HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes - November 15, 1989107
CITY COUNCIL, CITY OF LODI
CARNEGIE FORUM, 305 WEST PINE STREET
WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 15, 1989
7:30 P.M.
ROLL CALL Present: Council Members - Hinchman, Olson, Reid,
Pinkerton and Snider (Mayor)
Absent: Council Members - None
Also Present: City Manager Peterson, Assistant City
Manager Glenn, Community Development
Director Schroeder, Public Works Director
Ronsko, City Attorney McNatt, Deputy City
Clerk Perrin and City Clerk Reimche
INVOCATION The invocation was given by Pastor Don Thomas, Lodi
Community Church.
PLEDGE OF The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Mayor Snider.
ALLEGIANCE
4
PRESENTATIONS A proclamation for "Scouting for Food Good Turn Week" in
Lodi was presented to Patricia Menough and her troup of Boy
Scouts.
CONSENT CALENDAR In accordance with report and recommendation of the City
Manager, Council, on motion of Council Member Reid, Olson
second, approved the following items hereinafter set
forth. Further, Agenda item No. E-11 - "Class
Specifications for Automotive Parts Coordinator" was
removed from the agenda.
CLAIMS CC -21(a) Claims were approved in the amount of 2,260,411.44.
MINUTES The Minutes of October 4, 1989, October 24, 1989 (Special
Meeting), and October 31, 1989 (Special Meeting) were
approved.as written.
PLANS AND SPECIFICATIONS
FOR LANE LINE PAINTING,
VARIOUS STREETS, 1989
WERE APPROVED AS WRITTEN
CC -12.1(c) The City Council approved the specifications for Lane Line
Painting, Various Streets 1989, and authorized advertising
for bids to be received Wednesday, November 29, 1989.
This project provides painting of land lines on arterial
and collector streets on an annual basis, and approximately
50 percent of residential streets. Should the actual bid
I
108
Continued November 15, 1989
be less than the amount budgeted, the difference will be
used to paint additional lane lines.
A recap of lane lines and quantities is shown below:
Lane Line Miles
Broken White/Yellow
Double Yellow
Eight -inch Solid White
Edge Line
Transitional
Federal Left Turn
Total Miles
SPECIFICATIONS APPROVED AND
AUTHORIZATION TO ADVERTISE FOR
BIDS FOR THE PURCHASE OF
HIGH-PRESSURE SODIUM LUMINAIRES
GRANTED
45.3
12.6
2.2
4.4
0.6
4.8
WE
CC -12.1(a) The City Council approved the specifications for the
purchase of a total of 200 High -Pressure Sodium Luminaires
and authorized advertisement for bids thereon. The
requirements include 120 100 -watt and 80 250 -watt
luminaires.
The bid opening date has been scheduled for Tuesday,
November 28, 1989.
The Electric Util.ity Department has issued preliminary work
orders to replace Mercury Vapor lights with the more
economical High Pressure Sodium lights.
Some of the areas where the conversions will take place are:
Turner Road between Stockton Street and Ham Lane, and
Lower Sacramento Road to Rutiege/Rainier/Garden Drives,
between Turner Road and Lodi Avenue
A portion of the quantity purchased will be placed in
inventory to support routine maintenance and replacement.
Their estimated cost of this purchase is $16,000. Funding
is available for this purchase in the Public Works/Street
Light Maintenance account.
04
Continued November 15, 1989 1 o,9
SPECIFICATIONS APPROVED AND
AUTHORIZATION TO ADVERTISE
FOR WATTHOUR METERS GRANTED
CC -12.1(c) The City Council approved the specifications for the
purchase of 576 watthour meters and authorized
advertisement for bids thereon.
The bid opening date has been scheduled for Tuesday,
November 28, 1989.
The meters will be used to meter electric energy usage at
the following developments:
Sunwest 9, 10 and 11
Almond Drive Apartments
Geweke Estates
In addition, the meters will be required for other smaller
developments throughout the City, to maintain an inventory
for other needs as they develop, and for replacement of
obsolete and deteriorated meters located during meter
testing.
The estimated cost of this purchase is $19,000, with
delivery expected about 8 weeks after placement of order.
Funding is available in the Electric Utility Department's
operating fund.
PURCHASE OF WASTEWATER
COLLECTION SYSTEM MANAGEMENT
SOFTWARE
RES. NO. 89-163
CC -12(d) The City Council approved the purchase of the Hansen
CC -47 Software Inc., Wastewater Collection System Management
CC -300 Software.
On August 16, 1989, the City Council approved a Request for
Proposals (RFP) for the Wastewater Collection System
Management Software (WCSM). The program is to be used for
scheduling, tracking, and generating work orders for both
preventative and non-scheduled maintenance work and for
general wastewater system management. The RFP was for a
turnkey system, including entry of existing data. The
system was to be simple and understandable to non-technical
users, as it is to be used by maintenance and clerical
staff at the Municipal Service Center.
Four vendors responded. Their proposals were generally
complete and responsive to the points raised in the RFP.
The following is a summary of the costs:
3
110
Continued November 15, 1989
i
1
Vendor Software Data Entry* Training Total
RJN Computer $ 8,500.00 $ 81010.00 $ 4,500.00 $21,010.00
Services, Inc.
Wheaton, IL
Hansen Software, $ 4,200.00 $19,550.00 $ 1,050.00 $24,800.00
Inc.
Sacramento, CA
CH2M Hill $10,000.00 $27,500.00 Included $36,500.00
Emeryville, CA
Public Works $11,130.00 $25,500.00 $ 1,600.00 $38,230.00
Software, Inc.
Port Hueneme, CA
*Date Entry includes an amount for estimated number of existing reports, as
stated in the RFP, at the unit price proposed.
Due to the high cost of the CH2M Hill and Public Works
Software, those packages were reviewed relatively quickly.
Staff noted that the CH2M Hill software would be custom
written for the City's application. This would be fine if
the wastewater staff could concisely and completely express
what was needed, however, staff's feeling has been that we
are better off working with a commercial package that has
gone through this process many times. In addition, future
enchancements would be custom made and therefore relatively
costly, whereas commercial packages are regularly updated,
with the cost shared among many users who purchase the
upgrade.
The RJN and Hansen packages were investigated closely and
other users contacted. Staff prefers the Hansen package
for the following reasons:
1. Site License - The Hansen price is for the
City of Lodi as one site. We will be able
to run copies on other computers, such as
engineering or administration to do analysis
and review or for training purposes. The
RJN proposal is for one computer. A site
license from RJN for the modules proposed
would cost approximately $3,000. If this
cost were added to provide an equal basis of
comparison, the cost difference between the
two proposals is less than $1,000.
2. Proximity of Company - The Hansen company is
located in Sacramento, meaning on-site help
is very close at hand. While RJN, located
in Illinois, is willing to be present at
start-up and training time and occasionally
4
Continued November 15, 1989
has a representative in the area, there is
no doubt that eventually on-site help will
be more available and less expensive through
Hansen. This is evident in the training
prices.
3. User Group - The Hansen package has over 12
users within 100 miles, while RJN has none.
Based on the Department's experience with
other software (mainly the computer-aided
drafting system), a local users' group is a
tremendous asset. We have found that ideas
exchanged at user group meetings are often
more helpful than vendors' instructions.
Also, we can visit other users and learn
from their experiences how to make the most
of the software.
4. Future Enhancements/Software Features - RJN
is an engineering company with a number of
different packages using different database
systems and/or query languages. The
package proposed for Lodi is one combination
of their various systems. Hansen is a
software company with one basic wastewater
package that is upgraded periodically, based
upon user requests and other marketing or
programming considerations. (Both companies
have software for other applications.) It
is staff's feeling that the Hansen package
will have better product support and
enhancements over the long run. This is
evident now in the various software features
available in the Hansen package such as
pop-up windows and graphics.
PURCHASE OF SELF-CONTAINEn
BREATHING APPARATUS, FACE
PIECES, AND EQUIPMENT FOR THE
FIRE DEPARTMENT
RES. NO. 89-164
CC -12(d) The City Council approved the purchase of MSA Face Pieces,
CC -47 Regulator Conversion Kits, and two Ultra Lite SCBA units.
CC -300
The Fire Department is presently equipped with
Self -Contained Breathing Apparatus (SCBA) manufactured by
the MSA company. In the 1989-90 budget the purchase of
additional equipment and the necessary items to upgrade
current SCBA were approved. The upgrading is required by
OSHA regulations and will add to the present safety of our
personnel. Since it is against OSHA regulations to mix and
match this type of equipment, staff is requesting to
112 Continued November 15, 1989
i
purchase the equipment through the Special T Company of
Santa Rosa California. Purchasing Agent, Joel Harris has
checked with the MSA company and was told that Special T is
their Northern California Distributor.
A break down of the purchase requested is as follows:
Face pieces with breather tube
and neck strap $5,800.00
#486182 conversion kits $5,650.00
Two Ultra Lite SCBA $2,950.00
Two cases for Ultra Lite SCBA $ 191.00
$14,591.00
The 1989-90 Budget contains $14,755.00 for the purchase of
this equipment. The funds are budgeted in the Equipment
Fund, 12.0-012.01-20; 12.0-012.01-22; and in the General
Fund, 10.0-201.01-306.
PURCHASE OF POWER SCOPE
RES. NO. 89-165
CC -12(d) The City Council authorized the purchase of a Power Scope
CC -47 from the sole supplier, SMI (Basic Measuring CC -300
Instruments), Foster City, CA, in the amount of $17,285.50.
This analysis equipment will be used to detect power line
disturbances, analyze such disturbances, detect their cause
and help select solutions. In today's world, highly
penetrated with microprocessors, our ability to get to the
root of a "dirty power" problem is both a service an
electric utility is expected to offer and an important
aspect in minimizing claims and litigations.
The Electric Utility Department has done extensive research
on known available equipment for this type of analysis.
Two manufacturers clearly outdistance all others and of
these two, one is far superior in equipment capability,
speed of response, automatic data retention, interface
capability, and ease of use. These features are all
required by the Department in order to have equipment that
can be left at a customer's premise to monitor and retain
all abnormal events and conditions for subsequent analysis.
Funding in the amount of $17,500 was included in the
Electric Utility Department's 1989-90 fiscal year budget.
R
Continued November 15, 1989
PURCHASE OF COPY MACHINES
FOR THE FIRE DEPARTMENT AND
THE PARKS AND RECREATION
DEPARTMENT APPROVED
RES. NO. 89-166
CC -12(d) The City Council awarded the bid for the purchase of two
CC -47 copy machines, one for the Fire Department and one for the
CC -300 Parks and Recreation Department, to the low bidder,
Business Office Systems of Stockton, bidding Minolta
EP -4300 machines. The total bid for the two copiers is
$13,423.84.
It was also recommended that the City Council approve the
purchase of a large -capacity (2,000 -sheet) paper tray
option for the Parks and Recreation Department copier at an
incremental cost of $609.50. Total cost of the purchase
would then be $14,033.34.
On October 18, 1989, the City Council approved
specifications and authorized advertisement for bids. Bids
were opened on November 1.
Bid prices and evaluation results are shown below:
Bidder Equipment Total
Business Office Syst. Minolta EP -4300 $13,423.84
Stockton, CA
Pitney Bowes P.B. D-230 $13,578.60
Sacramento, CA
California Copy Ricoh 5520 $14,999.00
Stockton, CA
Lucas Business Syst. Konica 3290 $15,170.30
Bid evaluations included comparisons of purchase price as
well as estimated five-year supplies and maintenance
contract costs. Supplies and maintenance costs were based
on estimated annual volumes of 90,000 and 175,000 copies,
respectively, for the Fire and Parks Departments.
Most copiers in the specified capability range come
equipped with 250 -sheet main paper trays. With the
estimated monthly volume for the Parks and Recreation
Department in the 14,000 to 15,000 copy range, it was
recommended that the large capacity tray be added to reduce
the number of paper reloads per month from 58 to 8.
A total of $15,000 ($7,500 each machine) has been budgeted
for this purchase in the 12 -Equipment Fund.
7
114
Continued November 15, 1989
ACCEPTANCE OF IMPROVEMENTS
UNDER TYPE II SLURRY SEAL,
VARIOUS CITY STREETS,
1989/90 CONTRACT
CC -90 The City Council accepted the improvements for "Type II
Slurry Seal, Various City Streets, 1989/90 Contract" and
directed the Public Works Director to file a Notice of
Completion with the County Recorder's Office.
The contract was awarded to Graham Contractors, Inc., of
San Jose on August 16, 1989, in the amount of $40,996.61.
The contract has been completed in substantial conformance
with the plans and specifications approved by the City
Council.
The contract completion date was October 27, 1989, and the
actual completion date was October 19, 1989. The final
contract price is $39,782.93. The difference between the
contract amount and the final contract price is mainly due
to 26,970 square feet dropped from the schedule after bids
were received.
MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING
BETWEEN THE CITY OF LODI
AND THE POLICE OFFICERS'
ASSOCIATION OF LODI
RES. NO. 89-168
CC -34 The City Council took the following actions pertaining to
CC -300 the Memorandum of Understanding between the City of Lodi
and the Police Officers' Association of Lodi:
1. Received the new Memorandum of Understanding
between the City of Lodi and the Police
Officers' Association of Lodi;
2. Adopted Resolution No. 89-168, thereby
revising the salary schedule for represented
police employees and mid -management police
personnel; and
3. Appropriated funds for police safety
equipment and salary changes.
The City of Lodi and the Police Officers' Association of
Lodi have recently agreed to a new Memorandum of
Understanding which calls for adjustments to their salary
schedule effective the pay period commencing October 2,
1989. This revised schedule is set forth below:
W
Continued November 15, 1989 i 1.5
MONTHLY SALARY
TITLE STEP: A B C 0 E
Police Officer Trainee $2055.33 $2158.10 $2266.00 $2379.30 $2498.27
Police Officer Trainee II 2055.33 2158.10 2266.00 2379.30 2498.27
Police Officer 2379.30 2498.27 2623.18 2754.34 2892.06
Police Sergeant 2814.96 2955.71 3103.50 3258.67 3421.60
Police Lieutenant 3258.67 3421.60 3592.68 3772.31 3960.93
Police Captain 3772.31 3960.93 4158.98 4366.92 4585.27
This increase results in corresponding increases for sworn
Police Mid -Management classifications, which are also
presented.
Council also appropriated funds for police safety equipment
and salary changes from the General Fund Operating
Reserve. The amounts to be appropriated are listed by
object code below:
Object Code Description Amount
101 Salary $ 92,870
101 Special Allowances 19,990
111 Workers' Compensation 4,690
112 Medical Insurance [5,745]
113 Dental Insurance 4,500
121 Pension 24,815
123 Deferred Compensation 1,875
306 Safety Equipment 20,000
Total $162,905
G]
11.6
Continued November 15, 1989
PUBLIC HEARING SET FOR
DECEMBER 6, 1989 REGARDING
APPEAL OF NOTICE OF PUBLIC
NUISANCE, ORDER TO ABATE AND
ORDER TO VACATE RECEIVED FROM
THE OWNER OF THE TRAVELERS
HOTEL, 112 NORTH SCHOOL STREET
CC -24(c) The City Council set a public hearing for December 6, 1989
regarding the appeal of Notice of Public Hearing, Order to
Abate and Order to Vacate received from the owner of the
Travelers Hotel, 112 North School Street
On December 2, 1987, an inspection of the premises was
conducted by the Community Development Department/Building
Division and the Fire Department. As a result of this
inspection, a NOTICE OF PUBLIC NUISANCE AND ORDER TO ABATE
was issued by the Community Development Department/Building
Division on December 16, 1987. On December 31, 1987, a
letter was sent to the building owner by the Fire
Department listing items that required corrective action.
On April 14, 1988, a second letter was sent by the Fire
Department indicating those items that were not corrected,
and in addition required that an approved second exit be
installed.
On October 6, 1988, Mr. Surenda Patel, the owner of the
subject property, contacted the Fire Department and
indicated that he would install the fire escape and that
plans would be available October 7, 1988. .
On April 26, 1989, an inspection was conducted by the Fire
Department and a NOTICE OF PUBLIC NUISANCE AND ORDER TO
ABATE was issued.
Telephone conversations and correspondence continued until
September 7, 1989, at which time a NOTICE TO VACATE in
addition to a NOTICE OF PUBLIC NUISANCE AND ORDER TO ABATE
were issued and posted on the premises on September 8, 1989.
On September 12, 1989, a letter was delivered by Mr. Patel
requesting that he be granted a period of 90 days to comply
due to financial hardship. Consultation with the City
Attorney resulted in a decision to consider this request as
a form of appeal. This would allow Mr. Patel approximately
90 days and still provide for the continuance of abatement
proceedings.
Section 15.28.070 et seq. of the Lodi Municipal Code
provides that the City Council shall set a public hearing
to consider appeals received in these matters at which time
all interested parties may appear and show cause why the
10
Continued November 15, 1989
building(s) or structure(s) involved in the proceedings
should not be repaired, vacated and repaired or demolished.
ADOPTED URGENCY ORDINANCE
AUTHORIZING THE DELIVERY
OF UNCLAIMED BICYCLES AND
TOYS FOR THE MAYOR'S ANNUAL
HOLIDAY CHILD SHARE PROGRAM
ORDINANCE NO. 1471
(URGENCY ORDINANCE)
CC -6 The City Council adopted Urgency Ordinance No. 1471 thereby
CC -39 authorizing the delivery of unclaimed bicycles and toys to
CC -149 the Lodi Service Center and Salvation Army Service
Extension Committee for the Mayor's Annual Holiday Child
Share Program.
Last year, the Lodi Service Center, working in conjunction
with the U. S. Marine Corps "Toys For Tots" campaign
requested and received all unclaimed bicycles and toys held
by the Lodi Police Department, in lieu of selling them at
auction. These items were then distributed to
underprivileged children.
However, due to lack of staffing, the Marine Corps is not
involved this year in that activity. Instead, the Lodi
Service Center is working in conjunction with Robert
Friedberger of the Lodi Salvation Army Service Extension
Committee, to accomplish the same goals. A letter from
Margaret Velasquez, of the Lodi Service Center, is shown
below. The program will be known as "The Mayor's Annual
Holiday Child Share Program".
Dear Mrs. Reimche:
I am writing this letter to request your assistance in
obtaining some of the unclaimed bicycles accumulated at the
Police Department as we were able to do last year.
These bicycles represent a very substantial gift to the
underprivileged youths of our Lodi community.
We would like to request that these bicycles be made
available as soon as possible in order that we might
refurbish them in time for our Christmas Basket Giveway.
I further wish to inform you that the marines are no longer
going to handle the toys for tots due to lack of staff.
However that function will be performed by the Lodi Service
Center in cooperation with Robert Friedberger of the Lodi
Salvation Army Service Extension Committee.
11
118 Continued November 15, 1969
If
On behalf of the Lodi Service Center advisory Board, we
wish you a heartfelt thanks for any assistance you can
provide for the underprivileged children of the community.
If you need more information, please phone 369-7772.
Thank you.
Sincerely yours,
Margaret Velasquez
Welfare and Institutions Code §217 is to be utilized to
authorize delivery of the toys and bicycles to these
organizations for distribution.
The ordinance authorizing the delivery was made on an
urgency basis in order to allow the delivery of the toys in
time for Christmas.
COMMENTS BY CITY
COUNCIL MEMBERS The following comments were received under the "Comments by
City Council Members" segment of the agenda:
REPORT REGARDING
TRANSIT GUIDEWAY
FUNDS
CC -50(b) Council Member Olson asked the City Manager about her
recent report regarding Transit Guideway funds and the
arrangements for a meeting on the subject. The City
Manager suggested having this as an agenda item at a
Council Meeting or the topic of discussion at a Shirtsleeve
Session and inviting Doralee Boles from the Council of
Governments to discuss the matter. Council Member Olson
indicated that it was essential to identify critical rail
transit projects and then set priorities.
LICENSING FEES
OF PETS
CC -56 Council Member Olson shared with the Council a story of a
CC -65 retired man who found some kittens by his house and
complained of the fees involved in taking care of them,
particularly the licensing fees.
SCHOOL BOARD'S
SUGGESTION TO MOVE
THE DISTRICT OFFICE
OUT OF THS DOWNTOWN AREA
CC -7(e) Mayor Pro Tempore Hinchman informed the Council of his
disapproval of the School Board wanting to move the
District Office building out of the downtown area and
12
Continued November 15, 1989
INVITATION TO ATTEND
THE CITY OF STOCKTON
COUNCIL MEETING
119
suggested meeting with the Downtown Business Association to
help encourage the Board to move the District Office to
Needham School.
Mayor Snider invited both the public and the City Council
to join him at the upcoming Stockton City Council meeting
regarding expansion beyond Eight Mile Road.
COMMENTS BY THE
PUBLIC ON NON
AGENDA ITEMS There was no one wishing to speak under the "Comments by
the public on non -agenda items" segment of the agenda:
PUBLIC HEARINGS Notice thereof having been published according to law, an
affidavit of which publication is on file in the office of
the City Clerk, Mayor Snider called for the Public Hearing
to consider Resolution of Necessity to acquire
certain real property by Eminent Domain (5200 East Sargent
Road - Industrial Substation Site)
CLOSED SESSION -
5200 EAST SARGENT ROAD
CC -200(c) Prior to the Public Hearing on the acquisition of certain
CC -200(d) real property by Eminent Domain (5200 East Sargent Road -
Industrial Substation Site), the City Council met in
"Closed Session" regarding the matter and the possible
litigation involving it. The City Council reconvened at
approximately 8:30 p.m.
{
RESOLUTION OF NECESSITY
TO ACQUIRE CERTAIN REAL
PROPERTY BY EMINENT DOMAIN
(5200 EAST SARGENT ROAD -
INDUSTRIAL SUBSTATION SITE)
RES. NO. 89-169
CC -27(f) The matter was introduced by staff who presented diagrams
CC -300 of the subject area. Council was reminded that the City is
presently proceeding with plans for the construction of an
electric utilities industrial substation this location.
The site is presently owned by the heirs of the Diekman
family. Total size of the parcel is approximately 15
acres. Under present plans, construction was to be in
January 1990, and be completed in June 1990, in time to
deal with summertime peak demand periods.
Environmental documents have been finalized and the City
has been negotiating with the owners for more than one
13
120 Continued November 15, 1989
year. The owners have never expressed opposition to the
City's plans, and, in fact, had indicated a willingness to
sign a Right of Entry form allowing the City to commence
construction before the final sales price was determined.
However, it now appears that a voluntary sale may not be
possible between the City and the owners. Our initial
belief that the owners would give voluntary consent for
possession by the City while negotiations on price
continued, was erroneous, and the owners via their attorney
have declined to give such consent. The asking price in
the most recent proposal is nearly double the figure in the
City's original appraisal, and the owners have placed other
conditions on the sale.
The only apparent alternative left to the City if
construction is to be accomplished anywhere near the
timetable established, is to commence condemnation and seek
an order of immediate possession from the Court. Because
there is an occupied residence on the site, a minimum of 90
days would be required to obtain possession if the owners
do not voluntarily have the premises vacated prior to that
time.
An initial decision to be made by the Council is the size
of the parcel which may be condemned. The City originally
considered acquisition of the entire 15 acre Diekman
parcel in order to accommodate the substation and accessory
uses. At the request of the owners, and in the spirit of
cooperation, the City was willing to modify its plans and
split the parcel at the site of the proposed extension of
Thurman Road. That would have created an 8.1 acre parcel
north of the Thurman Road extension for the substation
site, and would have left the owners with a 7 acre parcel
adjacent to Thurman Road on the south side.
If it becomes necessary to acquire the site by eminent
domain, the Council may wish to again consider the entire
15 acre parcel, since the Electric Utility has indicated it
has use for the entire piece, for the substation and
accessory uses. The Notice provided to the owners
describing the condemnation proposed, included the entire
15 acre parcel. Of course, the Council has discretion to
scale that back and acquire only the smaller 8.1 acre
parcel north of the Thurman Road extension, if it wishes
to accommodate the owners.
Under applicable law, Resolutions of Necessity must be
adopted by 2/3 vote of the Council, or in our situation, by
the affirmative vote of 4 Council members.
In the meantime, negotiations are continuing with the
owners to see if a mutually -agreeable solution can be
reached.
14
Continued November 15, 1989
121
Requests to address the Council at the hearing on the issue
of necessity have been received both from the owners and
the tenant. Under State law, the issue of valuation should
not be discussed at this hearing.
City Council discussion followed with questions being
directed to staff.
Mr. Michael Normoyl, lawyer to the Diekmans, 3340 Tully
Road, Suite A, Modesto, 95350, inquired whether or not the
City has decided to purchase the the entire 15+ acres or
the 8.1 acres and indicated that his clients are willing to
go with the 8.1 acre take.
There being no other persons in the audience wishing to
speak on the matter, the public portion of the hearing was
closed.
After a brief discussion, on motion of Council Member Reid,
Hinchman second, the City Council voted to adopt Resolution
of Necessity No. 89-169 as set forth below and directed the
City Attorney to continue negotiations on the per acre
price. The motion carried by unanimous vote of the City
Council.
RESOLUTION NO. 89-169
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LODI
RESOLUTION OF NECESSITY TO ACQUIRE CERTAIN REAL PROPERTY BY EMINENT DOMAIN FOR
MUNICIPAL PURPOSES, PURSUANT TO CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE SECTION 1245.220 ET
SEQ. (5200 EAST SARGENT ROAD: DIEKMAN PROPERTY)
WHEREAS, on October 18, 1989, the Council of the City of Lodi set a
hearing to consider a Resolution of Necessity to Acquire Certain Real Property
described below; and
WHEREAS, on November 15, 1989, the Lodi City Council held a hearing in the
City Council Chambers, Carnegie Forum, 305 West Pine Street, Lodi, in order to
determine the necessity for acquisition of said real property by eminent domain
proceedings for the purposes of a municipal industrial electrical substation;
NOW, THEREFORE, -BE IT RESOLVED by the Lodi City Council as follows:
The Lodi City Council finds, determines, and hereby declares:
1. That the public interest, necessity, and convenience require the
acquisition, construction, and completion of a public improvement, to
wit: the acquisition of a site for an industrial electric substation,
on and across certain real property located at 5200 East Sargent Road,
within San Joaquin County, described as follows:
a. Acquisition in fee.
15
. 1 22 Continued November 15, 1989
Commencing at the northwest corner of the Northeast
Quarter of Section 7, T3N, VE, MDB&M, thence S
0-32'00" E, 100.15 feet, along the west line of said
Quarter Section to the True Point of Beginning, thence
S 87=20'49" E, 533.68 feet, along the southerly line of
the Central California Traction Company, thence S
0-47'19" E, 658.99 feet, along a line parallel with the
east line of said Section 7, thence N 87-2433" W,
536.59 feet, thence N 00-32'00" W, 659.40 feet along
said west line to the True Point of Beginning,
containing 8.1 acres, more or less.
b. Parcels 2 and 3 (easement only).
Easement 1
Commencing at the northwest corner of the Northeast
Quarter of Section 7, T3N, R7E, MDB&M, thence S
0-32'00" E, 759.55 feet along the west line of said
Quarter Section to the True Point of Beginning, thence
S 87-24'33" E, 40.0 feet, thence S 2-35'27" W, 32.0
feet, thence N 87-24'33" W, 38.25 feet, to said west
line, thence N 0-32'00" W, 32.05 feet along said west
line to the True Point of Beginning.
Easement 2
A 60 kv Public Utility Easement being more
particularly described as follows:
Commencing at the northwest corner of the Northeast
Quarter of Section 7, T3N, R7E, MDB&M, thence S
0-32'00" E, 791.60 feet along the west line of said
Quarter Section to the True Point of Beginning, thence
S 87-24'33" E, 16.52 feet, thence S 00-32'00" E, 542.75
feet along a line parallel with said west line to the
south line of the north one-half of said Northeast
Quarter, thence N 87-33'30" W, 16.53 feet along said
south line, thence N 0-32'00" W, 542.80 feet along said
west line to the True Point of Beginning, totalling .24
acres, more or less, (both easements combined).
AND
2. That the real property hereinafter described is suitable,
adaptable, necessary, and required for the public use of
said City of Lodi, as hereinabove set forth.
3. The proposed project is planned and located in the manner
that will be most compatible with the greatest public good
and the least private injury.
16
Continued November 15, 1989 12 3
4. That the City of Lodi acquire the hereinafter described real
property for an industrial electric substation by donation,
purchase, or by condemnation in accordance with the
provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure of the State of
California- relating to eminent domain. That the City
Attorney is hereby authorized to prosecute in the name of
the City of Lodi, any and all actions or proceedings
required to acquire the necessary property and/or to fix the
compensation to be paid for property damage resulting from
the construction and maintenance of said improvements; and
in the absence of a satisfactory price agreement with the
owner of the land, the City Attorney is hereby directed to
immediately commence proceedings under Title Seven, Chapter
Three of the Code of Civil Procedure of the State of
California, to condemn the property hereinafter described
for the purpose of taking said land for the public use of
said City as hereinabove set forth.
5. To make application to a Court of competent jurisdiction for
an order fixing the amount of such security in the way of
money deposits as said Court may direct, and for an order
permitting said City of Lodi to take immediate possession
and use of said property, or interest in real property, or
existing improvements for the public use as hereinabove set
forth; to make deposit of such security or monies in such
amount so fixed and determined and in such manner as said
Court in which said condemnation proceedings are pending may
direct.
6. The real property or interest in real property which the
City of Lodi is by this Resolution authorized to acquire for
said public improvements is situated in the County of San
Joaquin, State of California, as described above.
7. Pursuant to Government Code Section 7267.2, a written offer
was made to the owners of record in the amount of
$269,100.
8. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the City Attorney be and hereby
is authorized and directed to commence and maintain in the
name of the City of Lodi, such actions and "proceedings of
eminent domain in the Superior Court of California, County
of San Joaquin, as are necessary to acquire, for the
purposes and uses aforesaid, that certain real property
which is situated in the County of San Joaquin, as described
above.
DATED: November 15, 1989
I hereby certify that Resolution No. 89-169 was passed and
adopted by the City Council of the City of Lodi in a
regular meeting held by the following vote:
17
124 Continued November 15, 1989
Ayes: Council Members - Hinchman, Olson, Pinkerton,
Reid and Snider (Mayor)
Noes: Council Members - None
Absent: Council Members - None
RECESS
Alice M. Reimche
City Clerk
The Mayor declared a five-minute recess and the Council
reconvened at approximately 9:05 p.m.
SETTING AND ESTABLISHING
INCREASED RATES FOR SEWER
SERVICE AND CONNECTION FEES
ORDINANCE NO. 1463
CC -51(a) Notice thereof having been published according to law,
CC -56 affidavit of which is on file in the office of the City
CC -149 Clerk, Mayor Snider called for the public hearing to
receive public input regarding considertion of the
introduction of an ordinance setting and establishing
increased rates for sewer service and connection fees.
The City Council was reminded that it had adopted
Resolution 86-152 at its regular meeting of October 1, 1986
setting in place a schedule of annual sewer service charges
and connection fees adjustments until such time as the
White Slough Water Pollution Control Facility expansion
project is completed or until that resolution is
superseded. The adjustments are 15% effective each year on
or as close to October 1 as feasible.
The proposed fee and related ordinance changes are outlined
below:
At the October 4, 1989 Council meeting, under the
discussion of increasing sewer fees, two questions were
raised that continued the action on the proposed fee
increase. These questions were:
1. Should we have a flat connection fee for all
sizes of residential units rather than the
present variable connection fee which is
tied to the number of bedrooms?
18
Continued November 15, 1989
2. How is the connection fee and sewage service
charge determined for commercial and
industrial uses?
Residential Connection Fee
Section 1 of the proposed Ordinance shows the residential
connection fee as $1,825.00 per Sewage Service Unit.
Section 13.12.180 of the overall sewer ordinance shows the
following relationship between the number of bedrooms and
sewage service units:
Number of Sewage Service
Bedrooms Units
1 0.75
2 1.00
3 1.25
Number of Sewage Service
Bedrooms Units
4 1.50
5 1.75
6 2.00
7 2.25
Therefore, the connection fees for residential would be as
follows:
Number of
Bedrooms Connection Fee
1 $1,368.75
2 $1,825.00
3 $2,281.25
4 $2,737.50
5 $3,193.75
6 $3,650.00
7 $4,106.25
The Council requested that staff calculate a flat rate
connection fee for all sizes of residential units that
would provide the same revenue as the proposed connection
fee tied to bedrooms. In order to make this calculation,
an assumption has to be made on what ratio of bedrooms per
residential unit will be constructed in the future. Listed
below are the alternates and what the flat rate connection
fee would be for each.
19
126 Continued November 15, 1989
Under these four alternatives, the flat rate connection fee
varies from $1,860 to $2,245 per residential unit. If the
Council desires a flat rate residential connection fee,
staff would recommend using Alternate 4 which is based on
the average of the 1988/89 building permits and provides a
flat rate fee of $2,160 per residential unit.
Commercial and Industrial Fees
In Section 1 of the proposed Ordinance, the cost per sewage
service unit for moderate strength commercial and
industrial users on the domestic system is as follows:
Annual Sewage Service $74.28 per sewage service unit
($6.19 monthly)
Connection Fee $1,825.00 per sewage service
unit
High strength user fees are calculated individually using
flow, BOD, and SS.
Example
A Church (Meeting Place, Religious) with 300 seats would be
charged for 1.5 Sewage Service Units (300 s 200 = 1.5)
Connection Fee
1.5 X $1,825 = $2,737.50
Sewage Service Charge
1.5 X $74.28 : 12 months = $9.28/month
The proposed Ordinance recommends a change in the
allocation of sewage service units to some commercial and
industrial uses. The recommended changes are based on
20
Flat Rate
Alternate
Description
Connection Fee
1
The future ratio
will equal the ratio of
$1,860
existing units presently constructed
2
The future ratio
will equal that ratio based
$2,245
on 1988 building
permits
3
The future ratio
will equal that ratio based
$1,990
on 1989 building
permits
4
The future ratio
will equal the average of the
$2,160
1988/89 building
permits
Under these four alternatives, the flat rate connection fee
varies from $1,860 to $2,245 per residential unit. If the
Council desires a flat rate residential connection fee,
staff would recommend using Alternate 4 which is based on
the average of the 1988/89 building permits and provides a
flat rate fee of $2,160 per residential unit.
Commercial and Industrial Fees
In Section 1 of the proposed Ordinance, the cost per sewage
service unit for moderate strength commercial and
industrial users on the domestic system is as follows:
Annual Sewage Service $74.28 per sewage service unit
($6.19 monthly)
Connection Fee $1,825.00 per sewage service
unit
High strength user fees are calculated individually using
flow, BOD, and SS.
Example
A Church (Meeting Place, Religious) with 300 seats would be
charged for 1.5 Sewage Service Units (300 s 200 = 1.5)
Connection Fee
1.5 X $1,825 = $2,737.50
Sewage Service Charge
1.5 X $74.28 : 12 months = $9.28/month
The proposed Ordinance recommends a change in the
allocation of sewage service units to some commercial and
industrial uses. The recommended changes are based on
20
Continued November 15, 1989
127
!I
calculated sewer flows determined from actual water metered
usage.
Under Section 1, the unit charges for flow, BOD, and SS for
a high strength industrial user on the domestic system were
increased more than the standard 15%. Three years ago,
when the connection fees were increased from $290 to
$1,200, these unit charges for connection fees were not
proportionately increased. This oversight was not caught
until now. If this had not been caught, a two-bedroom
residence using these unit charges would be charged a
connection fee of only $110 versus the $1,825 that should
be charged. Fortunately, no high strength industrial users
have connected in the last three years, so the City has not
lost any revenue.
Section 4 of the proposed Ordinance revises the appeal
section of the overall sewer ordinance. The revision will
allow the Public Works Director to make adjustments in the
monthly sewage service charge. The existing ordinance only
allows an adjustment in the connection fee.
Section 4 also provides for determining and adjusting
connection fees and sewage service charges based on
calculated sewer flows where water meters are installed.
This data was reviewed with the City Council at its
"Shirtsleeve" session of November 7, 1989. The proposed
adjustments will increase the monthly sewer service charge
for a two-bedroom house from $5.38 to $6.19, and the
connection fee from $1587 to $1825.
Staff still feels that the fairest way to apply connection
fees to residential units is by number of bedrooms. If the
Council wishes to change the concept to a flat rate
connection charge, this approach can be incorporated at the
time the ordinance is introduced.
Since these increases will help to fund the proposed
expansion of the White Slough Treatment Plant it is
critical that Ordinance No. 1463 be introduced at this
meeting. The introduction of this ordinance requires a 4/5
vote of the Council.
At the last "Shirtsleeve" session, Councilmember Pinkerton
requested to be informed of the City fees for a standard
single-family home. For an average 1800/s.f. three-bedroom
home the City fees collected are as follows:
Building Permit Charge $1300.00
(includes building permit,
plan check, Strong Motion
Instrumentation Program
(seismic safety), plumbing,
21
128 . Continued November 15, 1989
electrical and mechanical/air
conditioning)
Sewer Connection
(using proposed increase)
$2281.25
Total581. 5
The school impact fee ($1.56/s.f.) is collected by Lodi
Unified School District.
There being no persons in the audience wishing to speak on
the matter, the public portion of the hearing was closed.
Council Member Pinkerton let it be known to the Council
that he believed it was unfair to charge the connection
fees per bedroom and therefore abstained from voting on the
matter. Following more discussion, on motion of Mayor Pro
Tempore Hinchman, Reid second, Council introduced Ordinance
No. 1463 setting and establishing increased rates for sewer
service and connection fees with a sliding scale for
residential connection fees by the following vote. The
Ordinance also modified other wording the Code.
Ayes: Council Members - Hinchman, Olson, Reid
and Snider (Mayor)
Noes: Council Members - None
Absent: Council Members - None
Abstain: Council Members - Pinkerton
PLANNING COMMISSION There was no meeting since the last report
REPORT
COMMUNICATIONS
(CITY CLERK)
CLAIMS CC -4(c)
Following recommendation of the City Attorney and the
City's Contract Administrator, ADJUSTCO, the City Council
on motion of Mayor Pro Tempore Hinchman, Olson second,
denied the following claim:
a) Andrew S. MacKay, Date of loss 8/19/89
22
Continued November 15, 1989 129
POSTING FOR TERMS
EXPIRING ON VARIOUS
CITY OF LODI BOARDS
AND COMMISSIONS
CC -2(a) On motion of Council Member Olson, Reid second, the City
CC -2(e) Clerk was directed to post for the terms expiring on the
CC -2(1) following City Boards and Commissions:
a.
M
c.
REGULAR CALENDAR
GATE FEE INCREASE -
HARNEY LANE LANDFILL
Lodi Senior Citizens Commission, term of
Dorance Ochs, expiring 12/31/89
Mosquito Abatement District, term of Robert
S. Fuller, expiring 12/31/89
Site Plan and Architectural Review
Committee, term of Leonard Bull, expiring
January 1, 1990
CC -7(b) The City has been advised by the County of San Joaquin of a
CC -22(b) recommended increase in the dump fee at the Harney Lane
CC -56 Sanitary Landfill, effective January 1, 1990. In addition,
the County is required by Assembly Bill 939, "The
California Integrated Waste Management Act of 1989," to
levy an additional tipping fee of 50 cents per ton to be
deposited in the State's new Integrated Waste Management
Account. These monies will be used to fund the State's
various monitoring and testing programs to ensure
compliance by local agencies. These matters will come
before the Board of Supervisors at its regular meeting of
Tuesday, November 28, 1989 at 10:00 a.m. The City of Lodi
will be represented at this public hearing.
As proposed, the combination of the recommended increase in
the gate fee for maintenance and operations of 88 cents per
ton and the required AB 939 fee (probably 50 cents per ton)
translate to an approximate 2% increase in the City's
refuse rate schedule, or about 15 cents per can for
residential customers.
For the City Council's information the per ton gate fees at
the Harney Lane site have been adjusted as follows:
May 15, 1978 - $10.00
September 1,1987 - 12.95
January 1, 1988 - 13.60
January 1, 1989 - 14.60
23
130. Continued November 15, 1989
No action was taken on this item; however, it was decided
by motion of Council Member Reid, Snider second, that this
matter should be placed on the December 6, 1989 City
Council meeting for continued discussion.
PURCHASE OF DIAL -A -RIDE
VEHICLES
RES. NO. 89-167
CC -12(d) The City Council on motion of Mayor Pro Tempore Hinchman,
CC -47 Olson second, adopted Resolution 89-170 awarding the bid
CC -50(b) for the purchase of two 1989 Chevrolet station wagons to
the low bidder, Sanborn Chevrolet, Inc., in the amount of
$31,337.80
On November 14, 1989 bids were received as follows:
Sanborn Chevrolet, Inc. $31,337.80
Chase Chevrolet Co., Inc. $34,543.66
These vehicles will be used to replace two Dial -A -Ride
vehicles which have over 90,000 miles of service. The
funds for this purchase was included in our 1989-90 TDA
claim.
VOTING DELEGATE AND
VOTING ALTERNATE DESIGNATED FOR
ANNUAL LEAGUE OF CALIFORNIA
CITIES CONFERENCE,
SAN FRANCISCO, DECEMBER
17 - 19, 1989
CC -7(i) The City Council was reminded that the Annual League of
California Cities Conference originally scheduled for
October 22 - 25, 1989 in San Francisco was postponed
because of the October 17 earthquake that hit the Bay
area. The Annual Conference has been rescheduled for
December 17 - 19, 1989 in San Francisco.
The Annual Conference resolutions guide cities and the
League in its efforts to improve the quality,
responsiveness and vitality of local government. The
League Constitution provides that each city is entitled to
one vote in matters affecting municipal or League Policy.
All cities have the opportunity to exercise their vote on
resolutions at the Business Session scheduled for Tuesday,
December 19, 1989 at 1:30 p.m. at the Hilton Hotel in San
Francisco.
At the September 6, 1989 City Council meeting, the City
Council determined that Mayor Snider would serve as the
24
Continued November 15, 1989 131
City's Voting Delegate and Mayor Pro Tempore Hinchman as
the Voting Alternate. The League of California Cities is
now asking all cities to verify their voting delegate and
alternate.
On motion of Mayor Pro Tempore Hinchman, Olson second, the
Council voted to delegate City Manager, Tom Peterson, as
Voting Delegate and Assistant City Manager, Jerry Glenn, as
the Alternate Voting Delegate.
URGENCY ITEM ADDED
TO THE AGENDA PURSUANT
TO STATE LAW
City Manager Peterson advised the City Council that there
was an emergency situation that had developed and the need
to take action on the matter arose after the preparation
and posting of the agenda.
On motion of Council Member Reid, Olson second, the City
Council determined that pursuant to Government Code Section
54954.2 that an emergency situation has developed and the
need to take action arose after the preparation and posting
of the agenda.
On motion of Mayor Pro Tempore Hinchman, Olson second,
"Amendment to Resolution No. 89-53 Regarding the Office of
Criminal Justice Planning (OCJP) Grant for Drug Suppression
Program in Schools" was added to the agenda.
AMENDING RESOLUTION NO. 89-53
REGARDING THE OFFICE OF CRIMINAL
JUSTICE PLANNING (OCJP) GRANT FOR DRUG
SUPPRESSION PROGRAM IN SCHOOLS
RES. NO. 89-170
CC -7(f) The City Council was advised that on May 3, 1989, the Lodi
CC -175 City Council adopted Resolution No. 89-53 which authorized
CC -152 the application to the OCJP for grant funds for the third
CC -300 year of the Drug Suppression Program. The grant was
submitted to OCJP and was to begin October 1, 1989. On
November 9, 1989, the Lodi Police Department was notified
by telephone that a Statement of Liability was not included
in the Council Resolution and that it was required before
funding could begin. On November 13, 1989, OCJP notified
the Lodi Police Department of the contents of the Statement
of Liability, and that it was needed by November 17, 1989
to complete the grant application.
The Statement of Liability must be added to the resolution
to complete the grant application.
25
132.- Continued November 15, 1989
On motion of Council Member Reid, Olson second, the City
Council adopted Resolution No. 89-170 Amending Resolution
No. 89-53 Regarding the Office of Criminal Justice Planning
(OCJP) Grant for Drug Suppression Program in School.
ORDINANCES
AMENDING THE LAND USE
ELEMENT OF THE LODI GENERAL
PLAN BY REDESIGNATING A 51 -ACRE
PARCEL AT THE NORTHEAST CORNER
OF KETTLEMAN LANE AND BECKMAN ROAD
FROM UNCLASSIFIED INDUSTRIAL TO
LIGHT INDUSTRIAL; AND PREZONING
SAID PROPERTY C -M, COMMERCIAL -LIGHT
INDUSTRIAL; AND PREZONING SAID
PROPERTY C -M, COMMERCIAL -LIGHT INDUSTRIAL
AND M-1 LIGHT INDUSTRIAL
ORDINANCE NO. 1467
CC -53(a) Ordinance No. 1467 entitled, "An Ordinance of the Lodi City
CC -149 Council Amending the Land Use Element of the Lodi General
Plan by Redesignating a 51 -Acre Parcel at the Northeast
Corner of Kettleman Lane and Beckman Road from Unclassified
Industrial to Light Industrial; and Prezoning Said Proprety
C -M, Commerical -Light Industrial and M-1 Light Industrial"
having been introduced at a regular meeting of the Lodi
City Council held November 1, 1989 was brought up for
passage on motion of Council Member Pinkerton, Olson
second. Second reading of the ordinance was omitted after
reading by title, and the ordinance was then adopted and
ordered to print by the following vote:
Ayes: Council Members - Hinchman, Olson, Pinkerton,
Reid and Snider (Mayor)
Noes: Council Members - None
Absent: Council Members - None
Abstain: Council Members - None
ORDINANCE AMENDING THE LAND
USE ELEMENT OF THE GENERAL
PLAN BY RECLASSIFYING A 3.7+/ -
ACRE PARCEL LOCATED AT THE
SOUTHEAST CORNER OF LOWER.
26
Continued November 15, 1989 133
SACRAMENTO ROAD AND WEST VINE
STREET AND REZONING THE SUBJECT
PARCEL FROM R -C -P, RESIDENTIAL -
COMMERCIAL -PROFESSIONAL TO R-1,
RESIDENTIAL -SINGLE FAMILY
ORDINANCE NO. 1468
CC -53(a) Ordinance No. 1468 entitled "An Ordinance of the Lodi City
CC -149 Council Amending the Land Use Element of the Lodi General
Plan by Reclassifying the 3.7+/- Acre Parcel Located at the
Southeast Corner of Lower Sacramento Road and West Vine
Street form Office -Institutional to Residential -Low
Density", having been introduced at a regular meeting of
the Lodi City Council held November 1, 1989 was brought up
for passage on motion of Council Member Reid, Olson
second. Second reading of the ordinance was omitted after
reading by title, and the ordinance was then adopted and
ordered to print by the following vote:
Ayes: Council Members - Hinchman, Olson, Pinkerton,
Reid and Snider (Mayor)
Noes: Council Members - None
Absent: Council Members - None
Abstain: Council Members - None
ORDINANCE AMENDING THE OFFICIAL
DISTRICT MAP OF THE CITY OF LODI
AND THEREBY REZONING THE 3.7+/ -
ACRE PARCEL LOCATED AT THE SOUTHEAST
CORNER OF LOWER SACRAMENTO ROAD AND
WEST VINE STREET FROM R -C -P,
RESIDENTIAL -COMMERCIAL -PROFESSIONAL,
TO R-1, RESIDENTIAL -SINGLE FAMILY
ORDINANCE NO. 1469
CC -53(a) Ordinance No. 1469 entitled "An Ordinance of the Lodi City
CC -149 Council Amending the Official District Map of the City of
Lodi and Thereby Rezoning the 3.7+/- Acre Parcel Located at
the Southeast Corner of Lower Sacramento Road and West Vine
Street from R -C -P, Residential -Commercial-Professional, to
R-1, Residential -Single Family" having been introduced at a
regular meeting of the Lodi City Council held November 1,
1989, was brought up for passage on motion of Mayor Pro
Tempore Hinchman, Olson second. Second reading of the
ordinance omitted after reading by title, and the ordinance
was then adopted and ordered to print by the following vote:
Ayes: Council Members - Hinchman, Olson, Pinkerton,
Reid and Snider (Mayor)
27
134 - Continued November 15, 1989
Noes: Council Members - None
Absent: Council Members - None
Abstain: Council Members - None
ORDINANCE ADOPTING A CAPITAL
IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM BUDGET FOR
STREETS IN THE CITY OF LODI FOR
FISCAL YEAR 1989/90
ORDINANCE NO. 1470
CC -15 Ordinance No. 1470 entitled "An Ordinance of the Lodi City
CC -149 Council Adopting a Capital Improvement Program Budget for
Streets for the City of Lodi for Fiscal Year 1989/90"
having been introduced at a regular meeting of the Lodi
City Council held November 1, 1989, was brought up for
passage on motion of Mayor Pro Tempore Hinchman, Olson
second. Second reading of the ordinance omitted after
reading by title, and the ordinance was then adopted and
r orderd to print by the following vote:
Ayes: Council Members - Hinchman, Olson, Pinkerton,
Reid and Snider (Mayor)
Noes: Council Members - None
Absent: Council Members - None
Abstain: Council Members - None
ADJOURNMENT There being no further business to come before the
City Council, Mayor Snider adjourned the meeting at
approximately 10:05 p.m:
ATTEST:
Alice M. Reimche'
City Clerk
28