HomeMy WebLinkAboutAgenda Report - August 4, 2010 D-13AGENDA ITEM #406
CITY OF LODI
COUNCIL COMMUNICATION
AGENDA TITLE: Adopt Resolution Authorizing the City Managerto Enter Into a Professional
Services Agreement for an Electric System Arc Flash Study with RW Beck, Inc. of
Hendersonville, TN ($39,900) (EUD)
MEETING DATE: August 4,2010
PREPARED BY: Electric Utility Director
RECOMMENDEDACTION: Adopt a resolution authorizing the City Manager to enter into a
Professional Services Agreement for an Electric System Arc Flash
Study with RW Beck, Inc. of Hendersonville, TN in the amount of
$39,900.
BACKGROUND INFORMATION: The Occupational Safety and Health Administration requires
employers to assess the workplace to determine if hazards are
present, or likelyto be present, and have each employee use
appropriate personal protection equipment. Regulations require employers to perform a flash hazard
analysis on electrical power systems to determine the level of hazard and the appropriate protective
equipmentto avoid potential electrical arc -flash injuries such as shock, burns, hearing loss, arc blast,
shrapnel, lung damage or even death.
The Electric Utility's existing arc flash study is outdated. In November 3, 2004, an initial arc flash study
was conducted only for substations. Since then, significant changes to the City's electric distribution
system include load growth, distribution upgrades, and reconstruction of Killelea Substation, all of which
limit the applicability of that study.
To improve safety, EUD would like to upgrade the arc flash study for the electric distribution system to
comply with industry standards. RW Beck, Inc., has been identified as the company best -suited to
perform this work because it recently created a model of the EUD's electric distribution system for power
flow studies. That model will be used in the arc flash study. RW Beck's familiarity with Lodi's electric
system means a lower-cost study with a faster turnaround time, making it the preferred contractor.
The study will be executed as described in RW Beck's proposal dated April 20, 2010.
FISCAL IMPACT: The professional services cost is $39,900.
FUNDING: included in FY2010/11 Budget Account No. 161652
%-Z. XMZA-; c-
f,*/Jorda yers
Deputy City Manager/Internal Services Director
,- _ ff,, nn ��ll
EA T�-
Elizabdkh A. Kirkley
Electric Utility Director
Prepared by: Demy Bucaneg, Jr. -PE, Assistant Electric Utility Director
APPROVED:
K6hfWBartlam, Interim City Manager
PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT
This PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT (Agreement) is dated July 19, 2010, by
and between R. W. Beck, Inc. (Consultant), with offices at 131 Saundersville Road, Suite 300,
Hendersonville, TN, 37075 and City of Lodi, a Municipal Corporation (Client), with offices at
City of Lodi, Electric Utility Department, 1331 South Ham Lane, Lodi, CA 95242.
NOW, THEREFORE in consideration of the promises herein and for other good and valuable
consideration, the parties agree as follows:
1. Scope of Services: Consultant and Client agree Consultant will perform an electric
system arc flash study as described in the Scope of Services attached as Exhibit A in
accordance with the schedule set forth therein.
2. Independent Contractor: Consultant is an independent contractor and is not an
employee of Client. Services performed by Consultant under this Agreement are solely
for the benefit of Client. Nothing contained in this Agreement creates any duties on the
part of Consultant toward any person not a party to this Agreement.
3. Standard of Care: Consultant will perform services under this Agreement with the
degree of skill and diligence normally practiced by professional engineers or consultants
performing the same or similar services. No other warranty or guarantee, expressed or
implied, is made with respect to the services furnished under this Agreement and all
implied warranties are disclaimed.
4. Changes/Amendments: This Agreement and its exhibits constitute the entire
agreement between the Parties and together with its exhibits supersede any prior written
or oral agreements. This Agreement may not be changed except by written amendment
signed by both Parties. The estimate of the level of effort, schedule and payment
required to complete the Scope of Services, as Consultant understands it, is reflected
herein. Services not expressly set forth in this Agreement or its exhibits are excluded.
Consultant shall promptly notify Client if changes to the Scope of Services affect the
schedule, level of effort or payment to Consultant and the schedule and payment shall be
equitably adjusted. If Consultant is delayed in performing its services due to an event
beyond its control, including but not limited to fire, flood, earthquake, explosion, strike,
transportation or equipment delays, act of war, or act of God, then the schedule or
payment under the Agreement shall be equitably adjusted, if necessary, to compensate
Consultant for any additional costs due to the delay.
Fee for Services: The fee for the services under this Agreement will be based on a fixed
fee of Thirty -Nine Thousand, Nine Hundred Dollars (US $39,900) for the Scope of
Services outlined in this Agreement.
An SAIC Company
GA001809\General\Arc Flash\PSA.doc Client # 001809 R. W .Beck PSA 1 of 7
PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT
6. Payment: Client shall pay Consultant for services furnished under this Agreement
based upon monthly invoices which estimate the proportion of the services completed.
Client shall pay Consultant in U.S. dollars within thirty (30) days of receipt of invoices
less any disputed amounts. If Client disputes any portion of the invoice, the undisputed
portion will be paid and Consultant will be notified in writing, within ten (10) days of
receipt of the invoice of the exceptions taken, Consultant and Client will attempt to
resolve the payment dispute within sixty (60) days or the matter may be submitted to
arbitration as provided below. If Client fails to pay undisputed invoiced amounts within
sixty (60) days after delivery of invoice, Consultant, at its sole discretion, may suspend
services hereunder or may initiate collections proceedings, including mandatory binding
arbitration, without incurring any liability or waiving any right established hereunder or
by law.
7. Indemnity: To the extent permitted by law, Consultant agrees to indemnify, defend and
hold harmless Client and its elected officials, directors, officers, shareholders and
employees from and against any liability (including without limitation, reasonable costs
and attorneys' fees) incurred by Client to the extent caused by Consultant's negligent acts,
errors or omissions, includingjudgments in favor of any third party.
To the extent permitted by law, Client agrees to indemnify, defend and hold harmless
Consultant and its directors, officers, shareholders, employees, and subconsultants from
and against any liability (including, without limitation, reasonable costs and attorney's
fees) incurred by Consultant to the extent caused by Client's negligent acts, errors or
omissions, includingjudgments in favor of any third party.
Each party (the First Party) specifically and expressly waives its immunity under
applicable worker's compensation and industrial insurance laws regarding liability
against the other party (the Second Party) for actions brought by any of the First Party's
employees against the Second Party, to the extent the liability is caused by the First
Party's negligent acts, errors or omissions.
8. Reperformance of Services: If Client believes any of the services provided under this
Agreement do not comply with the terms of this Agreement, Client shall promptly notify
Consultant to permit Consultant an opportunity to investigate. If the services do not
meet the applicable standard of care, it will promptly reperform the services at no
additional cost to Client, including assisting Client in selecting remedial actions. If
Client fails to provide Consultant with prompt notice of non-compliance and an
opportunity to investigate and reperform its services, Consultant's total obligation to
Client will be limited to the costs Consultant would have incurred to reperform the
services.
9. Section Intentionally Left Blank.
G100I809\General\Arc Flash\PSA.doc Client# 001809 R. W. Beck PSA 2of 7
PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT
10. Insurance: Consultant shall maintain insurance with the following required coverages
and limits and upon execution of this agreement, will provide a Memorandum of
Insurance to Client:
Worker's Compensation
Employer's Liability
Commercial General Liability
Commercial Auto Liability
Professional Liability
Statutory
U.S. $1,000,000
U.S. $1,000,000 per occurrence
U.S. $1,000,000 aggregate
U.S. $1,000,000 combined single limit
U.S. $1,000,000 per claim and in the
aggregate
11. Work Product: Client shall have the unrestricted right to use the documents, analyses
and other data prepared by Consultant under this Agreement (Work Products); provided,
however Client shall not rely on or use the Work Products for any purpose other than the
purposes under this Agreement and the Work Products shall not be changed without the
prior written approval of Consultant. If Client releases the Work Products to a third
party without Consultant's prior written consent, or changes or uses the Work Products
other than as intended hereunder, (a) Client does so at its sole risk and discretion, (b)
Consultant shall not be liable for any claims or damages resulting from the change or use
or connected with the release or any third party's use of the Work Products and (c) Client
shall indemnify, defend and hold Consultant harmless from any and all claims or
damages related to the release, change or third party use.
12. Limitation of Liability: No employee of Consultant shall have individual liability to
Client. To the extent permitted by law, the total aggregate liability of Consultant, its
officers, directors, shareholders, employees and subconsultants for any and all claims
arising out of this Agreement, including attorneys' fees, and whether caused by
negligence, errors, omissions, strict liability, breach of contract or contribution, or
indemnity claims based on third party claims, shall not exceed the revenue received by
Consultant under this Agreement or one hundred fifty thousand dollars (U.S.
$150,000.00), whichever is greater.
13. No Consequential Damages: In no event and under no circumstances shall Consultant
be liable to Client for any principal, interest, loss of anticipated revenues, earnings,
profits, increased expense of operation or construction, loss by reason of shutdown or
non -operation due to late completion or otherwise or for any other economic,
consequential, indirect or special damages.
14. Information Provided by Others: Client shall provide to Consultant in a timely
manner any information Consultant indicates is needed to perform the services
hereunder. Consultant may rely on the accuracy of information provided by Client and
its representatives.
G1001809\GeneraMrc Flash\PSA.doc Client # 001809 R. W. Beck PSA 3 of 7
PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT
15. Opinions of Cost: Consultant does not control the cost of labor, materials, equipment or
services furnished by others, nor does it control pricing factors used by others to
accommodate inflation, competitive bidding or market conditions. Consultant estimates
of operation expenses or construction costs represent its best judgment as an experienced
and qualified professional and are not a guarantee of cost. This section'does not apply to
the cost of Consultant performing the Scope of Services.
16. Safety and Security: Consultant has established and maintains programs and
procedures for the safety of its employees. Unless specifically included as a service to be
provided under this Agreement, Consultant specifically disclaims any authority or
responsibility for j ob site safety and safety of persons other than Consultant's
employees. Consultant shall not provide any such services and disclaims any
responsibility under this Agreement related to site security or the assessment, evaluation,
review, testing, maintenance, operation or safety practices or procedures related to
security.
17. Section Intentionally Left Blank.
18. Termination: Either party may terminate this Agreement upon thirty (30) days prior
written notice to the other party. Client shall pay Consultant for all services rendered to
the date of termination plus reasonable expenses for winding down the services. If either
party defaults in its obligations hereunder, the non -defaulting party, after giving seven (7)
days written notice of its intention to terminate or suspend performance under this
Agreement, may, if cure of the default is not commenced and diligently continued,
terminate this Agreement or suspend performance under this Agreement.
19. Dispute Resolution: Consultant and Client shall attempt to resolve conflicts or disputes
under this Agreement in a fair and reasonable manner and agree that if resolution cannot
be made to attempt to mediate the conflict by a professional mediator (except for
payment disputes which may be submitted directly to arbitration). If mediation does not
settle any dispute or action which arises under this Agreement or which relates in any
way to this Agreement or the subject matter of this Agreement within ninety (90) days
after either requests mediation, the dispute or conflict shall be subject to arbitration in
English under the Construction Industry Arbitration Rules as promulgated by the
American Arbitration Association and arbitrability shall be subject to the Federal
Arbitration Act. Venue for mediation and arbitration under this Agreement shall be in
San Joaquin County, California.
20. Section Intentionally Left Blank.
G100I 809\General\Arc Flash\PSA.doc Client # 001809 R. W. Beck PSA 4of 7
PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT
21. Litigation Expenses: Client will be responsible for payment of all expenses and costs
associated with Consultant's compliance with a subpoena or Client request to produce
documents, data or testimony relating to any proceeding relating to any information
pertaining to Client's project or to the work Consultant performed for Client, excluding
any litigation or proceeding between Client and Consultant. These costs will include
hourly charges for persons involved in responding to a subpoena or Client request, travel
and reproduction expenses, advice and participation of counsel in responding to a
subpoena and other request and other reasonable expenses. Consultant will endeavor to
confer with Client prior to responding to any subpoena or request covered by this
paragraph.
22. Non Exclusivity of Services: Consultant may perform for other clients similar or
identical services to those services contemplated under this Agreement, subject to
applicable confidentiality and ethical obligations of Consultant. In the event Client
desires any level of exclusivity or other limitations on Consultant's services to its other
clients, Client and Consultant shall confer regarding the scope of requested exclusivity or
other limitations and the additional compensation to be paid to Consultant for the
requested exclusivity or other limitations on providing services to other clients. Any
agreed exclusivity or other limitations on providing similar or identical services shall be
confirmed in writing signed by both parties and shall expressly state such provision shall
supersede this Section 22. No fiduciary or agency obligations shall be created as a result
of any exclusivity obligations or other limitations on Consultant's services to other
clients.
23. Miscellaneous:
a. This Agreement is binding upon and will inure to the benefit of Client and
Consultant and their respective successors and assigns. Neither party may assign
its rights or obligations hereunder without the prior written consent of the other
party.
b. Any notice required or permitted by this Agreement to be given shall be deemed
to have been duly given if in writing and delivered personally or five (5) days
after mailing by first-class, registered, or certified mail, return receipt requested,
postage prepaid and addressed as follows:
Client: City of Lodi Electric Utility Department,
Attention: Mr. Demetrio S Bucaneg, Jr
Assistant Electric Utility Director
Address: 1331 South Ham Lane
Lodi, CA 95242
Consultant: R. W. Beck, Inc.
Attention: Office Supervisor
Address: 131 Saundersville Road,
Suite 300,
Hendersonville, TN 37075
GA001809\General\Arc Flash\PSA.doc Client 9 001809 R. W .Beck PSA 5of 7
PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT
With copies to:
Legal Department (which will not be considered notice)
1001 Fourth Avenue, Suite 2500
Seattle, WA 98154-1004
USA
Office of the City Attorney
City of Lodi
221 West Pine Street
Lodi, CA 95240
c. Client expressly agrees that all provisions of the Agreement, including the clause
limiting the liability of Consultant, were mutually negotiated and that but for the
inclusion of the limitation of liability clause in the Agreement, Consultant's
compensation for services would otherwise be greater and/or Consultant would
not have entered into the Agreement.
d. If any provision of this Agreement is invalid or unenforceable, the remainder of
this Agreement shall continue in full force and effect and the provision declared
invalid or unenforceable shall continue as to other circumstances.
e. This Agreement shall be governed by, and construed in accordance with, the laws
of the State of California.
f. In any action to enforce or interpret this Agreement, the prevailing party shall be
entitled to recover, as part of its judgment, reasonable attorneys' fees and costs
from the other party.
g. This Agreement shall not be construed against Consultant only on the basis that
Consultant drafted the Agreement.
h. Notwithstanding any statute to the contrary, the Parties agree that any action to
enforce or interpret this Agreement shall be initiated within two (2) years from the
time the party knew or should have known of the fact giving rise to its action, and
shall not in any case be initiated later than six (6)years after Consultant completes
its Scope of Services under this Agreement.
This Agreement may be executed in multiple counterparts, each of which shall be
deemed to be an original instrument, but all of which taken together shall
constitute one instrument.
GA001809\General\Arc Flash\PSA.doc CHentif 001809 R. W. Beck PSA
PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Parties have signed this Agreement the date first written above.
CITY OF LODI, A MUNICIPAL R. W. BECK, INC.
CORPORATION
Signature
Name
Title
Date
A roved as to to=
DWAY City At:ar+�ey
Signature
Name
Title
Date
la- 1114�
Keith Mullen
Senior Project Manager
July 19, 2010
GA00 809\General\Arc as oc Client# 001809 R. W, Beck PSA o 7
IEXhHtsIT Al
April 20, 2010
An SAID Company
Deinetrio S. Bucaneg, Jr., P.E.
Assistant Electric Utility Director
City of Lodi Electric Utility Department
1331 S. Ham Lane
Lodi, CA 9522-3995
Subject; Electric System Arc Flash Study
Dear Mi., 13ucaneg:
The 2007 NEW 410.A,3 rule states, "effective January I, 2009, the employer shall ensure that tui
assessment is performed to dctormine potential exposure to an electric arc for employees who work on or
near energized pacts or equipment." Based oil this requirement, the City of Lodi Electric Utility
Department (Lodi) desires the developn'tant of an Electric System Arc Flash Satdy.
Lodi serves approximately 28,910 electric customers located in Lodi, California. Lodi provides service
through a 60/34.6 kV sub -transmission system and 29 disc-ibmion feeders operatod at 12,0/6.9 W
Analysis of the Lodi electric system will be based on the following:
It EE Standard 1584
r
Current ongincering models of the existing system
Arc Flash module in Milsol't's version 7.3 of WinclMil r
Arel'ro soRmtre from Kineoldos, Inc.
• Source impcdancesfor the substations' 60/34.6 kV and 12.0/6,9 kV buses
s Existingovc^rcurrcnt protection schemo, devices, and settings
We have prepared the following Scope ofServiccs and will perform requested services usinglhe approach
detailed below.
Scope of Services
Task 1; Data Collection
The following dant is required from Lodi for the development of the Electric Syston Arc Flash Study
(electronic copies may be submitted, where appropriate):
in Up-to-date system models (WinclMil) including:
m Tho allocation of the most rcctmt system peak loads
W Substation source impedances
• Recloser types, sizes, existing; settings, and locarions
® Fuse types, sizes, and locations
■ Capacitor bank and regulator sizes and locations
Mr. Bucaneg
April 20, 2010
Page 2
8 Primary wire sizes and lengths
Standard distributiun transformer sizes and manufacturer's specifications
Standard distribution transformer fuse sizes
Task 2: Model Device Database Development
R. W. Beck will review the existing WindMil engineering models of the Lodi electric system, and perform
the following in preparation for the development of the Electric System Arc Flash Study. A total of 16
man-hours has been allocated to this task and includes the following:
a iJpdate equipment definitions based on manufacturer's specifications and settings provided by
Lodi for the following:
ar Substation relays/breakers
a, Line recloscrs and fuses
ao Regulators and capacitors
Verify the Light`1'able device database for protective devices in the WindMil@ engineering models
of the Lodi electric system
m Collaborate with Lodi to. resolve warnings and errors identified in the existing WindMil
engineering models of the Lodi electric system
Task 3: Kick-off Meeting
I , W, Beck will meet at the Lodi office to:
w Collect the retnuin ing information requested
• Review and approve the existing WindMil engineering Models 01'010, Lodi 0,1=1 is system
• Discuss the following with fliv, Lodi managenment rind engineering statl':
ar Utility requirements and project scope
* Arc 1"Jash analysis methodology
* Rxisting overcurrent protection philosophy and its potential impact on ru•c energy
is Potential impact of the analysis results on system operations
w Project schedule and responsibilitios
n Submit a summary of information collected and discussed tit the initial meeting to Lodi for review
and approval
Task 4: Arc Flash Analysis
R. W, Beck will utilise the WindMil models of the Lodi electric system to perform the following tasks:
0 Determine the range of arc energy available based on the following:
Mr. Bucaneg
April 20,2010
Page 3
in Calculated range of maximum fault currents available on the 60/34.6 kV and 12.0/6.9 kV buses
and switchgear at the existing substations serving the Lodi system
a Calculated range of maxinwiin fault currents available on the distribution system, based on the
WindMil model
s Up to IS standard transformers selected by Lodi will be added at the end of each line section in
the WindMil model
s Calculated range of maximum fault currents available at the lugs of the distribution
transformer's added to the WindMil model, based on the standard sizes and manufacturer's
specifications provided by Lodi
is Existing overcurrent protection scheme, device locations and settings
s Arc Flash module in WindMil's version 7.3
s ArcPi-o software from Kinectrics, hic.
a Summarize tile calculated results in Cal/cm2
a Provide a summary of the calculationsto Lodi for review and approval
Task 5: Draft Report Preparation
R, W. Beck will:
■ Prepare a draft report describing the assumptions, analysis, and recommendations of the Electric
System Arc Flush Study
* System map illustrating the calculated arc energy
■ Submit the draft report to Lodi for review and approval
Task 6: Draft Review Meeting
R. W. Beck will meet with Lodi management arid engineering staff on-site for a one day meeting to
review the existing draft report and discuss the following:
w Analysis methodology and assumptions
■ Analysis resulE.s
s Recommended modifications to the draft report of the electric System Arc Flash Study as
necessary to create the final document
MI. Bucaneg
April 20, 2010
Page 4
Task 7: Final Document and Delivery
R. W. Heck will:
w Modify the draft report of the Electric System Arc Flash Study to create, the final document for
delivery to Lodi for the internal use, as necessary
as Finalize the system map illustrating the calculated arc energy
m Deliver three copies in a three-ring Binder of the Final document and system map to Lodi
Task 8: Presentation (Optional)
R. W. Beck will:
a Deliver it presentation of the analysis methodology, assumptions, and resuhs for the Electric
System Arc Flash Study to the, l..odi engineering, operations, and management staff
Fee for Services
R. W. Heck will provide the Scope; of Services outlined in this Agreement for a fixed fee ofThirtyNine
Thousand, Nine Hundred Dollars ($39,900), as broken out below. This proposal will remain valid for 45
clays from (lie date given above,
service Fee Initials
Distribution Arc Flash Analysis $29,800
Transmission Arc Flash Analysis ( I $4,600
Presentation (optional) $5,500
TOTAL $39,900
If this meets with your. approval, please authorize on the following page and roL u'n one copy of this letter
to my attention for our records. R. W. Beck will provide the services described herein pursuant to the
accepted terms and conditions of`the Professional Services Agreement between R. W, Beck and City of
Lodi Hiectric Utility Department dated April 20, 2010.
Mr, Bucaneg
April 20, 2010
Page 5
Additional Services
R. W. Beck can provide the following as additional services with written authorization from Lodi:
■ Meeting(s) at Lodi's oilloo in addition to the Kick-off Meeting included in Task 3 and the Draft
Review Meeting in Txk 6
■ Recommendations to reduce the calculated arc energy
■ Additional analysis to evaluate alternate system configurations and device settings
I will contact you to ensure the Scope of Services meets your needs, Thank you for the continued
opportunity to provide our services lo City of Lodi Electric Utility Department.
Sincerely,
R. W. BECK, INC.
Keith Mullen, P.E.
Project Manager
Authorization
CITY OF LODI I:I EC'I'RIC IJ'rILITY R, W. BECK, INC,
DINIAR'rivIENT
Signed
Printed
Title
Signed ?�
Printed Joni Batson, P.I.
Vice President – Transmission and
Title Distribution Planning and Analysis
Date — Date A rp it 20, 2010
RESOLUTION NO. 2010-132
A RESOLUTION OF THE LODI CITY COUNCIL
AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO ENTER
INTO A PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT
WITH RW BECK, INC.
WHEREAS, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) requires
employers to assess the workplace to determine if hazards are present, or likely to be present,
and have each employee use appropriate personal protection equipment (PPE). The National
Electrical Code (NEC) states that equipment must be marked to warn of potential electrical arc -
flash hazards. The National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) 70E states that a flash hazard
analysis must be performed to determine the level of hazard and appropriate PPE for given
tasks; and
WHEREAS, in November3, 2004, an initial arc flash studywas conducted for substation
facilities only, however since that time, there have been significant changes in the City's electric
distribution system; therefore, the arc flash study needs to be updated and expanded; and
WHEREAS, for safety, the Lodi Electric Utility Department would like RW Beck, Inc. to
conduct, upgrade, and expand the Arc Flash Study for the electric distribution system in
accordance with the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) Standard 1584 and
NFPA 70E. RW Beck has intimate knowledge of the Lodi system because of its recent work
creating a model of the system for system power flow studies. That model will be used in the
arc flash study. Thus, RW Beck can do the arc flash study best with the least additional work.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Lodi City Council does hereby
authorize the City Manager to enter into a professional services agreement with RW Beck, Inc.
for performing the Electric System Arc Flash Study for the entire electric distribution system of
the City of Lodi at a cost of $39,900.
Dated: August 4, 2010
-------------------
-------------------
I hereby certify that Resolution No. 2010-132 was passed and adopted by the City
Council of the City of Lodi in a regular meeting held August 4,2010, by the following vote:
AYES: COUNCIL MEMBERS — Hansen, Hitchcock, Johnson, and
Mayor Katzakian
NOES: COUNCIL MEMBERS — None
ABSENT: COUNCIL MEMBERS — Mounce
ABSTAIN: COUNCIL MEMBERS — Nome
HL
City Clerk
2010-132