HomeMy WebLinkAboutAgenda Report - April 15, 2009 E-10AGENDA ITEM Q
CITY OF LODI
COUNCIL COMMUNICATION
M
AGENDATITLE: Adopt Resolution Awarding a Contract to R.W. Beck, Inc. to Perform
Comprehensive Electric Systems Study ($95,800) (EUD)
MEETING DATE: April 15,2009
PREPARED B Y Electric Utility Director
RECOMMENDEDACTION: Adopt a resolution awarding a professional services contract to
R.W. Beck, Inc. of Sacramento, CA to perform power systems
studies on Lodi's 12kV electric distribution system, including
substations and transmission lines in an amount of not to exceed
$95,800.
BACKGROUND INFORMATION: Sound utility practice is to perform comprehensive power system
studies regularly (every three to five years). Such studies verify that
existing components of the network are within safe operational
limits. The last comprehensive power system study for the City's
power grid was conducted in 2001, It needs to be updated.
As a result, the Electric Utility Department (EUD) advertised bid documents on November 13, 2008 as
per prior Council authorization. On December 10, 2008, six power system consulting engineering firms
asked for the bid documents and one (R.W. Beck) actually submitted a bid of $95,800. Inquiries to other
bidders found that they focused on larger transmission type studies, did not have experience with the
software modeling software specified in the RFP, or were not interested in the work at this time.
Staff reviewed the proposal from R.W. Beck and found it to be compliant to the bid documents and scope
of work. R.W. Beck has been conducting various power systems studies at extra high voltage, medium
and low voltage in the transmission and distribution systems. The firm also has expertise and experience
in the business side of the electric utility industry. EUD has previously utilized their services, skills, and
expertise which gives them familiarity of the City's contractual and work processes. The professional
services proposal from R.W. Beck covers: the City's existing 12kV electric distribution system, four (4)
substation facilities (Henning, Industrial, Killelea and McLane), and the 60kV transmission lines including
the interconnection with PG&E.
R.W. Beck will submit comprehensive technical reports, data, figures, recommendations, system
configurations and models in electronic CD and/or DVD format at the conclusion of the studies. The
database received will enable EUD to perform most future distribution system studies internally.
Staff considered the reasonableness of R.W. Becks quoted price since it was the only bidder. Based on
past pricing experience for this type of comprehensive study, the proposed price was deemed to be
reasonable.
APPROVED:
Blair Kin nager
Adopt Resolution Awarding a Contract to R.W. Beck, Inc. to Perform Comprehensive Electric Systems Study ($95,800) (EUD)
April 15, 2009
Page 2
Performing comprehensive and detailed power systems study and analysis of the City's existing electric
distribution system and electrical infrastructure will minimize nuisance power outages and increase
reliability of electric service. As a result, staff recommends awarding a professional services contract to
perform power systems studies to R.W. Beck Company in the amount of not to exceed $95,800. R.W.
Beck shall complete these services within five months from the date of "Notice to Proceed.
FISCAL IMPACT: Not to exceed $95,800
FUNDING: Fiscal Year 2008-09 Budget Account No. 160652.7323 — Professional Services
with fund transfers from Accounts 160611, 160612, 160613 and 160652 Object
Codes.
Jordan Ayers
Deputy City Manager/Internal Services Director
Georg F. Ma ow
Electric Utility Director
Prepared By: Demy Bucaneg, Jr., P.E., Assistant Electric Utility Director
Weldat Haile. P.E., Senior Power Engineer
G FM/Ist
Attachments
PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT
FOR THE CITY OF LODI
BY R W . BECK, INC.
ENGINEERING SERVICES
for the
POWER SYSTEMS STUDIES
R.W. Beck, Inc. (RW Beck) agrees to enter into a Professional Services Agreement (Agreement)
with the City of Lodi to perform power systems studies on existing 12kV electric distribution
systems, four (4) substations, and 60kV transmission lines as more fully described in RW Becks
proposal entitled, "Power Systems Studies" dated December 10, 2008 and in the Request For
Proposal (RFP) dated November 8, 2008. RW Beck agrees to perform the work, as outlined in
the December 10" proposal, for a fixed fee of not -to -exceed Price of $95,800. RW Beck will not
exceed this price unless it first receives written approval from the City of Lodi to increase the
approved amount. As outlined in RW Becks December 10'h proposal, the services under this
Agreement shall be performed and completed in approximately five (5) calendar months after
receiving Notice -to -Proceed. Copy of RW Beck's "Power Systems Studies" proposal, including
the Cover Letter, Sections 1 through 5 dated December 10, 2008. and the RW Beck email dated
March 16,2009 from Steven Rupp are attached to and is a part of the agreement.
RW Beck shall furnish a certificate of insurance to the City of Lodi in accordance with Section
5.413, "Insurance Requirements for Contractor" (Public Liability and Property Damage
Insurance)and Section 5.414, "Compensation Insurance" as well as the Hold Harmless condition
of section 5-409, "Responsibility for Damage" at the time the signed agreement is returned to the
City. Copies of each section referenced above are attached to and is a part of the agreement.
R.W. BECK. INC.
An Washington Corporation
By:
John Bakken
Title: Project Manager
Date:
Address: 1001 Fourth Avenue. Suite 2500
Seattle, Washington, 98154-1004
Approved as to form:
D. Stephen Schwab ue ,
City Attorney
CITY OF LODI. CALIFORNIA
A California Municipal Corporation
By:
Blair King
Title: City Manager
Date:
Address: 221 W. Pine Street
Lodi, California 95240
Attest:
City Clerk
C. -Q=. ft and '%W0r"ft DowAWtsV"W &,%"9Mdhn%PM AVVIWk•L" 03- a-M.doc
5-409 Responsibility for Damage The City of Lodi, the City Council, all officers and employees or agent shall not be answerable or accountable in
any manner for any loss or damage that may happen to the work or any part thereof; or for any material or equipment used in performing the work; or
for injury or damage to any person or persons, either work personnel or the public; for damage to adjoining property from any cause whatsoever during
the progress of the work or any time before final acceptance with the exception of those injuries or damages arising out of the active negligence of the
City of Lodi or its agents, officers or employees.
Contractor shall indemnify and save harmless the City of Lodi, the City Council, elected and appointed Boards, Commissions, all officers and
employees or agents from any suits, claims or actions brought by any person or persons for or on account of any injuries or damages sustained or
arising from the services performed under this Agreement, but only to the extent caused by the negligent acts, errors or omissions of the Contractor
and except those injuries or damages arising out of the active negligence of City or its agents, officers or employees.. The City Council may retain as
much of the money due the Contractor as shall be considered necessary until disposition has been made of such suits or claims for damages as
aforesaid.
5-413 Insurance Reguirements for Contractor The Contractor shall take out and maintain during the life of this contract, insurance coverage as listed
below. These insurance policies shall protect the Contractor and any subcontractor performing work covered by this contract from claims for damages
for personal injury, including accidental death, as well as from claims for property damages, which may arise from Contractor's operations under this
contract, whether such operations be by Contractor or by any subcontractor or by anyone directly or indirectly employed by either of them, and the
amount of such insurance shall be as follows:
COMMERCIAL GENERAL LIABILITY 2. COMPREHENSIVE AUTOMOBILE LIABILITY
Per Occurrence
$1,000,000 Property Damage -
Personal & Adv Injury
$2,000,000 General Aggregate
$1,000,000 Combined Single Limits
NOTE: Contractor agrees and stipulates that any insurance coverage provided to the City of Lodi shall provide for a claims period following termination
of coverage which is at least consistent with the claims period or statutes of limitations found in the California Tort Claims Act (California Government
Code Section 810 at seq.).
A copy of the certificate of insurance with the following endorsements shall be furnished to the City:
(a) Additional Named Insured Endorsement
Such insurance as is afforded by this policy shall also apply to the City of Lodi, its elected and appointed Boards, Commissions, Officers,
Agents and Employees as additional named insureds insofar as work performed by the insured under written contract with the City of Lodi.
(This endorsement shall be on a form furnished to the City and shall be included with Contractor's policies.)
(b) Primary Insurance Endorsement
Such insurance as is afforded by the endorsement for the Additional Insureds shall apply as primary insurance. Any other insurance
maintained by the City of Lodi or its officers and employees shall be excess only and not contributing with the insurance afforded by this
endorsement.
(c) Severability of Interest Clause
The term "insured" is used severally and not collectively, but the inclusion herein of more than one insured shall not operate to increase the
limit of the company's liability.
(d) Notice of Cancellation or Change in Coverage Endorsement
This policy may not be canceled nor the coverage reduced by the company without 30 days' prior written notice of such cancellation or
reduction in coverage to the City Attorney, City of Lodi, P.O. Box 3006, Lodi, CA 95241.
(e) Contractor agrees and stipulates that any insurance coverage provided to the City of Lodi shall provide for a claims period following termination
of coverage which is at least consistent with the claims period or statutes of limitations found in the California Tort Claims Act (California
Government Code Section 810 at seq.).
"Claims made" coverage requiring the insureds to give notice of any potential liability during a time period shorter than that found in the Tort
Claims Act shall be unacceptable.
5-414 Compensation Insurance The Contractor shall take out and maintain during the life of this contract, Worker's Compensation Insurance for all
of Contractor's employees employed at the site of the project and, if any work is sublet, Contractor shall require the subcontractor similarly to provide
Worker's Compensation Insurance for all of the latter's employees unless such employees are covered by the protection afforded by the Contractor. In
case any class of employees engaged in hazardous work under this contract at the site of the project is not protected under the Worker's
Compensation Statute, the Contractor shall provide and shall cause each subcontractor to provide insurance for the protection of said employees. This
policy may not be canceled nor the coverage reduced by the company without 30 days' prior written notice of such cancellation or reduction in
coverage to the City Attorney, City of Lodi, P.O. Box 3006, Lodi, CA 95241.
CITY COUNCIL
JOANNE MOUNCE, Mayor
LARRY D. HANSEN,
Mayor Pro Tempore
SUSAN HITCHCOCK
PHIL KATZAKIAN
BOB JOHNSON
To Prospective Proposers
CITY OF LODI
ELECTRIC UTILITY DEPARTMENT
GEORGE F. MORROW, DIRECTOR
1331 S HAM LANE
LODI, CALIFORNIA 95242-3995
(209)333-6762
FAX (209) 333-6839
November 8, 2008
BLAIR KING, City Manager
RANDI JOHL, City Clerk
D. STEPHEN SCHWABAUER,
City Attorney
Subject: Request for Proposal (RFP) for Power Systems Studies on the Existing 12kV
Electric Distribution Systems, Four (4) Substations, and 60kV Transmission Lines
The City of Lodi hereby invites sealed proposals to provide engineering services to perform power
systems studies on the existing 12kV electric distribution systems, four (4) substations, and 60kV
transmission lines. Each proposal shall be in accordance with this notice and specifications on file and
available from the Engineering & Operations Division, City of Lodi Electric Utility Department, 1331 South
Ham Lane, Lodi, California 95242, (209) 333-6762. No proposal will be considered unless it is submitted
on a format according to the `ORGANIZATION OF PROPOSAL' Section of this RFP document.
Sealed proposals shall be delivered to the Budget Manager at the City Hall Annex, 300 West Pine Street,
Lodi, CA 95240 (P.O. Box 3006, Lodi, CA 95241-1910) on or before
December 10, 2008, at 11:00 a.m.
At that date and hour said sealed proposals will be publicly opened and read in the Public Works
Conference Room, City Hall, 221 West Pine Street, Lodi, California. Proposers or their authorized
representatives are invited to be present.
Please submit detailed proposal and your standard service agreement for review and approval. If there
are any questions regarding this request for proposal, you may contact me at (209) 333-6811, by email at
dbucaneg(@-lodielectric.com or Weldat Haile of my Staff at (209) 333-6763, by email at
whaile@lodielectric.com. Arrangement for site inspection may be made by calling Mr. Haile at least 24
hours in advance of planned inspection.
Demetrio S. Bucaneg, Jr. -PE
Assistant Electric Utility Director
Engineering & Operations Division
City of Lodi Electric Utility Department
Request for Proposal
for
POWER SYSTEMS STUDIES
The Engineering & Operations Division, City of Lodi Electric Utility Department is inviting qualified
consulting firms to provide engineering services to perform power systems studies on the existing 12kV
electric distribution systems, four (4) substations, and 60kV transmission lines. The following Request for
Proposals (RFP) outlines the background, scope of work and proposal requirements for the services.
BACKGROUND
Growth within the City between year 2001 and 2006 increased significantly the electrical loads being
served by the existing electric distribution system. The summer peak load in 2001 was approximately
120MW. In 2006, load crested to a new high of approximately 148MW.
In previous years of operations, the City's electric distribution system experienced a number of nuisance
device trippings of unknown causes, prolonged outages due to several protective devices being activated
at the same time at different phase circuits, and widespread power shutdowns caused by main protective
relays operating at the substation facility. Troubleshooting of faulted lines proved to be difficult and
needed more time to investigate before power could be restored. Some overhead capacitor banks were
switched -off and left in place and a number of capacitor banks were removed from service. Others were
switched -on continuously and had a number of faulted capacitor banks.
Standard power utility practices dictate the performance of comprehensive and detailed power system
analyses and evaluation of the existing facilities/systems regularly (every two to three years). This is to
verify and confirm that existing limits, as well as various electric distribution, substation and transmission
components, are within the safe operational limits to serve electrical loads. Continued checks and
adjustments enhance the reliability and the security of continuous power service to the customer and
minimize prolonged power outages. The last comprehensive power system study for the City's power grid
was conducted in 2001. It needs to be updated.
SCOPE OF WORK
The request for proposal will cover the power system studies of the City's existing 12kV electric
distribution system, four (4) substation facilities (Henning, Industrial, Killelea and McLane), and the 60kV
transmission lines including the interconnection with PG&E. This task will be executed using MILSOFT
Software. The scope of work for this engineering services to provide comprehensive power systems
studies will encompass, but not be limited to, the following task areas:
1. Database creation, setup, configuration, parameter and data
entries
2. Short circuit studies for at least the three-phase fault and line -to -
ground fault
3. Protective relay coordination from the 60kV to the smallest fuse
installed in both overhead and underground distribution system at
the 480 -volt system
4. Update protective device library to include all devices installed and
being used throughout the City's power grid
5. Establish and standardize relay settings, fuse sizes, circuit breaker
sizes and reclosers including 12kV reclosing strategy at different
fault conditions
6. Voltage drop study, voltage profile and voltage support analysis for
each of the more heavily loaded 12kV feeders and substation
transformers
7. Evaluate the effectiveness of existing line capacitors and confirm
the correct capacitor placement in the electric distribution system
8. Determine strategic location and placement of fault indicators for
simplified and efficient troubleshooting
9. Undertake load flow studies at normal operating conditions and for
contingency analysis at N-1 condition showing the overloaded
element(s), if any
10. Complete facilities studies and three (3) sets of final reports in hard
and electronic copies
ORGANIZATION OF PROPOSAL
Prospective Proposers are furnished with one request for proposal (RFP) document. Proposals shall
follow the following format:
A. Service approach narrative — This section should demonstrate an understanding of the task at
hand and include a narrative describing how the Proposer would go about the work. This section
will also include the methodologies and assumptions in performing the power systems and
facilities studies.
B. Project team — Describe the personnel who will carry out services, and their respective
responsibilities.
C. Qualifications — Provide a narrative describing how the team as a whole meets the qualifications
for the services. Include a list of prior relevant projects, power utilities, and contact persons where
MiLsoFT Software was used.
D. Submittals & Report — This section should summarize the submittals, final report structure,
attachments, figures, data, tables, drawings, etc. It should include also schedule of preliminary
and final submittals and the required number of copies and the respective formats of each
particular submittal.
E. Proposal & Project Schedule — Provide the proposed project schedule to commence within 15
days after receipt of `Notice to Proceed' from the City. It should include in detail the proposed
cost in performing the tasks as described in the `Scope of Work', and a summarized
engineering/consulting fee structure and other surcharges, and/or details as appropriate.
Proposal costs shall be individually itemized to correspond with each task areas as
described in Items 1 through 10 of the `Scope of Work'. Note: Refer also to the `Additional
Terms And Conditions' of this request for proposal.
F. Signatures - The proposal must be signed with the full name and address of the proposer, by an
authorized representative of the company with all the information below.
i.
Name of company
ii.
Address
iii.
Authorized signature
iv.
Name
v.
Title
vi.
Telephone No.
vii.
Fax No.
viii.
Date
G. Note - The City of Lodi reserves the right to reject any or all proposals, to waive any informality in
any proposal, to accept other than the lowest proposal, or not to award the project.
PROPOSAL SUBMISSION
A. The Budget Manager will receive sealed proposals at the following address until
11:00 am, Wednesday, December 10, 2008.
B. Proposals shall be submitted under sealed cover, plainly marked
Proposal — Power Systems Studies
RFP Opening - December 10, 2008.
Proposals, which are not properly identified, may be disregarded. Proposals, which are not
received by 11:00am, Wednesday, December 10, 2008 will be returned to the Proposer
unopened.
RFPs shall be submitted
To: Lodi City Council
c/o —Budget Manager
(If delivered by FedEx, UPS, or courier): (If delivered by mail):
300 West Pine Street P O Box 3006
Lodi CA 95240 Lodi CA 95241-1910
RFP OPENING
A. At 11:00 A.M., Wednesday, December 10, 2008, or as soon as possible thereafter, in the Public
Works Conference Room, City Hall, 221 West Pine Street, Lodi, California, proposals will be
publicly opened and read. Proposers or their authorized representatives are invited to be
present.
SELECTION PROCESS
Complete proposals will be evaluated based on the information submitted. This will permit a
recommendation to the City Council for contract award. The following equally weighted criteria will be
used to evaluate submitted proposals:
A. The likelihood of the proposed approach to produce the desired results.
B. Qualifications of the Proposer.
C. The value offered by the Proposer's price in relation to the proposed approach.
REJECTION OF PROPOSALS
The City of Lodi reserves the right to reject any and all proposals and to solicit new proposals with
modified terms and conditions. It also reserves the right to waive any informality in connection with the
proposals.
CONTRACT AWARD
1. The City of Lodi reserves the right to reject any or all proposals, to waive any informality in any
proposal, to accept other than the lowest proposal, or not to award the project.
2. If there will be a tie in the submitted proposals, the tie will be broken by a coin toss, conducted by
the Budget Manager. Tie proposers will be notified and may be present.
3. In all circumstances, including receipt of alternative proposals, the City Council reserves the right
to select the proposal most advantageous to the City.
4. The award, if made, will be made within forty five (45) days after the opening of the proposals.
GENERAL PROVISIONS
5-409 Responsibility for Damage The City of Lodi, its elected and appointed boards,
commissions, officers, agents and employees shall not accept responsibility for any loss or damages that
occur during the scope of work to the work or any part thereof; or for any material or equipment used in
performing the work; or for injury or damage to any person or persons, either work personnel or the
public; for damage to adjoining property arising from or related to Contractor's negligence or willful
misconduct during the progress of the work or any time before final acceptance.
Contractor shall indemnify and save harmless the City of Lodi, the City Council, elected and appointed
Boards, Commissions, all officers and employees or agents from any suits, claims or actions brought by
any person or persons for or on account of any injuries or damages sustained or arising from the services
performed under this Agreement, but only to the extent caused by the negligent acts, errors or omissions
of the Contractor and except those injuries or damages arising out of the active negligence of City or its
agents, officers or employees. The City of Lodi may retain as much of the money due the Contractor as
shall be considered necessary until disposition has been made of such suits or claims for damages as
aforesaid.
5-413 Insurance Requirements for Contractor The Contractor shall provide proof of insurance to
be maintained during the life of this contract as listed under General Liability and Automobile Liability
coverage listed below. These insurance policies shall protect the Contractor and any subcontractor
performing work covered by this contract from claims for damages for personal injury, including
accidental death, as well as from claims for property damages, which may arise from Contractor's
operations under this contract, whether such operations be by Contractor or by any subcontractor or by
anyone directly or indirectly employed by either of them, and the amount of such insurance shall be as
follows:
COMMERCIAL GENERAL LIABILITY
Per Occurrence
$1,000,000 Property Damage
Personal & Adv Injury
$2,000,000 General Aggregate
2. COMPREHENSIVE AUTOMOBILE LIABILITY
$1,000,000 Combined Single Limits
NOTE: Contractor agrees and stipulates that any insurance coverage provided to the City of Lodi shall
provide for a claims period following termination of coverage which is at least consistent with the claims
period or statutes of limitations found in the California Tort Claims Act (California Government Code
Section§ 810 et seq.).
A copy of the certificate of insurance with the following endorsements shall be furnished to the City of
Lodi:
(a) Additional Named Insured Endorsement with Primary Wording
Such insurance as is afforded by this policy shall also apply to the City of Lodi, its elected and
appointed Boards, Commissions, Officers, Agents and Employees as additional named insured,
insofar as work performed by the insured under written contract with the City of Lodi.
(This endorsement shall be on a form furnished to the City of Lodi and shall be included with
Contractor's policies.)
Wording: Such insurance as is afforded by the endorsement for the Additional Insureds shall apply
as primary insurance. Any other insurance maintained by the City of Lodi or its officers and
employees shall be excess only and not contributing with the insurance afforded by this
endorsement.
(c) Severability of Interest Clause
The term "insured" is used severally and not collectively, but the inclusion herein of more than one
insured shall not operate to increase the limit of the company's liability.
(d) Notice of Cancellation or Change in Coverage Endorsement
This policy may not be canceled nor the coverage reduced by the company without 30 days' prior
written notice of such cancellation or reduction in coverage to the City Attorney, City of Lodi, P.O.
Box 3006, Lodi, CA 95241.
(e) Contractor agrees and stipulates that any insurance coverage provided to the City of Lodi shall
provide for a claims period following termination of coverage which is at least consistent with the
claims period or statutes of limitations found in the California Tort Claims Act (California
Government Code Section 810 et seq.).
"Claims made" coverage requiring the insureds to give notice of any potential liability during a time
period shorter than that found in the Tort Claims Act shall be unacceptable.
5-414 Workers' Compensation Insurance The Contractor shall provide proof of and maintain
during the life of this contract, Worker's Compensation Insurance for all Contractor's employees
employed at the site of the project and, if any work is Subcontracted, Contractor shall require the
subcontractor similarly to provide Worker's Compensation Insurance for all of the latter's employees
unless such employees are covered by the protection afforded by the Contractor. In case any class of
employees engaged in hazardous work under this contract at the site of the project is not protected under
the Worker's Compensation Statute, the Contractor shall provide and shall cause each subcontractor to
provide insurance for the protection of said employees. This policy may not be canceled nor the
coverage reduced by the company without 30 days' prior written notice of such cancellation or reduction
in coverage to the City Attorney, City of Lodi, P.O. Box 3006, Lodi, CA 95241.
ADDITIONAL TERMS AND CONDITIONS
1. The successful proposer will schedule within 15 days from receipt of 'Notice to Proceed' a
coordination meeting between the successful proposer and the City of Lodi to start the project.
Meeting will be held at the E&O Conference Room, 1331 S. Ham Lane, Lodi, CA 95242. Time
and duration of meeting will be established coordinated by the successful proposer.
2. Consultant shall indemnify and save harmless the City of Lodi, the City Council, elected and
appointed Boards, Commissions, all officers and employees or agents from any suits, claims or
actions brought by any person or persons for or on account of any injuries or damages sustained
or arising from the services performed under this Agreement, but only to the extent caused by the
negligent acts, errors or omissions of the Consultant and except those injuries or damages
arising out of the active negligence of City or its agents, officers or employees.
3. All information, data, diagrams, schematics, equipment and device settings and ratings,
object/programming codes, maps, operational/engineering parameters, guidelines and
procedures are proprietary to the City of Lodi and shall be kept strictly confidential and shall not
be shared and disclosed without any written authorization from the City of Lodi. All of these shall
be returned and/or submitted to the City of Lodi after the completion of this project.
4. If the new relay settings will result to nuisance trippings/outages and miscoordinated operation of
protective devices, the successful proposer shall be responsible in evaluating the events and
mitigate the issue/s in a timely and effective manner consistent with the power utility standards
and practices.
5. It is agreed that in the event of any litigation arising hereunder, the proposer at the request of the
City of Lodi shall submit to the jurisdiction of any court of competent jurisdiction within the County
of San Joaquin, State of California, and will comply with all, requirements necessary to give such
court jurisdiction, and that all matters arising hereunder shall be determined in accordance with
the law and practice of such court. It is further agreed that service of process in any such
litigation may be made in the manner provided for in said code for service upon a person outside
of the State of California.
-now
NINON
- ON
W
PREPARED FOR:
City of Lodi Electric Utility Department
0 0 Fff ffo- TWO- W, RM I V =1 I
Mind Powered: Insight with Impact.
it
PREPARED FOR:
City of Lodi Electric Utility Department
0 0 Fff ffo- TWO- W, RM I V =1 I
Mind Powered: Insight with Impact.
a
December 10,2008
Demetrio S, Bucaneg, Jr., P.E.
Assistant Electric Utility Director
City of Lodi Electric Utility Department
1331 S. Ham Lane
Lodi, CA 9522-3995
Subject: RFP for Power System Studies on Existing 12 kV Electric Distribution Systems, Four
Substations, and 60 kV Transmission Lines
Dear Mr. Bucaneg:
The City of Lodi Electric Utility Department (City) has identified the need to complete selected Power
Systems Studies (Studies) for its existing electric facilities to evaluate system performance and improve
reliability. The City has requested engineering services to provide a comprehensive evaluation of the
following items:
■ The existing facilities' capacity to serve the significant growth seen since 2001
■ The number of nuisance trips and mis-coordination of system protective devices, which has resulted
in prolonged outages
■ The effectiveness of the existing distribution line capacitors to provide the required VAR correction
R. W. Beck has prepared this proposal based on our understanding gained through previous discussions,
as well as the City's Request for Proposals. We are qualified on all issues related to the proposed Studies,
and as a result are intimately familiar with the operation and planning issues that are unique to the City.
Our proposed team offers an approach to provide the requested Power System Studies, so that we can
effectively operate as a productive extension of your staff to efficiently complete. the proposed tasks
without burdening the City staff. As part of this project, our team will:
■ Develop engineering models of the transmission and distribution systems using software from
ASPEN Inc. and Mil soft Utility Solutions, Inc.
■ Evaluate system performance under normal and N-1 contingencies at peak loading conditions
■ Prepare a protective device coordination study for the transmission and distribution systems,
including: fault current calculations and the evaluation of device capabilities, establishing device
setting and application standards, and updating the City's device library
■ Evaluate existing capacitorplacement and recommend adjustments to enhance overall effectiveness
a Propose locations for fault indicators to improve outage response and restoration times
■ Provide copies of reports, data, figures, attachments, and models in electronic CD and/or DVD format
to the City at the conclusion of the Studies
131 Mir Parkway, Suite 300 Hendersonville, TN 37075 Phone (615)431-3200 Fax (615) 824-7570
Mr. Bucaneg
December 10,2008
Page 2
Based in R. W. Beck's Pasadena, California, office, Project Manager John Bakken will be responsible for
primary communication between the City and the R. W. Beck team, and is available to respond to any
inquiry in a timely fashion. Should you have questions regarding our proposal, please contact
Mr. Bakken at (206) 695-4784 and jbakken c&rwbeck.com or Steve Rupp at (916) 614-8246 and
sruoD n,rwbeck.com. We look forward to the opportunity to assist the City of Lodi Electric Utility
Department with this important project.
Sincerely,
R. W. BECK, INC.
John Bakken
Project Manager
4W //4� a --
Steve Rupp
Client Liaison
SECTION 1
SERVICEAPPROACH NARRATIVE
R. W. Beck will apply a team approach and work closely with the City of Lodi, Electric Utility
Department (City) staff to develop the requested Power System Studies (Studies). This section defines
the project goals and deliverable products proposed by R. W. Beck to meet the stated needs of the City.
Also provided is our approach, which is based on the lessons learned by our project team providing
similar services for similar -sized utilities. This experience -based approach provides the City a
comprehensive project that can be relied upon by the City for making critical decisions regarding the
performance and capability of the City's power system.
Project Goals
The following goals are to be achieved in the development of the Studies. R. W Beck will:
■ Develop engineering models to analyze the performance and capability of the transmission and
distribution systems
■ Identify existing system deficiencies, including equipment loading, phase -imbalance, electrical
losses, voltage -drop, power factor correction, conductor loading, and reliability
■ Prepare a short circuit and protective device coordination study of the existing system to address
nuisance and simultaneous device tripping issues to improve system sectionalizing, reliability, and
coordination of protective devices
■ Evaluate the effectiveness of the existing line capacitors, and recommend changes to reduce system
losses and improve the overall effectiveness of the VAR correction
■ Recommend strategic locations for fault indicators to reduce outage troubleshooting effort and
improve outage restoration times
■ Prepare a formal report summarizing the criteria and assumptions, results of analyses, findings, and
recommendations
Deliverables
R. W. Beck will provide the following to the City to assist in continuing in-house planning studies.
■ Engineering model of transmission system in ASPEN (software not included)
• Engineering model of distribution system in Milsoft Utility Solutions, Inc,'s Windmil software
(software not included)
• Three copies of the Power System Studies document and electronic copies of supporting information
including engineering model data
Scope of Services
The project approach is developed based on a work breakdown structure that establishes tasks and their
associated work products. The proposed approach envisions the following detailed tasks for the
preparation of the Power System Studies for the City. Upon receipt of authorization from the City,
R. W. Beck will complete the tasks proposed herein.
SECTION 1
Task 1: Data Collection
In order to prepare for the Kick-off Meeting and accomplish the development of the Studies, the City
will provide R. W. Beck copies of relevant data pertaining to the Electric System, including:
■ Electronic copies of circuit diagrams showing line conductors and sizes; phasing; distribution
transformer, regulator, and capacitor locations and specifications; and protection device locations and
types
■ To the extent the circuit diagrams are not up to date or do not contain the required data, the City and
R. W, Beck will develop an approach to obtain the data from the field; if the agreed approach requires
resources from R. W. Beck, the City and R. W, Beck will agree on the scope and cost of this
additional task and it will be performed as Additional Services
■ Copies of circuit diagrams and feeder maps, marked to show the location of existing large power and
special load customers
■ Historical billing for existing large power and special load customers for the last 12 months,
including kW and WAR loads
• Results of any recent field investigations concerning voltage, current and phase balance, and
information on power factor of the system and distinct areas of the system
• Historical hourly metering for the power delivery point(s) for the most recent 12 months, including
kW and WAR peak loads
■ Historical peak load data for the substation power transformers and breakers, including kW and
WAR loads
■ Substation configuration of transformers and circuit breakers with capacity ratings
■ Information on available fault current from the interconnection with PG&E
■ Information related to size, type, and settings of system protective devices
■ Existing overcurrent protection philosophy and sectionalizing goals
■ Any other pertinent data related to the services to be performed by R. W. Beck
Task 2: Kick-off Meeting (Meeting No. 1)
R. W Beck will meet on-site with the City to conduct a one -day meeting to discuss the following items
related to the Studies:
■ Basic design guidelines
■ Existing overcurrent protection philosophy and sectionalizing goals
■ System single -contingency reliability criteria
Preparation of the engineering models for the 60 kV transmission and 12 kV distribution systems
■ Substation and feeder load allocation
■ City and R. W Beck responsibilities and project schedule
Following the Kick-off Meeting, R. W. Beck will review the data received for adequacy and request any
additional data needed to effectively execute the Studies.
SERVICE APPROACH NARRATIVE
Task 3: Preparation of Transmission and Distribution System Models
R. W. Beck will prepare computer engineering models of the 60 kV transmission and 12 kV distribution
systems for load flow, contingency analysis, protective device coordination, and the evaluation of VAR
correction. The transmission model will be developed in OneLiner and Power Flow by ASPEN, Inc.,
and the distribution model in WindmilB from Milsoft Utility Solutions, Inc. ASPEN Oneliner and
Power Flow were selected to develop the transmission model based on its reputable performance for high
voltage, network system analysis. Windmil® also offers robust analysis tools, but is more focused on
detailed analysis for radial distribution systems.
The engineering models will consist of a series of sections representing the transmission and distribution
backbone and taps for each circuit, and the location of electric equipment such as transformers, capaci-
tors, regulators, switches, fuses, and reclosers. All circuit elements and connectivity will be based on the
existing circuit diagrams and any additional information provided by the City. The existing circuit can
be delivered in any of the following electronic formats.
■ ArcView Shape (shp)
' AutoCAD DWG (.dwg)
■ AutoCAD DXF (.dxf)
■ MicroStation DGN (Agn)
■ TIFF (.tif)
■ JPG (.Jpg)
■ Windows Bitmap (.bmp)
For the distribution system model, the circuit diagrams provided by the City will be used as a
background in the engineering model. As a result, the engineering model will be digitized on top of the
circuit diagrams, and resemble the distribution system geographically. A transformer element will be
included in the model for load allocation purposes and fault current calculations.
Note: R. W. Beck can negotiate the purchase cf the Windmil@ software ficin Milsoft Utility Solutions,
Inc on the City'sbehalf;however,, the cost cf the software is not included in theproject budget.
Task 4: Review New Transmission and Distribution Models On -Site (Meeting No. 2)
After the new engineering models of the 60 kV transmission and 12 kV distribution systems are
developed, R. W. Beck will review the primary conductor, phasing, and circuit connectivity on-site with
the City staff. Updates to the engineering model will be made based on the City staffs knowledge of the
electric system.
In addition, R. W. Beck will allocate the latest peak load to the models on-site with the City staff and
analytically test their performance. Load allocation for the distribution system model will be based on
the distribution transformer size (kVA) indicated on the existing circuit diagrams.
Task 5: Analysis of Existing Transmission and Distribution Systems
G� R W. Beck will prepare the load -flow and voltage -drop analysis results to analyze the existing electric
transmission and distribution systems' ability to serve the existing peak loads based on the following
criteria.
■ System Capacity Relative to Existing Load — The existing system shall be analyzed to evaluate
how well it is meeting current requirements. R. W. Beck will analyze existing bulk power delivery
point(s) and distribution substations to identify facilities with insufficient capacity to serve the
existing peak load. The purpose of these various analyses shall be to identify areas where immediate
or significant system improvements may be necessary.
R. W. Beck, Inc.
SECTION 1
■ System Performance — A number of factors will be used in evaluating system performance.
Computer load flows, along with voltage, current and power factor measurements, will be utilized to
identify particular issues related to the existing system's performance. Available metering and billing
information will also be evaluated relative to the wholesale reactive billing policy and any existing
system problems.
■ Reliability — The existing system will be reviewed considering normal (N-0) and single contingency
(N-1) configurations for peak loading conditions. Single contingency (N-1) is defined as the ability
to maintain adequate service with the loss of a single transmission line or substation transformer.
Upon completing the existing system analysis, R. W, Beck will summarize the findings and provide the
draft for review by the City.
Task 6: Short Circuit and Coordination Study
R. W. Beck will perform a protective device coordination study of the existing 60 kV transmission and
12kV distribution systems based on the following.
. Review the City's existing overcurrent protection philosophy and the existing coordination issues
discussed at the Kick-off Meeting
■ Revise the existing overcurrent protection philosophy to meet sectionalizing goals and apply the
revised scheme to the system models
■ Utilize the new models of City's transmission and distribution systems to analytically test the revised
protection scheme as follows.
R Prepare load flow and fault current analysis using the new system models
■ Review transmission, substation, and distribution system protective device interruption ratings
compared to available fault current
Coordinate substation breaker relays with transmission overcurrent relays
■ Coordinate feeder lateral fuses and reclosers with substation breaker relays
■ Coordinate feeder lateral fuses with line reclosers
• Review standard fuse sizes and characteristics for distribution transformers based on
manufacturer's recommendations
■ Make determination of locations where additional sectionalizing devices would be advantageous
■ Adjust the overcurrent protection scheme to meet sectionalizing goals, if necessary
■ Prepare a draft report with results of the protective device coordination study, which will include:
■ Summary of the overcurrent protection philosophy and standardized scheme
Summary of data used in the study
The available three-phase and line -to -ground fault currents at each transmission, substation, and
distribution protective device
Summary comparison of maximum available fault current at each device compared to interruption
capability
Tpical time -current curves to depict the standardized coordination scheme
14
SERVICE APPROACH NARRATIVE
■ Setting summary sheets showing relay data and settings
■ Settings for three-phase line reclosers
■ Summary of line reclosers and fuses in recommended scheme
Based on comments by the City, the draft report will be modified as necessary for delivery to the City
with the Studies report.
Task 7: Capacitor Assessment
R. W. Beck will evaluate the existing capacitor placement on the distribution system based on the City's
operating and planning criteria and reactive demand contract for power supply policy. The capacitor
assessment will be prepared as follows.
■ Review the most recent hourly power supply metering for the most recent 12 months to determine the
maximum and minimum system demand and VAR requirements
■ Evaluate the effectiveness of the existing line capacitors at the maximum and minimum system loads
using the distribution model created in Task 3
■ Recommend additional line capacitors, or the relocation of existing capacitors, to reduce system
losses and improve the overall effectiveness of the VAR correction
■ Recommend fixed and switched capacitor banks and locations based on maximum and minimum load
requirements
■ Prepare a report summarizing the capacitor assessment
Task 8: Fault Indicator Placement
This task will develop a plan for City staff to implement the installation of fault locating devices on the
electric distribution system. The plan will be comprised of identifying a methodology to optimize the
installation of fault indicators. The goal of the fault indicator recommendations will be the reduction of
time required to locate outages, isolating the outage, and restoring electric service.
■ Identify existing protective device equipment on the electric distribution systems
■ Select the types of fault indicators for overhead and underground type construction
■ Work with City staff to develop methodology for determining the areas to target for installing fault
indicators and for determining the types of equipment that necessitate fault recorders, such as circuits
exceeding the frequency and duration reliability standards, the number of customer down line of the
fault indicators and recorders, and load flowing in the circuit
Task 9: Draft Power System Studies Draft Report and Review (Meeting No. 3)
The Studies report will be prepared and R. W. Beck will meet at the City's office to jointly review the
document. The Report will include the following:
■ Executive Summary
■ Operating Criteria and Assumptions
Analysis of Existing System
■ System Coordination Study
R. W. Beck, Inc.
SECTION 1
■ Capacitor Placement
■ Fault Indicator Placement
■ Appendices as required (which at minimum would include):
. Load flow, voltage drop, and fault current results
Typical time -current curves to depict the coordination
Setting summary sheets showing relay data and settings
Settings for three-phase line reclosers
Circuit maps including recommendations for capacitors and fault indicators
Task 10: Preparation of Final Report
After the review of the Studies report, R. W. Beck will revise as necessary to develop the final document.
R. W. Beck will provide the City's staff with three copies of the draft and final Report. Electronic files
will be provided on a CD.
Task 11: Power System Studies Presentation
R. W. Beck will develop a presentation of the Studies with the City's staff for delivery to City members
and Council .
Additional Services by R. W. Beck
R. W. Beck shall provide additional services as requested by the City. R. W. Beck will prepare a scope
and the estimated cost of such services. Additional services may include, but are not limited to:
■ Conduct additional requested meetings
■ Prepare additional copies of the report
■ Train on engineering analysis software
■ Develop a Load Forecast
■ Evaluate system performance and capacitor requirements for future loads
■ Establish performance goals and benchmark reliability indices, such as SAIDI, SAIFI, and MAIFI, to
measure the future performance of the electric system with the implementation of the recommended
fault indicators
■ Establish pilot project to measure the future performance of the electric system with the
implementation of the recommended fault indicators
■ Determine methodology for connection of fault recorders to the City's SCADA system
■ Develop Capital Improvements Program (CIP)
■ Conduct economic evaluation of expansion alternatives
■ Provide ongoing maintenance and updating of system models
1-6
K
SERVICE APPROACH NARRATIVE
Services and Items to be Furnished by the City
The City will:
■ Assist by making readily available, when requested, all existing records and data pertinent to the
project
■ Provide other pertinent data and information needed
• Provide a timely review of deliverables (draft and final)
• Remain available for scheduled meetings and on-site work
R. W. Beck. Inc
M
Z2
0
0
SECTION 2
PROJECTTEAM
At R. W, Beck, we emphasize a team approach to successful project execution, and choose our project
teams to provide the maximum benefits and experience levels for our clients. Close communication and
coordination among the various team members make this an efficient and cost-effective approach. We
are committed to being responsive to the City's needs, managing our work to accomplish results in an
efficient and timely manner.
Primary contact with the City and overall responsibility for making sure the Studies are executed in
accordance with your requirements will be assigned to John Bakken, the Project Manager. Our team
brings extensive experience in developing power system studies and the development of engineering
models for electric systems across the country. In addition, Robert Jenkins and meson Reed will
perform the system analysis and device coordination, and will assist in the development of transmission
and distribution system models, and Trishia Swayne will be responsible for modeling analysis related to
fault indicator placement. Steve Rupp will serve as Client Liaison, and Keith Mullen will provide
QA/QC assistance for the system studies.
R. W. Beck has constructed the project team with the expressed purpose of completing comprehensive
Power System Studies. Our deliberate and calculated approach to building our team has resulted in a
group that will provide the City with cutting-edge technical knowledge and practical market insights that
are at the forefront of the energy industry.
Keith Mullen, R E,
Project -
Tyson Reed
Thshia Swayne
John Bakken, P.E.
Steve Rupp
Robert Jenkins, P.E.
Terrie Pedigo
2-1
SECTION 2
Experienced Project Team
The City requires a qualified team to conduct Studies ofthe City's electric transmission and distribution
systems to evaluate system performance and recommend enhancements to improve reliability. The
professionals introduced in the table below assemble a knowledgeable team with specific expertise in
each of the elements of work necessaryto complete the comprehensive studies. We are committed to
applying our familiarity with Iwai conditions and experience with similar clients to offer efficient and
flexible solutions for the City.
The following table highlights each member's related expertise and qualifications. Professional resumes
are provided intheAppendix.
John Bakken, RE
28 years industry
* As a project manager, Mr. Bakken collaborates with clients on
Project Manager
experience
projects, coordinates project team activities, monitors project
• Project
scopes, budgets and schedules and oversees QA/QC activities
Management
P Hisexperience includes managing planning studies, concept
■ Planning Studies
development, permitting support, equipment selection, detail
design development, grounding system analyses and design,
■ Protective Relay
insulation coordination, protective relay applications, relay setting
Applications
calculations, shop drawing reviews, construction support, and
* System Analysis
preparation of testing and checkout procedures
and Design
■ He brings engineering experience with high voltage and extra high
voltage substations, including 5F6gas-insulated stations, and has
sewed a; design engineer, lead electrical engineer, and project
managerfor numerous substation projects
■ He routinely carries out independent engineering reviews of
electric utilitysystems, including condition assessment and
operation and maintenance practices, in support of financingor
sate of assets
Steve Rupp
25+ years industry
■ Mr. Rupp leads large project teams i n the developmentof highly
Client Liaison
experience
complex electric system master plans that address issues such as
■ Management
addressing impacts of distributed generation on transmission and
Consulting
distribution systems; managing diverse stakeholder groups to
reach consensus on issues and strategies affecting the utility
■ Economics of
industry; and managing engineering design and construction of
Power Marketing
electric transmission and distribution system projects
Electric System
v He has developed power system plans for Investorand customer -
Master Plans
owned utilities, includingthe developmentof transmission system
plans and integrated resource plans
■ Mr. Rupp i s extensively experienced with power system analysis,
load forecasting, productioncost simulation, and security
constrained economic dispatch
2-2
PROJECTTEAM
KeitKMullen, PE. 1 16 years industry I ■ Mr. Mullen is actively engaged in the use of computer modeling to
QA/QC
experience
ummary of QualificationIlMs
ember/Role
Project
experienced with the application of a variety of engineering
Transmssion
Management
KeitKMullen, PE. 1 16 years industry I ■ Mr. Mullen is actively engaged in the use of computer modeling to
QA/QC
experience
address utility operations and system expansion issues- He is
PE
Project
experienced with the application of a variety of engineering
Transmssion
Management
analysis software packages related to electrical transmission and
System Modeling
and Control
distribution systems, and is also involved with the developmentof
and Coordination
Engineering
engineering analysis software as an elected member of a user
Analysis
advisory board
Electric Utility
He applies engineering models and uses various programs to
Design and
develop solutions that address system expansion plans to serve
System Planning
projected growth, alleviate day-to-day operating problems, .....
Load/Customer
coordination issues
Forecasting
Mr. Mullen supervises staff engineers and mapping technicians
involvedwith developing engineering models and database
applications- In this role, he has gained knowledgeof interfacing
various mapping software packages to engineering analysis
acka es
Robert Jenkins,
15years industry
■ Mr. Jenkins creates one -line, three -line, and elementary diagrams,
PE
expertise
bills of material and relay panel elevation drawings, as well as
Transmssion
■ Relay Protection
conduit plans, circuit lists, connection diagrams, and substation
System Modeling
and Control
grounding plans for all types of systems
and Coordination
Systems
■ He develops short circuit studies and relay coordination studies, as
■ Contract
well as relay settings and configuration files and is proficient at
Document Review
control system testing and troubleshooting
and Preparation
a Mr. Jenkins prepares substation cost estimates for procurement
■ Substation Cost
and construction of substation and distribution projects to ensure
Estimates and
compliance with company and industry standards
Design
Trishia Swayne
4 years industry
■ Ms, Swayne provides assistance in electric utility design and
Project Engineer
experience
system planning
■ Electric Utility
a She analyzes electrical transmission and distribution systems
Planningand
through use ofMilsoft's Utility Solutions software, WindMil,
Assessment
Advantica's SynerGEE Electric Software, and CYMDIST Distribution
■ System Planning
System Analysis Software
Guides
■ As a project engineer, she aides in developing RUS-approved
■ MasterPlan
construction work plans, long-range planning guides, municipal
Development
long-range plans, device coordination studies, and loss studies for
uti I ity systems across the nation
R. W, Beck, Inc. 2.
SECTION 2
Availability of ProjectTeam
With approximately 600 professionals nationwide, R. W. Beck is able to seamlessly account for
workload variations and efficiently staff each project according to tailored needs. The individuals
introduced above have availability to assist the City with the project tasks outlined in Section 1 of this
proposal.
2-4
QualificationsTeam
of
Member/Role.-
Relevant
Tyson Reed
3 years industry
■ Mr. Reed brings experience in protective device coordination, arc -
Distribution System
experience
flash studies, and distribution planning
Modeling and
■ Power System
■ He optimizes protection schemes, develops and refines electric
Coordination
Modeling
distribution system models, and performs engineering analysis on
■ Protective Device
various platforms
Coordination
■ Electric Arc -Flash
Studies
Terrie Pedigo
20+ years industry
■ Based on information from field inventoryand GIS mapping
,Model
experience
systems, she develops engineering models and extracts results
Development
E Database Design
from the models for report documents and client use
■ GIs Systems for
' Ms. Pedigo assists the T&D design teams by preparing plan and
Electric Utilities
profile drawings and staking sheets, develops construction unit
quantities, and verifies contractor requests for payment; she has
■ Drawing
also been active in one-on-one training with clients in the use of
Preparation
mapping software
* She i s an expert in database design and maintenance of GIs
systems for electric utilities with primary responsibilities including
drawing preparation and database development
Availability of ProjectTeam
With approximately 600 professionals nationwide, R. W. Beck is able to seamlessly account for
workload variations and efficiently staff each project according to tailored needs. The individuals
introduced above have availability to assist the City with the project tasks outlined in Section 1 of this
proposal.
2-4
SECTION 3
QUALIFICATIONS
Included in the following matrix i s a listing of related project experience completed by our project team
for clients with similar issues to that of the City.
Client, Project, . •-Services/Responsibilities
Client: To address its faster -than -expected growth, the City of Vineland
City of Vineland, New Jersey requested R W. Bede to develop an Electric System Master Plan and
procedures for maintaining the plan internally. Our project team
Project: collaborated with the City staff to develop an engineering model of
Electric System Master Plan the existing distribution system using Windmile software, a 20 -year
forecast, the five-year CIP and a system coordination study.
Reference: Following the study, our team provided "hands-on" training for the
Mr. Harry Maloney, P.E. City's staff on the Windmil® modeling software, and explain its
Chief Engineer benefits for planning and daily operations. In addition, we provided a
415 N. West Avenue four-day workshop to key City staff to present planning study
Vineland, NJ 08360 methodologies and establish proceduresfor the City staff to maintain
the plan as system loads and requirements change.
Client:
Utilities Commission, New
Smyrna Beach, Florida
Project:
Electric System Transmission
and Distribution Planning Study
Reference:
Mr. Jim White, P.E.
Director of Engineering
200 Canal Street
New Smyrna Beach, FL 32168
Client:
Erwin Utilities, Tennessee
Project:
Five -Year System Planning
Studv
Reference:
Mr. Lee Brown
Manager
244 Love St,
Erwin, TN 37650
An Electric Transmission and Distribution Planning Study was
prepared for the Utilities Commission, City of NewSmyrna Beach
(UCNSB) by R W. Beck to meet the needs of UCNSB and its customers
for the next ten years. Our team met with UCNSB to develop
planning and operating criteria, create a computer model for system
analysis, and develop a ten-year plan to provide for upgrade and
expansion of the distribution.
In addition, our project team prepared continnencvanalysis, and
protective device coordination using Windmile from Milsoft Utility
Solutions, Inc., and performed a condition assessment of UCNSB's
existing peaking and backup electric power generating resources. The
assessment included a site visit by R W. Beck's personnel to review
pertinent generating plant operations and maintenance records and
conduct a walkthrough of the facilities.
As a result of our established relationship with Erwin Utilities',
R W. Bede provided a Five-YearSystem Plan that identified actions
to upgrade the overall quality of service to Erwin Utilities' members.
We proposed a plan to provide for an orderly upgrade and expansion
of the system, so that investment in the improvements and new
facilities would be i n step with growth i n load and revenue.
Team members were able to apply their extensive experience i n
developing and usingWindMil® models to analyze Erwin Utilities'
distribution system. This established model and staff training will
assist Erwin Utilities i n continuing in-house planning studies.
SECTION 3
Client:
City of Pasadena Water and
Power Department, California
Project:
Electric Distribution System
Master Plan
Reference:
Mr. Joe Awad
Director of Power Delivery
Engineeringand Construction
Management
100 North Garfield Avenue
P.O. Box 7120
Pasadena, CA 91109
(626) 7.444157
Client;
Madisonville Municipal Water
and Light, Kentucky
Project:
System Studies, Mapping, and
Modeling
Reference:
Mr. Jim Asbury
Superintendent
37 East Center Street
Madisonville, KY 42431-0704
(270) 824-2130
3-2
The City of Pasadena Water and Power (PWP) was facing challenges
due to its aging infrastructure, residential and commercial growth
requiring additional and reliable capacity, and a lack of
organizational preparedness to address the next 20 years. These
factors led to the need for the rapid acceleration of their Electric
Distribution System Master Plan (EDSMP) implementation. Most
importantly, PWP needed to develop its sustainable, organic capacity
to implement the EDSMP over its 20 year horizon.
R W. Beck analyzed performance objectives through the year 2020
with the objective of achieving adequate system capacity to meet
service demand; maintaining service reliability; and maximizing
resources and business opportunities. This was achieved by
completing an analysis of solutions and developing a plan that
combined the solutions into a logical and progressive guide for
making decisions over the next two decades. The team completed
engineering studies to define infrastructure replacement plans,
determined delivery of advanced technology solutions to increase the
effectivenessof engineering, provided on-site project management
and comprehensive engineering support, implemented enterprise
project managementand work management systems, and provided
project management training for the City.
Madisonville Municipal Water and Light collaborated with R W. Beck
to update their system map and model to prepare a Five -Year System
Plan. Our team performed the following tasks for Madisonville
MunicipalWater and Light: update system maps based on the latest
changes to the electric facilities; update the existing coordination
study to solve system issues such as nuisance tripping and fuse mis-
coordination; and develop a load forecast and Five-YearSystem Plan.
In addition, our project team converted the existing electronic maps
into an AutoCAD Map system to take advantage of the AM/FM
functionality, and provided several hours of specialized on-site
AutoCAD training. As a result, Madisonville personnel were able to
produce system operating maps and truck maps for internal use.
Client:
Grayson Rural Electric
Cooperative, Kentucky
Project:
System Planning and Modeling
Reference:
Mn. Carol Fraley
President and CEO
109 Bagby Park
Grayson, KY 41143
(606) 474-5136
Client:
Princeton Electric Plant Board,
Kentucky
Project:
Five -Year System Plan
Reference:
Mr. John Humphries
Manager
304 East Legion Drive
Princeton, KY 42445
(270) 365-2031
R. W. Beck, Inc.
QUALIFICATIONS
Throughout our partnership for more than 14 years, Grayson Rural
Electric Cooperative (GRECC) has partnered with R W. Beck to
provide system planning reports including both long range plans and
construction work plans. Milsoft's WindMil® load flow software is
used for the system analysis at existing and projected loads.
Recommended improvements have included new substations,
feeders, and regulatorsas well as conductor upgrades.
In addition to the updated system planning reports, R. W. Beck
recently completed a Global Information System (GIS) project where
GRECC's old paper maps were converted to electronic format. We
also digitized a detailed model that is tied to other information
systems within the utility. This flagship project for the utility
provides a foundation for the future expansion of their GIS system.
GRECC is currently using the information utility -wide for more
efficient operations.
Over a number of years, Princeton Electric Plant Board (PEPB) has
requested several Five -Year Plans be prepared by RW Beck to
identify the capital improvements needed to serve projected growth.
Recently, the Five -Year Plan included the evaluation of a new
interconnection and the integration of the proposed diesel peaking
plant on its distribution system by our team. The Five -Year Plan
provided PEPBwith budget projections to be included i n the
municipal bond issue the followin6 spring.
R W. Beck applied a team approach to working closely with the PEPB
staff to develop the Five -Year Plan that met not only the needs of
PEPB, but also the needs of i is customers. Through our engineering
analysis, we developed an engineering model of distribution system
developed usingMilsoft Utility Solutions, Inc.'s Windmil® software,
along with substation and feeder load forecast spreadsheet
templates. We provided PEPB with a System Plan document that
included assumptions, analyses, and a five-year construction plan,
and an existing system Capacitor Placement Study. Included i n the
Plan were cost estimates for the five-year capital requirements to
achieve the construction plan.
SECTION 4
SUBMITTALSAND REPORT
R. W. Beck will submit three hardcopies of the Studies Report to the City, including draft and final
reports, in accordance with the City's request. The Report will be prepared in Microsoft Word and
include the following:
Executive Summary
Operating Criteria and Assumptions
Analysis of Existing System
System Coordination Study
Capacitor Placement
Fault Indicator Placement
Appendices as required (which at minimum would include):
UL PDF copies load flow, voltage drop, and fault current results
PDF copies of typical time -current curves to depict the coordination
It Setting summary sheets in Excel showing relay data and settings
Settings summary sheets in Excel for three-phase line reclosers
Circuit maps in ,AutoCAD or ESRI including recommendations for capacitors and fault indicators
An electronic copy of the final report, circuit diagrams, spreadsheet templates, and engineering model
database files will be provided to the City on a CD or a DVD.
4-1
SECTION 5
PROPOSALAND PROJECT
SCHEDULE
Included in the following table is a proj ect schedule outlining the tasks the proj ect team will complete for
the City in completing the comprehensive Studies. Specific services have been broken down into Tasks
One through Ten, as outlined in the City's Request for Proposal.
DevelopTransmission 1 213 It4
and DistributionModels$22,000
Perform Short
Cirr_uif ShirILom 1. 2 6t 6 $2,000
Evaluate Protective
Device Coordination
R. W. Beck will provide the Scope of Services included in Section 1 of this proposal for a fixed fee of
Ninety -Five Thousand Eight -Hundred Dollars ($95,800). as detailed above. This amount is inclusive of
labor, materials, and all other associated expenses and travel. This proposal will remain valid for 90 days
from December 10,2008.
Page 1 of 1
Demy Bucaneg (Lodi EUD)
From: Rupp, Steven [SRupp@rwbeck.com1
Sent: Monday, March 16,200910:47 AM
To: Demy Bucaneg (Lodi EUD); Weldat Haile (Lodi EUD)
cc: Mullen, Keith
Subject: Proposal for Power System Analysis
Attachments: City of Lodi (CA) Power Systems Studies Proposal 1208.pd€
Messrs. Bucaneg and Haile:
This email serves as notification that the pricing in our December 8, 2008 proposal to provide a
power system study will remain in effect until June 1,2009. Please let me know if you have
questions regarding this. We look forward to working with you.
Best regards,
Steve
Steven S. Rupp
Vice President
Office 916.614.8246 Cell 916.390.0432
2720 Gateway Oaks Drive, Suite 310 Sacramento, C4 95833
Mind Powered: Insight with Impact.
rwbea,com
This communicafionand any related verbal communication are pmvided under the forms of R. W. Beck's contrecf wifhits clienf, and are not intended
to be used orrelied upon by any Mird pariy other than advisors or consultants to Me client. Any use of such communicafionby any other third party is
fhe responsibility of such third pariy, and R. W. Beck accepts no responsibility for any damages incurred by any fhird party as a result of decisions or
actions based on such communication. Any guidance or opinionsprovidedherein should only be read and relied upon by client within the limitations
and context of any prior guidance provided by R. VW. Beck in any prior workproducts relating to the subjectmatter of such communication.
03/23/2009
RESOLUTION NO. 200940
A RESOLUTION OF THE LODI CITY COUNCIL AWARDING
CONTRACTTO SOLE BIDDER, R.W. BECK, INC. TO
PERFORM POWER SYSTEMS STUDY
------------------------
WHEREAS, in answer to notice duly published in accordance with law and the
order of this City Council, sealed bids were received and publicly opened on December
10, 2008, at 11:00 a.m., for the power system studies on the existing 12kV electric
distribution system, four substations, and 60kV transmission lines as described in the
specifications therefore approved by the City Council on August 6, 2008; and
WHEREAS, said bids have been compared, checked, and tabulated and a report
thereof filed with the City Manager as follows:
MILSOFT Utility Solution, Abilene, TX
No bid
R.W. Beck, Sacramento, CA
$95,800.00
EET INC., Citrus Heights, CA
No bid
Auriga Corporation, Milpitas, CA
No bid
Stantec Consulting, Inc., Walnut Creek, CA
No bid
Source One, Inc., Boston TX
No bid
WHEREAS, staff reviewed the sole bid price and found it to be reasonable
based on past experience.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Lodi City Council does hereby
approve the award of professional services contract to R. W. Beck, Inc., of Sacramento,
CA, the sole bidder, to perform power systems studies on the existing 12kV electric
distribution system, four substations, and 60kV transmission lines in the amount not to
exceed $95.800.
Dated: April 15, 2009
hereby certify that Resolution No. 2009-40 was passed and adopted by the City
Council of the City of Lodi in a regular meeting held April 15, 2009, by the following vote:
AYES: COUNCIL MEMBERS — Hitchcock, Johnson, Katzakian, and
Mayor Hansen
NOES: COUNCIL MEMBERS — None
ABSENT: COUNCIL MEMBERS— Mounce
ABSTAIN: COUNCIL MEMBERS — None
OHL
City Clerk
2009-40