALS newsletter, pet
page and petfinder.
They do not include the hundreds of
volunteer hours for fundraising, vet runs and
fostering.
ADOPT[OP
HOURS
L �I
-' 4 �Cad vv � SAT
i
c
F'
"�,
�.
�.
i
t � �
.f
- �,-
��
a
�
`�� �
f„
p:.'.
_
�:� _
"'�"A�
�zg`1
1
�e
F
'=t''�E �.
r
.,,�
'�
k�'
y E�
i
��
�'^
{YY{��,, 3fi � -
� ���C` x'21\" ..
�'`
� y
� � yy
�� t i'-
r,,. xx-:
Ito MTV
molt
•xxt.:s:re�;rnas
a7E:S7a i.::pCR53IIm, 1: A t r _.. �.. •� .
':;irr�r��fr.::
u�+:u:Asat
$j "S4i
G
�
u
6
ebb
Ito MTV
molt
•xxt.:s:re�;rnas
a7E:S7a i.::pCR53IIm, 1: A t r _.. �.. •� .
':;irr�r��fr.::
u�+:u:Asat
Fy
Ito MTV
molt
•xxt.:s:re�;rnas
a7E:S7a i.::pCR53IIm, 1: A t r _.. �.. •� .
':;irr�r��fr.::
u�+:u:Asat